McArdle v. Tronetti

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• explaining that, under Pennsylvania law, “res judicata generally is thought to turn on the essential similarity of the underlying events giving rise to the various legal claims”
• finding a lack of identity between two sets of claims-federal constitutional violations and state law gross negligence-because they involved distinct factual allegations and elements
• noting that conclusion is consistent with Restatement (Second
• noting that conclusion is consistent with Restatement (Second
• “As to the identity of eause[s] of action, rather than resting upon the specific legal theory invoked, res judicata generally is thought to turn on the essential similarity of the underlying events giving rise to the various legal claims.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

35 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Deanna Turner v. Crawford Square Apartments Iii, L.P. McCormack Baron Management Services, Inc
  Third Circuit· 2006-05-31· cited 221×
• Lerner v. Lerner
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-08-07· cited 134×
• Dempsey v. Cessna Aircraft Co.
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1995-01-25· cited 66×
• Hopewell Estates, Inc. v. Kent
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1994-08-22· cited 45×
• Carr v. Rose
  District of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1997-10-09· cited 44×
• Tucker v. Philadelphia Daily News
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2000-06-28· cited 34×
• Weinar, M. v. Lex, W.
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-12-15· cited 27×
• Khalil, A. v. Cole, B.
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2020-10-02· cited 25×
• Rearick v. Elderton State Bank
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-07-23· cited 23×
• Rosemont Taxicab Co. v. Phila. Parking Auth.
  E.D. Pennsylvania· 2018-06-26· cited 19×
• RUTH F. v. Robert B.
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1997-02-06· cited 17×
• Scott v. Mershon
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1995-05-02· cited 14×
• Butler v. Charles Powers Estate
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-09-07· cited 11×
• Singleton v. Jas Auto. LLC
  E.D. Pennsylvania· 2019-05-01· cited 8×
• PG Publishing Co. v. Aichele
  W.D. Pennsylvania· 2012-10-09· cited 7×
• Russo v. City of Philadelphia
  E.D. Pennsylvania· 2011-05-11· cited 2×
• Pennsylvania Chiropractic Ass'n v. Blue Cross Blue Shield Ass'n
  N.D. Illinois· 2012-10-12· cited 2×
• Sheils v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (In re Fleming)
  M.D. Pennsylvania· 2013-05-14· cited 1×
• Turner v. Crawford Square Apt
  Third Circuit· 2006-05-31
• Kiec v. Sherrerd
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1999-06-08

Cites

11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Thelma DAVIS v. UNITED STATES STEEL SUPPLY, DIVISION OF UNITED STATES STEEL CORPORATION, Appellant
  Third Circuit· 1982-08-30· cited 144×
• Yania v. Bigan
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-11-09· cited 102×
• Brant v. Wisconsin
  Supreme Court· 1983-02-28· cited 99×
• Byers v. Ward
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1951-11-13· cited 83×
• In Re Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp.
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-06-01· cited 63×
• LERAMAN v. Rudolph
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1964-03-17· cited 52×
• Dyer v. Travelers
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1990-04-03· cited 35×
• Rose v. Wissinger
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1982-01-08· cited 34×
• Mintz v. Carlton House Partners, Ltd.
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1991-08-07· cited 33×
• Greenspan v. United Services Automobile Ass'n
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-01-20· cited 31×
• Melat v. Melat
  Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1992-01-28· cited 29×

Other cases named McArdle v. Tronetti

1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.

• McArdle v. Tronetti
  W.D. Pennsylvania· 1991-08-01· cited 7×