First Circuit· 9/6/2016
Kaufman v. CVS Caremark Corp.
Citations
- 836 F.3d 88
- 2016 WL 4608131
- 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 16350
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that a structure/function claim would be misleading if it “fail[ed] to disclose the harmful aspects of the nutrient’s structure/function”
- noting that a 22 structure/function claim would be misleading if it “fail[ed] to disclose the harmful aspects 23 of the nutrient's structure/function”
- concluding the complaint provided sufficient particularity for Rule 9(b) purposes, where “CVS is the ‘who’; the heart health statements are the ‘what’; the label is the ‘where’; and the occasion on which Kaufman purchased the product is the ‘when’”
- rejecting the plaintiff’s argument that “evidence showing a supplement does not reduce heart disease necessarily implies that the nutrient itself has no function in maintaining heart health”
- denying a Rule 12(b)(6) motion because studies cited in the complaint did not “render implausible [plaintiff’s] allegation that substantiation for [misleading statements made by defendant] d[id] not exist”
- “If a particular dietary supplement functions to harm health in the supplied or recommended dosage, a label claiming that the product supports health is plausibly viewed as misleading.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Torruella, Kayatta, Barron
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
8 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Dumont v. Reily Foods Co.First Circuit· 2019-08-08· cited 71×
- Paul Dachauer v. Nbty, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2019-01-10· cited 23×
- Lee v. Conagra Brands, Inc.First Circuit· 2020-05-06· cited 19×
- Sullivan v. etectRx, Inc.First Circuit· 2023-05-11· cited 6×
- Ferrari v. Vitamin Shoppe Industries LLCFirst Circuit· 2023-06-09· cited 6×
- DiCroce v. McNeil Nutritionals, LLCFirst Circuit· 2023-09-18· cited 4×
- Donna L. Hadley, et al. v. HomeBridge1 Financial Services, et al.D. New Hampshire· 2020-07-30· cited 1×
- Kia America, Inc. v. P DMO Auto Acquisitions, LLC et al.D. New Hampshire· 2025-03-31
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Alternative System Concepts, Inc. v. Synopsys, Inc.First Circuit· 2004-07-07· cited 347×
- Cleary v. Philip Morris Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2011-08-25· cited 307×
- United States v. Alfred ArgentineFirst Circuit· 1987-03-20· cited 85×
- Richard C. Powers v. Boston Cooper CorporationFirst Circuit· 1991-02-27· cited 68×
- Abdallah v. Bain Capital, LLCFirst Circuit· 2014-06-03· cited 58×
- Marcus v. Forest Pharmaceuticals, Inc.First Circuit· 2015-02-20· cited 54×
- Giragosian v. BettencourtFirst Circuit· 2010-07-29· cited 50×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.