Supreme Court of Virginia· 6/6/1997
Horton v. Horton
Citations
- 487 S.E.2d 200
- 254 Va. 111
- 1997 Va. LEXIS 60
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- defining “material breach” as “a failure to do something that is so fundamental to the contract that the failure to perform that obligation defeats an essential purpose of the contract”
- proof of specific amount of monetary damages not required when “breach was so central to the parties’ agreement that it defeated an essential purpose of the contract”
- “[A] party who commits the first breach of contract is not entitled to enforce the contract.”
- “Acceptance of defective performance, without more, does not prove intent to relinquish the -8- right to full performance.”
- “If the first breaching party committed a material breach ... that party cannot enforce the contract” (citing Neely v. White, 177 Va. 358, 14 S.E.2d 337 (1941))
- “A material breach is a failure to do something that is so fundamental to the contract that the failure to perform that obligation defeats an essential purpose of the contract.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Keenan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
64 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Stanley v. WebberSupreme Court of Virginia· 2000-06-09· cited 67×
- Mathews v. PHH Mortg. Corp.Supreme Court of Virginia· 2012-04-20· cited 61×
- Countryside Orthopaedics, P.C. v. PeytonSupreme Court of Virginia· 2001-01-12· cited 52×
- Hudson v. LanierSupreme Court of Virginia· 1998-02-27· cited 40×
- Steele v. IsikoffDistrict of Columbia· 2000-09-06· cited 36×
- Ashcraft & Gerel v. Coady, EdwardD.C. Circuit· 2001-04-06· cited 29×
- Virginia Polytechnic Institute & State University v. Interactive Return Service, Inc.Supreme Court of Virginia· 2004-04-23· cited 27×
- McPike v. Zero-Gravity Holdings, Inc.E.D. Virginia· 2017-11-21· cited 23×
- Centex Construction v. ACSTAR InsuranceE.D. Virginia· 2006-08-24· cited 21×
- Drummond Coal Sales, Inc. v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co.Fourth Circuit· 2021-06-29· cited 21×
- Collado v. City of AlbuquerqueNew Mexico Court of Appeals· 2002-03-13· cited 19×
- Cardinal Development Co. v. Stanley Construction Co.Supreme Court of Virginia· 1998-02-27· cited 18×
- Virginia Electric and Power Co v. Bransen Energy, IncFourth Circuit· 2017-03-09· cited 18×
- 1st Stop Health Services, Inc., etc. v. Department of Medical Assistance Services, etc.Court of Appeals of Virginia· 2014-04-08· cited 17×
- Culpeper Regional Hospital v. Cynthia B. Jones, DirectorCourt of Appeals of Virginia· 2015-01-13· cited 15×
- Wilma Miller, Doing Business as Double Diamond Construction v. Mills Construction, Inc. Van Tol Surety Company, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 2003-12-18· cited 14×
- VIENNA METRO LLC v. Pulte Home Corp.E.D. Virginia· 2011-03-29· cited 14×
- Bayliner Marine Corp. v. CrowSupreme Court of Virginia· 1999-01-08· cited 13×
- Design & Production, Inc. v. American Exhibitions, Inc.E.D. Virginia· 2011-09-16· cited 13×
- Elite Entertainment, Inc. v. Khela Bros. Entertainment Inc.E.D. Virginia· 2005-10-19· cited 10×
Cites
17 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Stanley's Cafeteria, Inc. v. AbramsonSupreme Court of Virginia· 1983-09-09· cited 93×
- W. S. Carnes, Inc. v. Board of SupervisorsSupreme Court of Virginia· 1996-11-01· cited 90×
- Tuomala v. Regent UniversitySupreme Court of Virginia· 1996-11-01· cited 73×
- RF & P CORP. v. LittleSupreme Court of Virginia· 1994-02-25· cited 64×
- Ervin Construction Co. v. Van OrdenIdaho Supreme Court· 1993-08-25· cited 62×
- Quintin Vespa Co. Inc. v. Construction Service Co.Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1962-02-06· cited 61×
- Bernstein v. NemeyerSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1990-02-13· cited 59×
- Hurley v. BennettSupreme Court of Virginia· 1934-09-20· cited 56×
- Eager v. BerkeIllinois Supreme Court· 1957-03-20· cited 48×
- Neely v. WhiteSupreme Court of Virginia· 1941-04-21· cited 38×
- Gulf South Capital Corporation v. BrownMississippi Supreme Court· 1966-03-14· cited 31×
- Federal Insurance v. Starr Electric Co.Supreme Court of Virginia· 1991-11-08· cited 25×
- Rogers v. RelyeaMontana Supreme Court· 1979-10-02· cited 19×
- J.P. Stravens Planning Associates, Inc. v. City of WallaceIdaho Court of Appeals· 1996-12-04· cited 14×
- Cady v. BurtonMontana Supreme Court· 1993-04-13· cited 10×
- Stuarts Draft Shopping Center, L.P. v. S-D AssociatesSupreme Court of Virginia· 1996-04-19· cited 10×
- Macon Mining & Manufacturing, Inc. v. LasiterCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 1983-02-16· cited 1×
Other cases named Horton v. Horton
61 other CourtListener records share this case name; the 50 most cited are listed.
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1998-04-23· cited 87×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 1963-07-03· cited 66×
- Horton v. HortonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1941-09-03· cited 54×
- Horton v. HortonWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1980-03-25· cited 44×
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 2001-12-07· cited 34×
- Horton v. HortonAlaska Supreme Court· 1974-03-18· cited 31×
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1990-12-11· cited 30×
- Horton v. HortonUtah Supreme Court· 1984-12-04· cited 29×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 2016-05-09· cited 28×
- Horton v. HortonArizona Supreme Court· 1929-06-19· cited 28×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1905-04-08· cited 19×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-02-27· cited 18×
- Horton v. HortonCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1953-01-14· cited 17×
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1981-11-19· cited 13×
- Horton v. HortonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1952-01-17· cited 12×
- Horton v. HortonArizona Supreme Court· 1921-07-05· cited 12×
- Horton v. HortonMississippi Supreme Court· 1950-11-27· cited 10×
- Horton v. HortonMissouri Court of Appeals· 1997-12-02· cited 10×
- Horton v. HortonSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1993-07-07· cited 9×
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1976-04-02· cited 9×
- Horton v. HortonIdaho Supreme Court· 2022-10-03· cited 9×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 1966-09-08· cited 8×
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1983-07-14· cited 8×
- Horton v. HortonNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1987-04-01· cited 8×
- Horton v. HortonNew York Supreme Court· 1824-05-15· cited 8×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 1997-11-17· cited 7×
- Horton v. HortonMontana Supreme Court· 2007-07-31· cited 6×
- Horton v. HortonD.C. Circuit· 1934-08-06· cited 6×
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Appeals of Arkansas· 2011-05-11· cited 5×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 1930-07-17· cited 5×
- Horton v. HortonMississippi Supreme Court· 1972-11-20· cited 5×
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Appeals of Arkansas· 2005-06-22· cited 4×
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)· 1936-03-20· cited 4×
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2011-06-10· cited 3×
- Horton v. HortonCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1919-09-24· cited 3×
- Horton v. HortonMississippi Supreme Court· 1974-10-07· cited 3×
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1991-01-29· cited 2×
- Horton v. HortonTex. App. Ct., 9th Dist. (Beaumont)· 2011-03-10· cited 2×
- Horton v. HortonNew York Supreme Court· 1919-06-15· cited 1×
- Horton v. HortonNew York Supreme Court· 1894-12-10· cited 1×
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 1975-09-02· cited 1×
- Horton v. HortonAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1993-12-29· cited 1×
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1986-01-03· cited 1×
- Horton v. HortonMississippi Supreme Court· 1952-03-24· cited 1×
- Horton v. HortonNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 2008-10-24
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Georgia· 2010-11-08
- Horton v. HortonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2015-11-16
- Horton v. HortonSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-12-07
- Horton v. HortonAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1931-10-15
- Horton v. HortonAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1941-06-30
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.