Peck v. Tribune Co.
Citations
- 214 U.S. 185
- 29 S. Ct. 554
- 53 L. Ed. 960
- 1909 U.S. LEXIS 1906
Syllabus
<p>The publication of a portrait-with a statement thereunder imports ' .that the original of. the portrait makes the statement even if another name be attached to the statement. Wandt v. Hearst’s Chicago American, 129 Wisconsin, 419; Morrison v. Smith, 177 N. Y. 366, approved on this point.</p> <p>Publication of the portrait of one person with statements thereunder as of another, by mistake, and without knowledge of whom the portrait really is, is not an excuse.' A libel is harmful on its face, and one publishing manifestly hurtful statements concerning an individual does so at his peril; and, if there is no justification other than that it was news or advertising, he is liable if the statements are false or are true only of some one else. See Morasse v. Brochu, 151 Massachusetts, 567.</p> <p>An unprivileged falsehood need not entail universal hatred to constitute a cause of action; to be libellous a statement need not be that the person libelled has done or said something that every one, or even a majority of persons in the community, may regard as discreditable ; it is sufficient if the statement hurts the party alluded to in the estimation of an important and respectable part of the community.</p> <p>A woman, whose portrait is published in connection with an endorsement of a brand of whiskey may be seriously hurt in her standing with a considerable portion of her neighbors and she is entitled to prove her case and go to the jury.</p> <p>Quaere and not decided whether the unauthorized publication of a person’s likeness is a tort per se.:</p> <p>154 Fed. Rep. 330; reversed.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- stating, in an opinion authored by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., “If the advertisement obviously would hurt the plaintiff in the estimation of an important and respectable part of the community, liability is not a question of a majority vote.”
- ‘“Whenever a man publishes, he publishes at his peril.’ ” (quoting The King v. Wood- fall, 98 Eng. Rep. 914, 916 (K.B.1774))
- photograph of plaintiff used to illustrate story about teenage sexual promiscuity
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Holmes
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
88 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Herbert v. LandoSupreme Court· 1979-04-18· cited 1,085×
- Brown v. Kelly Broadcasting Co.California Supreme Court· 1989-04-27· cited 341×
- Crump v. Beckley Newspapers, Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court· 1984-07-11· cited 201×
- Terminal Taxicab Co. v. KutzSupreme Court· 1916-05-22· cited 190×
- Afro-American Publishing Co., Inc. v. Eli Jaffe, T/a Douglas PharmacyD.C. Circuit· 1966-08-23· cited 158×
- Jews for Jesus, Inc. v. RappSupreme Court of Florida· 2008-10-23· cited 156×
- Lundquist v. ReusserCalifornia Supreme Court· 1994-07-21· cited 140×
- Kapellas v. KofmanCalifornia Supreme Court· 1969-10-24· cited 130×
- Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corporation v. Walter Jacobson and Cbs, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 1983-07-14· cited 118×
- Jankovic v. International Crisis GroupD.C. Circuit· 2007-07-24· cited 116×
- Cabaniss v. HipsleyCourt of Appeals of Georgia· 1966-09-07· cited 108×
- Washington Post Co. v. ChalonerSupreme Court· 1919-06-02· cited 102×
- Doe v. Dept. of Public Safety ex rel. LeeSecond Circuit· 2001-10-19· cited 88×
- Guilford Transportation Industries, Inc. v. WilnerDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2000-10-12· cited 82×
- Croixland Properties Ltd. Partnership v. CorcoranD.C. Circuit· 1999-04-13· cited 71×
- Herrmann v. Newark Morning Ledger Co.New Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1958-01-13· cited 67×
- Grant v. Reader's Digest Ass'nSecond Circuit· 1945-11-02· cited 54×
- National Refining Co. v. Benzo Gas Motor Fuel Co.Eighth Circuit· 1927-05-23· cited 46×
- Douglas v. StokesCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1912-09-27· cited 45×
- Senna v. Walter Florimont & 2400 Amusements, Inc.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 2008-09-22· cited 44×
Other cases named Peck v. Tribune Co.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.