Kentucky Supreme Court· 8/26/2015
Sargent v. Shaffer
Citations
- 467 S.W.3d 198
- 2015 WL 4967135
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that while the trial court may enjoy some discretionary leeway in deciding what instructions are authorized by the evidence, it has no discretion to give an instruction that misrepresents the applicable law
- allegations of instructional error based upon the claim that the trial court gave an instruction that was not sufficiently supported by the evidence
- overruled on other grounds by University Medical Center, Inc. v. Shwab, 628 S.W.3d 112 (Ky. 2021)
- “courts apply the conjunction, ‘and,’ as written by the legislature unless that construction would clearly thwart the intent of the legislature or produce an absurd result”
- \[A] trial court’s decision on whether to instruct on a specific claim will be reviewed for abuse of discretion; the substantive content of the jury instructions will be reviewed de novo.\
- \[A] trial court's decision on whether to instruct on a specific claim will be reviewed for abuse of discretion; the substantive content of the jury instructions will be reviewed de nova.\
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Abramson, Barber, Cunningham, Keller, Minton, Noble, Only, Venters
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
19 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Superior Steel, Inc. v. Ascent at Roebling's Bridge, LLCMissouri Court of Appeals· 2017-12-14· cited 83×
- In re Interest of LeVanta S.Nebraska Supreme Court· 2016-12-02· cited 49×
- Commonwealth v. CaudillMissouri Court of Appeals· 2018-02-15· cited 29×
- PBI Bank, Inc. v. Signature Point Condominiums LLCCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 2016-12-02· cited 21×
- Auslander Props., LLC v. NalleyMissouri Court of Appeals· 2018-09-27· cited 21×
- Smith v. SmithMissouri Court of Appeals· 2018-12-13· cited 18×
- Jewish Hosp. & St. Mary's Healthcare, Inc. v. HouseMissouri Court of Appeals· 2018-12-13· cited 18×
- Maupin v. TankersleyMissouri Court of Appeals· 2018-02-15· cited 16×
- Jackson v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2016-02-18· cited 14×
- Turner v. Com. of Ky.Missouri Court of Appeals· 2018-04-26· cited 14×
- Desai v. Charter Commc'ns, LLCW.D. Kentucky· 2019-03-29· cited 8×
- Zewoldi v. Transit Auth. of River CityCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 2018-05-18· cited 5×
- McCargo v. CommonwealthCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 2017-09-08· cited 2×
- City of Nicholasville Police Dep't v. AbrahamCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 2018-07-27· cited 2×
- Latasha Maupin v. Roland TankersleyKentucky Supreme Court· 2018-02-15
- Melinda Turner v. Commonwealth of KentuckyKentucky Supreme Court· 2018-04-26
- Troy Dunkleberger v. Commonwealth of KentuckyKentucky Supreme Court· 2025-03-20
- Raiantez Shackles v. Commonwealth of KentuckyKentucky Supreme Court· 2025-09-18
- Airan Hernandez Mendez v. Commonwealth of KentuckyKentucky Supreme Court· 2025-12-18
Cites
38 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Commonwealth v. EnglishKentucky Supreme Court· 1999-06-17· cited 1,274×
- Jerry W. Canterbury v. William Thornton Spence and the Washington Hospital Center, a Body CorporateD.C. Circuit· 1972-07-20· cited 455×
- Meyers v. Chapman Printing Co., Inc.Kentucky Supreme Court· 1992-12-17· cited 230×
- Harp v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2008-10-27· cited 154×
- Shawnee Telecom Resources, Inc. v. BrownKentucky Supreme Court· 2011-10-27· cited 144×
- Williams v. WilsonKentucky Supreme Court· 1998-04-16· cited 118×
- Arlene Galdamez v. John Potter, Postmaster GeneralNinth Circuit· 2005-07-15· cited 115×
- Ratliff v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2006-07-28· cited 108×
- Martin v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2013-09-26· cited 96×
- Kovacs v. FreemanKentucky Supreme Court· 1997-12-18· cited 86×
- Caneyville Volunteer Fire Department v. Green's Motorcycle Salvage, Inc.Kentucky Supreme Court· 2009-06-25· cited 76×
- Vitale v. HencheyKentucky Supreme Court· 2000-04-20· cited 63×
- Lederman v. Frontier Fire Protection, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2012-07-11· cited 58×
- Thomas v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2005-06-16· cited 56×
- Beverly M. Fisher and John B. Fisher, Sr. v. Ford Motor CompanySixth Circuit· 2000-08-23· cited 51×
- Wemyss v. ColemanKentucky Supreme Court· 1987-04-30· cited 49×
- Olfice, Inc. v. WilkeyKentucky Supreme Court· 2005-08-25· cited 48×
- Goncalves v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2013-02-21· cited 44×
- Larkin v. Pfizer, Inc.Kentucky Supreme Court· 2004-06-17· cited 42×
- Rogers v. KasdanKentucky Supreme Court· 1981-03-03· cited 41×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.