Sixth Circuit· 6/9/2003
Shields v. Reader's Digest Ass'n
Citations
- 331 F.3d 536
- 2003 WL 21305381
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that discretion was granted when the plan provided the admin- ABATIE v. ALTA HEALTH & LIFE INS. 9639 istrator had “complete control” over the administration of the Plan, and “the power to construe” the Plan and “determine all questions” that arise under it
- “When it is possible to offer a reasoned explanation, based on the evidence, for a particular outcome, that outcome is not arbitrary or capricious.”
- “When it is possible to offer a reasoned explanation, based on the evidence, for a particular outcome, that outcome is not arbitrary or capricious.”
- “[Because [the] [p]laintiff has not directly challenged the district court’s factual conclusions ... all factual controversies are deemed abandoned on appeal and the district court’s factual findings are hereby upheld.”
- “[B]ecause [the] [p]laintiff has not directly challenged the district court’s factual conclusions . . . all factual controversies are deemed abandoned on appeal and the district court’s factual findings are hereby upheld.”
- “[B]ecause the parties have asked us to resolve legal questions on appeal, any concessions or assumptions by the Defendants are of no consequence to our analysis.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Gwin, Rogers, Siler
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
22 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Northeast Ohio Coalition for the Homeless v. HustedSixth Circuit· 2016-09-13· cited 93×
- Karen McClain v. Eaton Corp. Disability PlanSixth Circuit· 2014-01-24· cited 77×
- DaimlerChrysler Corp. Healthcare Benefits Plan v. DurdenSixth Circuit· 2006-05-26· cited 75×
- Schwalm v. Guardian Life Insurance Co. of AmericaSixth Circuit· 2010-11-17· cited 72×
- United States v. Timothy MillerSixth Circuit· 2006-01-11· cited 13×
- White v. Standard InsuranceE.D. Michigan· 2012-02-09· cited 9×
- Abatie v. Alta Health & Life InsuranceNinth Circuit· 2006-08-14· cited 8×
- Nale v. FORD MOTOR CO. UAW RETIREMENT PLANE.D. Michigan· 2010-03-31· cited 7×
- O'Connor v. Provident Life & Accident Co.E.D. Michigan· 2006-09-25· cited 6×
- Derek Kramer v. Am. Electric Power Exec. Severance PlanSixth Circuit· 2025-02-10· cited 6×
- In Re Lager EstateMichigan Court of Appeals· 2009-11-03· cited 5×
- Shields v. Reader's Digest AssociationSixth Circuit· 2003-06-09· cited 3×
- Sanford v. Life InsuranceM.D. Tennessee· 2014-02-27· cited 3×
- Adams v. Anheuser-Busch Companies, Inc.S.D. Ohio· 2013-01-09· cited 3×
- Tikkanen v. Liberty Life Assurance Co.E.D. Michigan· 2014-07-14· cited 2×
- Carty v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co.M.D. Tennessee· 2016-12-15· cited 2×
- McCandless v. Standard InsuranceE.D. Michigan· 2011-02-15· cited 1×
- Kolpacke v. Csx Pension PlanE.D. Michigan· 2007-07-06· cited 1×
- Bauer v. Metropolitan Life InsuranceE.D. Michigan· 2005-10-25
- United States v. MillerSixth Circuit· 2006-01-11
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. BruchSupreme Court· 1989-02-21· cited 6,595×
- Boggs v. BoggsSupreme Court· 1997-06-02· cited 491×
- Connie M. Miller v. Metropolitan Life Insurance CompanySixth Circuit· 1991-02-15· cited 349×
- Benito T. PEREZ, Jr., Plaintiff-Appellant, v. AETNA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant-AppelleeSixth Circuit· 1998-07-01· cited 282×
- Pens. Plan Guide P 23922q Juanita Yeager v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance CompanySixth Circuit· 1996-07-08· cited 244×
- Bush v. Dictaphone Corp.Sixth Circuit· 1998-11-23· cited 216×
- Scott v. Dreamlite Holdings Ltd.Supreme Court· 1990-04-23· cited 109×
- Neistein v. Illinois Attorney Registration & Disciplinary CommissionSupreme Court· 1990-04-23· cited 93×
- Janet B. Davies Donald Davies v. Centennial Life Insurance Company, and Dun & Bradstreet Plan Services, Inc., Jerome J. Siegel, D.D.S., Third-PartyThird Circuit· 1997-10-16· cited 53×
- Raymond v. Moyle v. Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs Jones Oregon Stevedoring Co.Ninth Circuit· 1998-06-29· cited 33×
- In Re the Extradition of MolnarN.D. Illinois· 2002-03-18· cited 10×
- Lefkowitz v. Arcadia Trading Co. Ltd. Benefit Pension PlanSecond Circuit· 1993-06-22· cited 4×
Other cases named Shields v. Reader's Digest Ass'n
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.