Garrido v. Coughlin

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• concluding that a “verbal confrontation” with a guard regarding the 3 guard’s “abusive treatment of another inmate” is not protected conduct
• holding that the inmate plaintiff was not engaged in protected conduct when he had a \verbal confrontation\ with a correctional officer
• distinguishing between an exercise of First Amendment rights and a mere \verbal confrontation\ with prison staff
• inmate’s “verbal confrontation” with correctional officer over 23 the “allegedly abusive treatment of another inmate” did not give rise to a First Amendment 24 retaliation claim
• “While there is a claim of retaliation here ..., it was not for exercise of [the plaintiff's] First Amendment rights; rather, the alleged retaliation arose out of a verbal confrontation.”
• “While there is a claim of retaliation here ..., it was not for exercise of [the plaintiff's] First Amendment rights; rather, the alleged retaliation arose out of a verbal confrontation.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

14 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Torres v. Mazzuca
  S.D. New York· 2003-02-25· cited 65×
• Rivera v. Goord
  S.D. New York· 2000-09-26· cited 40×
• Watson v. McGinnis
  S.D. New York· 1997-05-01· cited 35×
• Santiago v. Miles
  W.D. New York· 1991-10-01· cited 24×
• Webster v. Fischer
  N.D. New York· 2010-03-09· cited 24×
• Zamakshari v. Dvoskin
  S.D. New York· 1995-09-08· cited 21×
• Abdush-Shahid v. Coughlin
  N.D. New York· 1996-06-24· cited 20×
• APA Excelsior III L.P. v. Premiere Technologies, Inc.
  S.D. New York· 1999-05-19· cited 17×
• Heyliger v. Krygier
  W.D. New York· 2018-09-28· cited 9×
• Doolittle v. Ruffo
  N.D. New York· 1994-03-15· cited 6×
• Wright v. Coughlin
  W.D. New York· 1998-12-17· cited 6×
• Taylor v. Sullivan
  S.D. New York· 1997-10-08· cited 4×
• Jackson v. New York Department of Correctional Services
  S.D. New York· 1998-02-11· cited 2×
• Dixon v. Leonardo
  N.D. New York· 1995-05-08· cited 1×

Cites

26 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Estelle v. Gamble
  Supreme Court· 1976-11-30· cited 28,035×
• Harlow v. Fitzgerald
  Supreme Court· 1982-06-24· cited 22,846×
• Gregg v. Georgia
  Supreme Court· 1976-07-22· cited 7,936×
• Rhodes v. Chapman
  Supreme Court· 1981-06-15· cited 6,761×
• Hewitt v. Helms
  Supreme Court· 1983-02-22· cited 3,877×
• Montanye v. Haymes
  Supreme Court· 1976-06-25· cited 1,017×
• James Williams v. Harold J. Smith, Superintendent, and W. Morgan, C.O., Attica Correctional Facility
  Second Circuit· 1986-01-15· cited 571×
• Gary Wayne Freeman v. Richard Rideout
  Second Circuit· 1986-12-30· cited 559×
• Josephina Duchesne as Administratrix of the Estate of Pauline Perez v. Jule M. Sugarman
  Second Circuit· 1977-11-08· cited 380×
• Robert D. Sprouse v. David Babcock, Charles Harper and Ronald G. Welder
  Eighth Circuit· 1989-03-20· cited 326×
• Francisco Franco v. Walter Kelly, Lt. Moscicki and Officer Higley
  Second Circuit· 1988-07-25· cited 299×
• Alfaro Motors, Inc. v. Ward
  Second Circuit· 1987-03-25· cited 137×
• Gill v. Mooney
  Second Circuit· 1987-07-16· cited 136×
• Tony Scott Trucking, Inc. v. National Labor Relations Board
  Supreme Court· 1987-10-13· cited 129×
• Michael A. Bolden, Sr. v. Al Alston, Superintendent, Lincoln Correctional Facility, Nathaniel Hayes, Sergeant and Edward Kirkland, Sergeant
  Second Circuit· 1987-01-28· cited 123×
• Wright v. McMann
  Second Circuit· 1972-03-16· cited 110×
• United States of America Ex Rel. Tyrone B. Larkins v. Russell G. Oswald, Commissioner of Corrections of New York State
  Second Circuit· 1975-01-24· cited 91×
• Owens v. Haas
  Second Circuit· 1979-07-09· cited 73×
• Leady v. United States
  Supreme Court· 1988-03-28· cited 64×
• Belt v. Utah
  Supreme Court· 1988-06-27· cited 47×