Seward v. Musick Auction, LLC

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding that under Idaho law, “formation of a valid contract requires a meeting of the minds as evidenced by a manifestation of mutual intent to contract” (citation and internal quotation marks omitted)

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

11 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Valiant Idaho v. VP Incorporated
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2018-11-01· cited 28×
• Brunobuilt v. Strata
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2020-02-05· cited 15×
• Kosmann v. Dinius
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2019-05-14· cited 12×
• Bailey v. Birch (In re Birch)
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2019-02-08· cited 6×
• Terrell v. Paradis de Golf Holding, LLC
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2023-03-24· cited 3×
• Carter Dental v. Carter
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2024-07-02· cited 3×
• Uzzle v. Estate of Eric Milo Hirning
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2022-10-19
• TCR, LLC v. Teton County
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2024-11-19
• Bailey v. Birch
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2019-02-08
• Rossman Law Group, PLLC v. Holcomb and Carraway
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2025-11-19
• Bedell v. Parsons
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2026-02-19

Cites

30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• G&M Farms v. Funk Irrigation Co.
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1991-03-19· cited 172×
• Baxter v. Craney
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2000-12-15· cited 87×
• James Adams v. Johns-Manville Corporation, and Raymark Industries, Inc.
  Ninth Circuit· 1989-05-26· cited 78×
• Ada County Highway District v. Total Success Investment, LLC
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2008-02-19· cited 66×
• Werry v. Phillips Petroleum Company
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1975-09-25· cited 60×
• Ackerman v. Sobol Family Partnership, LLP
  Supreme Court of Connecticut· 2010-09-28· cited 50×
• Sprinkler Irrigation Co., Inc. v. JOHN DEERE INS. COMPANY, INC.
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2004-02-11· cited 45×
• J.R. Simplot Co. v. Bosen
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2006-11-28· cited 37×
• Phillips v. Erhart
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2011-05-25· cited 34×
• BORLEY v. Smith
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2010-05-11· cited 28×
• The Estate of Benjamin Holland v. Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2012-05-29· cited 28×
• Mac Tools, Inc. v. Griffin
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1994-08-24· cited 27×
• Beus v. Beus
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2011-06-29· cited 23×
• Wandering Trails, LLC v. Big Bite Excavation, Inc.
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2014-06-18· cited 23×
• Gray v. Tri-Way Construction Services, Inc.
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2009-04-27· cited 22×
• VANDERFORD CO., INC. v. Knudson
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2011-03-21· cited 21×
• Earl v. Cryovac, a Division of W.R. Grace Co.
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 1989-04-05· cited 21×
• Budget Truck Sales, LLC v. Tilley
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2018-04-20· cited 21×
• PacificCorp v. Idaho State Tax Commission
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2012-12-24· cited 20×
• Willapa Trading Co. v. Muscanto, Inc.
  Court of Appeals of Washington· 1986-11-03· cited 20×

Other cases named Seward v. Musick Auction, LLC

1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.

• Seward v. Musick Auction, LLC
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2018-09-19