Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 11/23/2011
Pyeritz v. Commonwealth
Citations
- 32 A.3d 687
- 613 Pa. 80
- 2011 Pa. LEXIS 2831
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that no cause of action for negligent spoliation of evidence exists in Pennsylvania
- holding that the plaintiffs in an action against the Pennsylvania State Police did not have a cause of action for the State Police’s destruction of evidence related to the plaintiffs’ separate products liability suit
- concluding that the exception did not apply because “this is not a case . . . where the injury sued for is injury to the property itself;” rather, “[t]he alleged injury here is to legal claims arising out Decedent’s death because of the destruction of the [property].”
- defining “spoliation of evidence” as “the non-preservation or significant alteration of evidence for pending or future litigation.”
- focusing analysis on whether it was appropriate, as a matter of public policy, to affirmatively “impose[ ] a duty in tort not to commit negligent spoliation of evidence”
- delineating the applicable review standard only in terms of the legal-error component
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Castille, Saylor, Eakin, Baer, Todd, McCaffery, Greenspan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
45 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Parr, J. v. Ford Motor CompanySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-12-22· cited 136×
- PTSI, Inc. v. HaleySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-05-24· cited 40×
- Alderwoods (Pennsylvania), Inc. v. Duquesne Light Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-12-15· cited 35×
- Evans v. Thomas Jefferson UniversityCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-12-04· cited 33×
- Miner Dederick Construction, LLP v. Gulf Chemical & Metallurgical CorporationTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2013-04-11· cited 26×
- Sukenik v. Township of ElizabethCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-01-05· cited 21×
- Marshall, H. v. Brown's IA, LLCSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2019-06-19· cited 20×
- Pentlong Corp. v. GLS Capital, Inc.Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-07-15· cited 16×
- S. Brewington v. City of Philadelphia and Walter G. Smith Elementary School -- Appeal of: S. Brewington and J. BrewingtonCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-11-14· cited 15×
- Garzella v. Borough of DunmoreCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-01-29· cited 14×
- Deal, M. v. The Children's Hosp. of PhiladelphiaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2019-11-19· cited 13×
- Wagner v. Kimberly-Clark Corp.E.D. Pennsylvania· 2016-12-01· cited 11×
- Clipper Pipe & Service, Inc. v. Ohio Casualty InsuranceSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-06-15· cited 10×
- Peters Creek United Presbyterian Church v. Washington PresbyteryCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-04-30· cited 10×
- B. Leibensperger v. Carpenter Technologies, Inc. t/a Carpenter Technology Corp.Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-09-22· cited 8×
- M.H. Pane, M.F. Pane and C. Pane v. Indian Rocks Property Owners Association, Inc. of LedgedaleCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-07-19· cited 8×
- Vanesko v. Marina District Development Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 2014-08-05· cited 8×
- Edinger v. Borough of PortlandCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-07-08· cited 7×
- Turturro v. United StatesE.D. Pennsylvania· 2014-08-22· cited 7×
- R.J. Gillingham v. County of DelawareCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-02-14· cited 6×
Cites
30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Sinn v. BurdSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1979-07-11· cited 424×
- West v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co.Second Circuit· 1999-02-12· cited 379×
- Bortz v. NoonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1999-04-22· cited 280×
- Leong Ex Rel. Petagno v. TakasakiHawaii Supreme Court· 1974-03-28· cited 176×
- R.W. v. ManzekSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-12-28· cited 160×
- Jones v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation AuthoritySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2001-05-22· cited 130×
- Krentz v. Consolidated Rail Corp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-11-21· cited 109×
- Liss & Marion, P.C. v. Recordex Acquisition Corp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-11-16· cited 109×
- Yania v. BiganSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-11-09· cited 102×
- Ortega v. City of New YorkNew York Court of Appeals· 2007-10-16· cited 86×
- Schroeder v. Com., Dept. of Transp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1998-04-01· cited 83×
- Creazzo v. Medtronic, Inc.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-06-27· cited 63×
- Hannah v. HeeterWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2003-06-30· cited 59×
- Price v. BrownSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1996-07-31· cited 57×
- Central Storage & Transfer Co. v. KaplanSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1979-12-21· cited 48×
- Fletcher v. Dorchester Mutual InsuranceMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2002-08-16· cited 44×
- McHugh v. McHughSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1898-05-16· cited 42×
- Elias v. Lancaster General HospitalSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1998-03-30· cited 33×
- Lips v. SCOTTSDALE HEALTHCARE CORP.Arizona Supreme Court· 2010-05-03· cited 32×
- Cole v. WellsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1962-01-02· cited 28×
Other cases named Pyeritz v. Commonwealth
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.