Supreme Court of Iowa· 6/29/1972
McCarthy v. J. P. Cullen & Son Corp.
Citations
- 199 N.W.2d 362
- 1972 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 849
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding a judgment of punitive damages turns “more or less” on acts peculiar to each case, “rests largely in discretion of the jury,” and must be reasonably related to actual damages, but rejecting a numeric formula
- examining architects’ duties with respect to plans and specifications and noting duty extended to protection of owners of adjacent properties from harms “which reasonably could be expected to flow from” the plans
- examining architects’ duties with respect to plans and specifications and noting duty extended to protection of owners of adjacent properties from harms “which reasonably could be expected to flow from” the plans
- “amount of punitive damages must generally be proportionate to the actual damages”
- expressly rejecting the use of a mathematical ratio in examining punitive damages
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Legrand, Mason, McCormick
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
60 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Meyer v. NottgerSupreme Court of Iowa· 1976-05-19· cited 140×
- Tralon Corp. v. Cedarapids, Inc.N.D. Iowa· 1997-05-20· cited 124×
- Ryan v. ArnesonSupreme Court of Iowa· 1988-04-13· cited 77×
- Evans v. Howard R. Green Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1975-07-31· cited 59×
- Young v. City of Des MoinesSupreme Court of Iowa· 1978-02-22· cited 58×
- Porter v. Iowa Power and Light CompanySupreme Court of Iowa· 1974-04-24· cited 58×
- Giltner v. StarkSupreme Court of Iowa· 1974-06-26· cited 55×
- Shepherd Components, Inc. v. Brice Petrides-Donohue & Associates, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1991-07-17· cited 54×
- Page County Appliance Center, Inc. v. Honeywell, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1984-03-14· cited 48×
- Pringle Tax Service, Inc. v. KnoblauchSupreme Court of Iowa· 1979-08-29· cited 48×
- White v. Citizens National Bank of BooneSupreme Court of Iowa· 1978-02-22· cited 42×
- Montgomery Properties Corp. v. Economy Forms Corp.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1981-05-13· cited 40×
- Midwest Management Corp. v. StephensSupreme Court of Iowa· 1984-07-18· cited 39×
- Theresa Huck v. Wyeth, Inc. D/B/A Wyeth Schwarz Pharma, Inc. and Pliva, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 2014-07-11· cited 37×
- Sandhorst v. Mauk's Transfer, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1977-04-20· cited 32×
- Earl v. ClarkSupreme Court of Iowa· 1974-06-26· cited 31×
- Craven v. OggeroSupreme Court of Iowa· 1973-12-19· cited 30×
- Hagenson v. United Telephone Company of IowaSupreme Court of Iowa· 1973-07-03· cited 29×
- Kelly v. Iowa State Education Ass'nCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 1985-05-28· cited 29×
- Palleson v. Jewell Cooperative ElevatorSupreme Court of Iowa· 1974-05-22· cited 28×
Cites
21 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Rosenau Ex Rel. Rosenau v. City of EsthervilleSupreme Court of Iowa· 1972-06-29· cited 107×
- Hawkeye-Security Insurance Co. v. Ford Motor Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1970-02-10· cited 100×
- Iowa Power and Light Co. v. Abild Construction Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1966-07-14· cited 97×
- Sebastian v. WoodSupreme Court of Iowa· 1954-11-16· cited 66×
- Blackford v. Sioux City Dressed Pork, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1962-12-11· cited 61×
- Hawkeye Security Insurance Co. v. Ford Motor Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1972-06-29· cited 61×
- Peters v. LyonsSupreme Court of Iowa· 1969-06-10· cited 61×
- Syester v. BantaSupreme Court of Iowa· 1965-03-09· cited 58×
- Rozmajzl v. Northland Greyhound LinesSupreme Court of Iowa· 1951-10-16· cited 58×
- Henneman v. McCallaSupreme Court of Iowa· 1967-02-07· cited 55×
- Claude v. Weaver Construction CompanySupreme Court of Iowa· 1968-04-09· cited 53×
- Amos v. Prom, Inc.N.D. Iowa· 1953-09-30· cited 49×
- Ke-Wash Company v. Stauffer Chemical CompanySupreme Court of Iowa· 1970-05-05· cited 43×
- Robeson v. DiltsSupreme Court of Iowa· 1969-09-05· cited 42×
- Charles v. Epperson & CompanySupreme Court of Iowa· 1965-10-19· cited 41×
- Robinson v. Home Fire & Marine InsuranceSupreme Court of Iowa· 1953-07-17· cited 30×
- Katko v. BrineySupreme Court of Iowa· 1971-02-09· cited 26×
- Binkholder v. CarpenterSupreme Court of Iowa· 1967-08-31· cited 20×
- Epley v. S. Patti Construction CompanyN.D. Iowa· 1964-04-07· cited 20×
- Mayhew v. Iowa-Illinois Telephone Co.S.D. Iowa· 1967-09-14· cited 13×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.