Michigan Supreme Court· 7/27/2005
People v. Schaefer
Citations
- 703 N.W.2d 774
- 473 Mich. 418
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that a prosecution for operating while intoxicated causing death, MCL 257.625(4), requires proof that operation, not intoxication, caused victim’s death
- stating that gross negligence “by the victim .. . will generally be considered a superseding cause”
- stating that “gross negligence” or “intentional misconduct” on the part of a victim is sufficient to “break the causal chain between the defendant and the victim” because it is not reasonably foreseeable
- emphasizing that OUI causing death proscribes “operating while intoxicated,” not “operating in an intoxicated manner”
- stating that if an intervening act or cause was reasonably foreseeable, then it does not sever proximate cause
- noting, had the legislature not wanted to apply the standard of proximate causation, “the Legislature would have instead used the words ‘results in death’ rather than ‘causes the death’”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cavanagh, Kelly, Taylor, Weaver, Corrigan, Markman, Young
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
48 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- People v. RobinsonMichigan Supreme Court· 2006-05-31· cited 348×
- People v. FeezelMichigan Supreme Court· 2010-06-08· cited 329×
- People v. GillisMichigan Supreme Court· 2006-04-05· cited 274×
- People v. SchumacherMichigan Court of Appeals· 2007-10-11· cited 176×
- People v. Flick; People v. LazarusMichigan Supreme Court· 2010-07-27· cited 131×
- State v. TurnidgeOregon Supreme Court· 2016-05-05· cited 129×
- Douglas v. Allstate Insurance CompanyMichigan Supreme Court· 2012-07-30· cited 108×
- Paige v. City of Sterling HeightsMichigan Supreme Court· 2006-07-31· cited 99×
- Petersen v. Magna Corp.Michigan Supreme Court· 2009-07-31· cited 81×
- People v. CorbinMichigan Court of Appeals· 2015-09-22· cited 65×
- People v. LaidlerMichigan Supreme Court· 2012-05-30· cited 63×
- People v. LoweMichigan Supreme Court· 2009-08-13· cited 61×
- People v. DerrorMichigan Supreme Court· 2006-06-21· cited 60×
- People v. WilliamsMichigan Court of Appeals· 2010-04-08· cited 56×
- People v. HallMichigan Supreme Court· 2016-06-29· cited 48×
- People v. NyxMichigan Supreme Court· 2007-07-18· cited 47×
- People of Michigan v. Edward Michael CzuprynskiMichigan Court of Appeals· 2018-08-02· cited 44×
- People v. MonacoMichigan Supreme Court· 2006-02-01· cited 43×
- Stone v. WilliamsonMichigan Supreme Court· 2008-07-23· cited 36×
- People of Michigan v. Samer ShamiMichigan Supreme Court· 2018-04-26· cited 30×
Cites
50 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- People v. CarinesMichigan Supreme Court· 1999-07-27· cited 3,769×
- Connally v. General Construction Co.Supreme Court· 1926-01-04· cited 3,272×
- Marks v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1977-03-01· cited 2,149×
- Bouie v. City of ColumbiaSupreme Court· 1964-06-22· cited 1,779×
- People v. BabcockMichigan Supreme Court· 2003-07-31· cited 930×
- People v. LukityMichigan Supreme Court· 1999-07-13· cited 887×
- Robinson v. City of DetroitMichigan Supreme Court· 2000-07-18· cited 662×
- Rogers v. TennesseeSupreme Court· 2001-05-14· cited 616×
- Roberts v. Mecosta County General HospitalMichigan Supreme Court· 2002-04-24· cited 325×
- People v. CornellMichigan Supreme Court· 2002-06-18· cited 323×
- Koontz v. Ameritech Services, IncMichigan Supreme Court· 2002-06-12· cited 302×
- People v. ElstonMichigan Supreme Court· 2000-07-25· cited 235×
- People v. PetrellaMichigan Supreme Court· 1986-01-10· cited 219×
- Mayor of Lansing v. Public Service CommissionMichigan Supreme Court· 2004-06-09· cited 211×
- DiBenedetto v. West Shore HospitalMichigan Supreme Court· 2000-02-09· cited 187×
- Robertson v. DaimlerChrysler Corp.Michigan Supreme Court· 2002-04-09· cited 171×
- State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Old Republic InsuranceMichigan Supreme Court· 2002-05-29· cited 165×
- People v. MooreMichigan Supreme Court· 2004-05-12· cited 163×
- People v. YostMichigan Supreme Court· 2003-04-23· cited 150×
- People v. StoneMichigan Supreme Court· 2001-01-30· cited 148×
Other cases named People v. Schaefer
36 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- People v. SchaeferIllinois Supreme Court· 1993-02-25· cited 54×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1985-06-05· cited 35×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1991-08-23· cited 16×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 2010-02-23· cited 14×
- People v. SchaeferIllinois Supreme Court· 1914-12-16· cited 13×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1989-08-24· cited 9×
- People v. SchaeferCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1993-08-09· cited 9×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1980-08-13· cited 7×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1995-08-15· cited 7×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 2020-12-21· cited 7×
- People v. SchaeferSupreme Court of Colorado· 1997-05-19· cited 5×
- People v. SchaeferCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2012-08-29· cited 4×
- People v. SchaeferCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2004-05-17· cited 3×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1988-01-19· cited 3×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1991-06-14· cited 3×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 2003-09-02· cited 2×
- People v. SchaeferNew York Supreme Court· 1942-09-17· cited 2×
- People v. SchaeferNew York Court of Appeals· 1970-11-11· cited 1×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 2003-02-27· cited 1×
- People v. SchaeferYonkers City Court· 1987-04-28· cited 1×
- People v. SchaeferMichigan Court of Appeals· 1976-05-28· cited 1×
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 2020-12-21· cited 1×
- People v. SchaeferNew York County Court, Columbia County· 2025-05-13· cited 1×
- People v. SchaeferMichigan Supreme Court· 2006-08-29
- People v. SchaeferMichigan Supreme Court· 2004-11-29
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 2003-09-02
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 2010-02-23
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 2018-07-12
- People v. SchaeferSupreme Court of Colorado· 1997-09-15
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1915-04-15
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1980-09-11
- People v. SchaeferNew York Court of Special Session· 1934-10-08
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1915-04-30
- People v. SchaeferAppellate Court of Illinois· 1920-01-12
- People v. SchaeferCourt for the Trial of Impeachments and Correction of Errors· 2018-09-06
- People v. SchaeferNew York County Court, Columbia County· 2025-05-13
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.