Smith v. Doe
Citations
- 538 U.S. 84
- 123 S. Ct. 1140
- 155 L. Ed. 2d 164
- 2003 U.S. LEXIS 1949
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
2003 United States Supreme Court case
Smith v. Doe, 538 U.S. 84 (2003), was a court case in the United States which questioned the constitutionality of the Alaska Sex Offender Registration Act's retroactive requirements. Under the Act, any sex offender must register with the Department of Corrections or local law enforcement within one business day of entering the state. This information is forwarded to the Department of Public Safety, which maintains a public database. Fingerprints , social security number , anticipated change of address, and medical treatment after the offense are kept confidential. The offender's name, aliases , address , photograph , physical description, driver's license number, motor vehicle identification numbers , place of employment , date of birth, crime , date and place of conviction , and length and conditions of sentence are part of the public record , maintained on the Internet .
Smith v. Doe questioned the constitutionality of the act's retroactive requirements. John Does I and II were convicted of aggravated assault before the act's passage and filed suit, claiming the act was punitive and violated the _ex post facto _ clause of Article I of the U.S. Constitution . The district court ruled against the Does, ruling that the act was nonpunitive. The appeals court sided with the Does that the act was in fact punitive and violated ex post facto.
Supreme Court's ruling
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Smith_v._Doe&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Supreme Court's ruling")
]
Held: Because the Alaska Sex Offender Registration Act is nonpunitive, its retroactive application does not violate the ex post facto clause.
The question is if the intention was to impose a punishment or "civil proceedings". If the intention was to punish, that ends the inquiry. If the intention was to enact a regulatory scheme that is civil and nonpunitive, the Court must examine whether the scheme is so punitive as to negate the State's intention to deem it civil. Because the Court ordinarily defers to the legislature 's stated intent, only the clearest proof will suffice to override that intent and transform what has been denominated a civil remedy into a criminal penalty. The Court decided 6–3 that the legislature's intent was to create a civil, nonpunitive program to protect the public and that the resulting dissemination of the registration information was not significant enough to declare as debilitating.
The dissenting justices contended that the law was punitive and imposed severe deprivations of liberty. Justice Stevens' dissenting opinion said, "It is also clear beyond peradventure that these unique consequences of conviction of a sex offense are punitive. They share three characteristics, which in the aggregate are not present in any civil sanction. The sanctions (1) constitute a severe deprivation of the offender's liberty, (2) are imposed on everyone who is convicted of a relevant criminal offense, and (3) are imposed only on those criminals. Unlike any of the cases that the Court has cited, a criminal conviction under these statutes provides both a sufficient and a necessary condition for the sanction".
See also
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Smith_v._Doe&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: See also")
]
External links
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Smith_v._Doe&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: External links")
]
- Text of Smith v. Doe, 538 U.S. 84 (2003) is available from: Cornell Findlaw Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Library of Congress Oyez (oral argument audio)
show
U.S. Supreme Court Article I case law
show
Commerce Clause of Section VIII
show
Coinage Clause of Section VIII
show
Copyright Clause of Section VIII
show
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Smith_v._Doe&oldid=1351927099 "
Hidden categories:
Search
Search
Smith v. Doe
Add languages Add topic
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that Alaska Sex Offender Registration Act was civil even though a knowing failure to comply would subject the offender to criminal prosecution
- recognizing that Alaska's legislature \could conclude that a conviction for a sex offense provides evidence of substantial risk of recidivism\
- holding that the Alaska Sex Offender Registration Act did not violate the Ex Post Facto Clause
- holding that Alaska’s Sex Offender Registration Act did not violate the ex post facto clause
- holding that Alaska’s sex offender registration statute is not an invalid ex post facto law because it is civil and non-punitive
- holding that Alaska’s Sex Offender Registration Act is nonpunitive; thus, its retroactive application does not violate the Ex Post Facto Clause of the United States Constitution
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Kennedy, Rehnquist, O'Connor, Scalia, Thomas, Souter, Stevens, Ginsburg, Breyer
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
878 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. IreyEleventh Circuit· 2010-07-29· cited 1,965×
- In the Interest of A.V.Texas Supreme Court· 2003-07-03· cited 1,787×
- Lawrence v. TexasSupreme Court· 2003-06-26· cited 1,452×
- Commonwealth v. Muniz, J., Aplt.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-07-19· cited 899×
- People v. HarperColorado Court of Appeals· 2004-03-25· cited 514×
- State v. BodykeOhio Supreme Court· 2010-06-03· cited 413×
- State v. Dangler (Slip Opinion)Ohio Supreme Court· 2020-05-05· cited 408×
- State v. WilliamsOhio Supreme Court· 2011-07-13· cited 406×
- People v. BoscaMichigan Court of Appeals· 2015-03-26· cited 332×
- State v. BocheNebraska Supreme Court· 2016-10-07· cited 316×
- People v. McKeeCalifornia Supreme Court· 2010-01-28· cited 299×
- People v. StowellCalifornia Supreme Court· 2003-12-01· cited 275×
- Carr v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2010-06-01· cited 274×
- United States v. ComstockSupreme Court· 2010-05-17· cited 259×
- People v. Sprint Nextel Corp.New York Court of Appeals· 2015-10-20· cited 255×
- Demery v. ArpaioNinth Circuit· 2004-08-06· cited 247×
- United States v. Thomas Cameron KincadeNinth Circuit· 2004-08-18· cited 244×
- Adam Keith Waldman v. Alabama Prison CommissionerEleventh Circuit· 2017-09-26· cited 244×
- United States v. FarhaneSecond Circuit· 2011-02-04· cited 243×
- United States of America, State of California, Intervenor v. Raphyal Crawford, AKA Aarmyl CrawfordNinth Circuit· 2004-06-21· cited 239×
Cites
24 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. SalernoSupreme Court· 1987-05-26· cited 5,104×
- Meachum v. FanoSupreme Court· 1976-06-25· cited 3,743×
- Weaver v. GrahamSupreme Court· 1981-02-24· cited 2,482×
- Kennedy v. Mendoza-MartinezSupreme Court· 1963-02-18· cited 2,208×
- Griffin v. WisconsinSupreme Court· 1987-06-26· cited 2,149×
- Kansas v. HendricksSupreme Court· 1997-06-23· cited 2,057×
- Wisconsin v. ConstantineauSupreme Court· 1971-01-19· cited 1,666×
- Flemming v. NestorSupreme Court· 1960-06-20· cited 1,508×
- Hudson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1997-12-10· cited 1,410×
- United States v. UrserySupreme Court· 1996-06-24· cited 1,314×
- United States v. WardSupreme Court· 1980-08-22· cited 969×
- Johnson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2000-05-15· cited 941×
- McKune v. LileSupreme Court· 2002-06-10· cited 910×
- United States v. One Assortment of 89 FirearmsSupreme Court· 1984-02-22· cited 720×
- Allen v. IllinoisSupreme Court· 1986-07-01· cited 533×
- De Veau v. BraistedSupreme Court· 1960-06-06· cited 494×
- National Labor Relations Board v. Allis-Chalmers Manufacturing Co.Supreme Court· 1967-06-12· cited 474×
- Huddleston v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1974-03-26· cited 422×
- Hawker v. New YorkSupreme Court· 1898-04-18· cited 389×
- Nos. 96-5132, 96-5416Third Circuit· 1997-09-04· cited 301×
Other cases named Smith v. Doe
19 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Smith v. DoeCourt of Appeals of Georgia· 1988-10-24· cited 19×
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court of South Carolina· 2005-11-14· cited 9×
- Smith v. DoeCourt of Appeals of Georgia· 1985-10-10· cited 6×
- Smith v. DoeE.D. Louisiana· 1998-01-28· cited 6×
- Smith v. DoeLouisiana Court of Appeal· 1986-01-15· cited 5×
- Smith v. DoeCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1871-01-12· cited 5×
- Smith v. DoeRichmond County Circuit Court· 1988-05-18· cited 2×
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court· 2003-04-28· cited 2×
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court of Delaware· 2008-12-03· cited 1×
- Smith v. DoeCalifornia Supreme Court· 1860-07-01· cited 1×
- Smith v. DoeLouisiana Court of Appeal· 2001-04-11· cited 1×
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court· 2002-10-07
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court· 2002-11-01
- Smith v. DoeCourt of Appeals of South Carolina· 2003-12-15
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1999-11-19
- Smith v. DoeNew York Supreme Court· 1908-03-15
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court· 1989-07-03
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court· 1989-07-03
- Smith v. DoeSupreme Court· 2003-04-28
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.