Appellate Court of Illinois· 9/22/1998
Hopewell v. Vitullo
Citations
- 701 N.E.2d 99
- 299 Ill. App. 3d 513
- 233 Ill. Dec. 456
- 14 I.E.R. Cas. (BNA) 657
- 1998 Ill. App. LEXIS 633
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that the statement “fired because of incompetence” did not have a “precise and readily understood meaning,” and that “the veracity of the statement” was unverifiable
- holding that the alleged defamatory statement, “fired because of incompetence,” was “too vague and general to support an action for defamation as a matter of law”
- noting that where a subject is controversial, harsh statements are more likely to be substanceless rhetoric
- finding the isolated phrase “ ‘fired because of incompetence’ ” nonactionable because it was uttered without any specific factual context and was too broad, conclusory, and subjective to be objectively verifiable
- finding the statement that the plaintiff “was fired because of incompetence” to be nonactionable because readers could conclude that it was mere posturing before an ensuing legal battle between the parties and because there were no other factual assertions in support of the statement
- the statement “fired because of incompetence” found protectable opinion because the meaning of incompetence is broad, conclusory, and subjective
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Rakowski
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
50 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Solaia Technology, LLC v. Specialty Publishing Co.Illinois Supreme Court· 2006-06-22· cited 357×
- Dubinsky v. United Airlines Master Executive CouncilAppellate Court of Illinois· 1999-03-01· cited 80×
- Diane Trahanas v. Northwestern UniversitySeventh Circuit· 2023-04-07· cited 77×
- Wynne v. Loyola University of ChicagoAppellate Court of Illinois· 2000-12-21· cited 76×
- Brennan v. KadnerAppellate Court of Illinois· 2004-08-11· cited 56×
- Visvardis v. Eric P. Ferleger, P.C.Appellate Court of Illinois· 2007-07-27· cited 54×
- Kathleen Lifton v. The Board of Education of the City of Chicago, Arne Duncan, and William MeuerSeventh Circuit· 2005-07-22· cited 50×
- Madison v. FrazierSeventh Circuit· 2008-08-22· cited 50×
- Mid-West Energy Consultants, Inc. v. Covenant Home, Inc.Appellate Court of Illinois· 2004-08-27· cited 48×
- Law Offices of David Freyd v. Victoria ChamaraSeventh Circuit· 2022-01-28· cited 40×
- Schivarelli v. CBS, INC.Appellate Court of Illinois· 2002-08-16· cited 38×
- TUNCA v. PainterAppellate Court of Illinois· 2012-02-10· cited 36×
- Maxon v. Ottawa Publishing Co.Appellate Court of Illinois· 2010-06-01· cited 35×
- Doctor's Data, Inc. v. BarrettN.D. Illinois· 2016-03-21· cited 32×
- Giant Screen Sports v. Canadian Imperial BankSeventh Circuit· 2009-01-20· cited 28×
- Hester v. DiazAppellate Court of Illinois· 2004-02-06· cited 28×
- Turner v. 1212 S. Michigan PartnershipAppellate Court of Illinois· 2005-01-31· cited 27×
- Missner v. CliffordAppellate Court of Illinois· 2009-08-12· cited 26×
- Kopka v. Kamensky & RubensteinAppellate Court of Illinois· 2004-12-16· cited 23×
- Kopka v. Kamensky and RubensteinAppellate Court of Illinois· 2004-12-16· cited 22×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co.Supreme Court· 1990-06-21· cited 1,770×
- Bryson v. News America Publications, Inc.Illinois Supreme Court· 1996-10-24· cited 572×
- Kolegas v. Heftel Broadcasting Corp.Illinois Supreme Court· 1992-12-04· cited 396×
- Anderson v. Vanden DorpelIllinois Supreme Court· 1996-04-18· cited 215×
- Mittelman v. WitousIllinois Supreme Court· 1990-04-09· cited 174×
- Levinsky's, Inc. v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.First Circuit· 1997-09-29· cited 139×
- Beck v. SteppIllinois Supreme Court· 1991-09-19· cited 117×
- Ilya D. Levin v. John McPhee the New Yorker Magazine, Inc., and Farrar, Straus & Giroux, Inc.Second Circuit· 1997-07-17· cited 98×
- Lawson v. City of ChicagoAppellate Court of Illinois· 1996-03-22· cited 98×
- Kirchner v. GreeneAppellate Court of Illinois· 1998-02-06· cited 73×
- Doherty v. KahnAppellate Court of Illinois· 1997-06-18· cited 61×
- Andersen v. Resource Economics Corp.Illinois Supreme Court· 1990-01-17· cited 53×
- Kumaran v. BrotmanAppellate Court of Illinois· 1993-06-28· cited 51×
- Barakat v. MatzAppellate Court of Illinois· 1995-03-31· cited 47×
- Golden v. MullenAppellate Court of Illinois· 1998-05-01· cited 45×
- Quinn v. Jewel Food Stores, Inc.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1995-11-22· cited 40×
- Piersall v. Sportsvision of ChicagoAppellate Court of Illinois· 1992-05-26· cited 31×
- Quality Granite Construction Co. v. Hurst-Rosche Engineers, Inc.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1994-04-27· cited 26×
- McGuire v. JankiewiczAppellate Court of Illinois· 1972-11-03· cited 20×
- Hopewell v. VitulloAppellate Court of Illinois· 1998-09-22· cited 1×
Other cases named Hopewell v. Vitullo
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.