Skip to main content

McCoy v. People

Citations

  • 2019 CO 44
  • 442 P.3d 379

Syllabus

This case principally required the Supreme Court to determine the appropriate standard of review for unpreserved claims of insufficient evidence and to apply that standard to decide whether legally sufficient evidence supported defendant's convictions here. The Court initially concluded that sufficiency of the evidence claims may be raised for the first time on appeal and are not subject to plain error review. Accordingly, appellate courts should review unpreserved insufficiency claims de novo (i.e., in the same manner as if the claims were preserved), and not under a plain error standard of review. Such a rule is consistent with Colorado's criminal procedure rules, long-standing precedent, and the nature of sufficiency claims, including the settled principle that a conviction that is based on legally insufficient evidence cannot stand. On the merits of defendant's sufficiency claims, the Court began by construing CRS § 18-3-404(1)(g), which bars sexual contact committed during treatment or examination for other than bona fide medical purposes or in a manner substantially inconsistent with reasonable medical practices. After determining that this provision is ambiguous, the Court employed settled tools of statutory construction and concluded that the provision applies to a doctor or other individual who is, or holds himself or herself out to be, a health treatment provider of any kind, and who knowingly subjects the victim to sexual contact while examining, treating, or purporting to examine or treat the victim for other than a bona fide medical purpose or in a manner substantially inconsistent with reasonable medical practices. Finally, applying this construction here, the Court concluded that the provision is neither facially overbroad nor unconstitutionally vague and that the prosecution presented sufficient evidence to support defendant's convictions. Accordingly, the Court affirmed the division's judgment, although its reasoning differs in some respects from th

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

  • holding that courts may only resort to “other aids to statutory construction, including . . . the statute’s legislative history,” when statutory language is 12 ambiguous
  • holding “sufficient direct and circumstantial evidence supported McCoy’s convictions”
  • applying abuse of discretion standard to review revocation of deferred judgment
  • cautioning that we must avoid interpretations that render any statutory term superfluous
  • “[A] defendant effectively challenges the sufficiency of the evidence presented at trial by contesting that evidence at the trial, and we perceive no purpose in requiring a party to pursue some other form of objection directed to the evidence as a whole.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

102 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

Cites

56 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

Other cases named McCoy v. People

4 other CourtListener records share this case name.

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.