Skip to main content

Smith v. Doe

Citations

  • 15 Cal. 100

Syllabus

<p>The averments of possession and ouster in this case, were held to he insufficiently denied. See statement of facts.</p> <p>In ejectment for mineral land, plaintiff averred possession of a large tract of land, including the mining ground in controversy, and that he occupied the land for agricultural and mining purposes, without stating that any use was made of the particular portion held by defendants. This averment of possession, and also the averment of ouster, were insufficiently denied in the answer; but the answer averred affirmatively, that, at the time defendants entered upon the ground in dispute, it was a part of the public domain of the United States, contained large and valuable deposits of gold, that they entered upon and took possession of it for mining purposes, and that they have since held and used it for such purposes only. The Court below gave judgment for plaintiff on the pleadings. Held, that these affirmative averments of defendants being proved, plaintiff could not recover without showing such an actual and meritorious possession and occupancy, as rendered the interference of the defendants unjust and inequitable ; that he could not recover on the pleadings, because the character of his possession did not appear, the complaint not averring that this particular portion of the land was ever used by plaintiff for any purpose whatever.</p> <p>The allegation of possession is too broad to defeat the rights of a person who has, in good faith, located upon public mineral land for the purpose of mining. When a party enters upon mineral land for the purpose of mining, he cannot be presumed to be a trespasser; for if the land be not private property, he has the right to enter upon it for that purpose; and, until it is shown that the title has passed from the government, the statutory presumption, (Wood’s Dig. 527) that it is public land, applies.</p> <p>Mere entry and possession give no right to the exclusive enjoyment of any given quantity of the publi

Judges: Cope

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

1 case in this archive cites this case.

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.