Maloney v. Winston Bros.
Citations
- 18 Idaho 740
- 111 P. 1080
- 1910 Ida. LEXIS 76
Syllabus
<p>Instructions — Personal Injury — Hazardous Undertaking — Assumption op Bisk — Duty op Master — Duty to Make Place op Work Safe — Proof of Negligence — Sufficiency of Evidence — Excessive Damages.</p> <p>(Syllabus by tbe court.)</p> <p>1. Instructions examined, considered and held not to be erroneous,</p> <p>2. Where a laborer seeks and obtains employment at a hazardous and dangerous task and which must necessarily be prosecuted in a dangerous place, he thereby assumes the ordinary risks incident to the employment and attendant on the place where the work is prosecuted, but he does not thereby assume any additional burden of risk superimposed by reason of the master’s neglect of the duty that rested upon him to have the place inspected and maintained in a reasonably safe condition, as a place of the kind should be maintained in which employees are to prosecute their work.</p> <p>3. In the case of a hazardous work like driving a railroad tunnel through the mountain, an increased risk is assumed and an increased duty is imposed by law on both the master and servant proportionate to the dangers of the place and the risks of the employment — on the master to exercise increased care and diligence in maintaining the place in as safe a condition as the nature of the work will permit, and upon the servant to either assume or avoid patent and obvious dangers and those necessarily incident to the work and the place in which the work is being prosecuted.</p> <p>4. It is the established rule of law that the liability of the master depends upon the character of the act in the performance of which the injury arises, and not upon the grade or rank of the employee or fellow-servant to whom the negligent act is traceable.</p> <p>5. In an action for personal injuries received by and on account of the negligence of the master, negligence must be shown, and this may be done by positive testimony of the commission of a wrongful act by the master or the neglect by him to discharge a po
Judges: Ailshie, Stewart, Sullivan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
11 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Treinies v. Sunshine Mining Co.Supreme Court· 1940-01-29· cited 395×
- Newell v. NewellIdaho Supreme Court· 1956-01-13· cited 32×
- Denbeigh v. Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Co.Idaho Supreme Court· 1913-04-24· cited 21×
- Carron v. AbounadorNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1923-04-10· cited 15×
- White v. WhiteIdaho Supreme Court· 1971-02-10· cited 12×
- Newton v. New York Life InsuranceSupreme Court of Kansas· 1915-05-08· cited 11×
- Morris v. HinesNebraska Supreme Court· 1922-02-16· cited 8×
- Warner v. Pittsburgh-Idaho Co.Idaho Supreme Court· 1923-11-09· cited 7×
- Solleim v. Norbeck & Nicholson Co.South Dakota Supreme Court· 1914-05-18· cited 6×
- Barthel v. JohnstonIdaho Supreme Court· 1968-02-08· cited 4×
- Feroglio v. PaulsenWashington Supreme Court· 1913-05-06· cited 1×
Cites
82 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Choctaw, Oklahoma & Gulf R. R. v. McDadeSupreme Court· 1903-11-02· cited 296×
- Texas & Pacific Railway Co. v. ArchibaldSupreme Court· 1898-05-23· cited 172×
- Illinois Steel Co. v. SchymanowskiIllinois Supreme Court· 1896-05-12· cited 101×
- Goodwin v. Provident Savings Life Assurance Ass'nSupreme Court of Iowa· 1896-02-05· cited 86×
- Norris v. HarrisCalifornia Supreme Court· 1860-07-01· cited 74×
- Howland v. Oakland Consolidated Street Railway Co.California Supreme Court· 1895-12-18· cited 68×
- Boyce v. California Stage Co.California Supreme Court· 1864-07-01· cited 59×
- Alabama Great Southern Railroad v. CarrollSupreme Court of Alabama· 1892-07-01· cited 59×
- Florida Railway & Navigation Co. v. WebsterSupreme Court of Florida· 1889-01-15· cited 56×
- Morgan v. Southern Pac. Co.California Supreme Court· 1892-08-05· cited 49×
- Merchants & Miners Transportation Co. v. CorcoranCourt of Appeals of Georgia· 1908-08-04· cited 41×
- Chicago & Northwestern Railway Co. v. JacksonIllinois Supreme Court· 1870-09-15· cited 35×
- Dougherty v. Missouri RailroadSupreme Court of Missouri· 1888-10-15· cited 35×
- Lee v. S. Pac. R.R. Co.California Supreme Court· 1894-01-25· cited 32×
- Trinity & Sabine Railway Co. v. LaneTexas Supreme Court· 1891-02-20· cited 31×
- Chicago & Eastern Illinois Railroad v. RouseIllinois Supreme Court· 1899-02-17· cited 29×
- Williams Coal Co. v. CooperCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1910-05-06· cited 27×
- Davis v. Holy Terror Mining Co.South Dakota Supreme Court· 1906-04-03· cited 26×
- Indiana, Illinois & Iowa Railroad v. OtstotIllinois Supreme Court· 1904-10-24· cited 24×
- Holt v. Spokane & Palouse Railway Co.Idaho Supreme Court· 1895-04-06· cited 22×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.