Galloway v. United States
Citations
- 319 U.S. 372
- 63 S. Ct. 1077
- 87 L. Ed. 1458
- 1943 U.S. LEXIS 1118
About this case
Galloway v. United States
Galloway v. United States, 319 U.S. 372 (1943), was a Supreme Court of the United States decision in which the Court determined that a directed verdict in a civil case does not deprive litigants of their right to a trial by jury in civil cases under the Seventh Amendment to the United States Constitution .
Galloway, the petitioner, had an "on and off" history with the Army and Navy. In 1930 he began a series of medical examinations with the Veterans' Bureau which labeled him as having psychosis. The petitioner claimed that he was now totally and permanently disabled by reason of insanity brought about by the strain of active service abroad. Petitioner alleged that his insanity had existed before May 31, 1919, the day on which his yearly renewable term insurance policy lapsed for nonpayment of the premium. To prove his case, Petitioner offered a series of six witnesses who knew him before and after service and would comment on his behavioral change. The Petitioner's burden was to demonstrate by more than speculative inference that his condition began on or before May 31, 1919 and continuously existed or progressed until 1930. The Government moved for a directed verdict and the District Court granted it in favor of the Government stating Petitioner did not meet his burden with the evidence he presented. Petitioner claimed the directed verdict denied him his right to a jury trial . The Court of Appeals affirmed the District Court's ruling. The issue in this case was whether a directed verdict denied the Petitioner the right to a jury trial.
Contents
Background: The history of the Seventh Amendment
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Galloway_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background: The history of the Seventh Amendment")
The Seventh Amendment provides that "In suits at common law , where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved..." The Amendment was enacted to prevent oppression by a biased or corrupt court. It was meant as a guarantee that the personal interests or prejudices of certain judges would not serve to defeat the rights and responsibilities of citizens before the courts. To prevent corruption, the Seventh Amendment was written to guarantee a trial by our peers.
The Seventh Amendment has been interpreted to give people the right to a jury trial in many civil matters in federal court, but, seemingly contrary to the wording of the Amendment, not all. For example, lawsuits against the government, and admiralty matters, do not give rise to the right to have a jury decide the case. Rights to sue created by statute (versus the common law, or law created by court decision), including the ability to sue the United States Government, have jury rights created by statute and not the Seventh Amendment, according to the courts.
Federal medical facilities and medical practitioners overseen by the Federal Tort Claims Act are totally exempt from a jury trial. The decision to prevent jury trials in matters such as these was criticized by Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black’s dissenting opinion in a case decided in 1943 wherein he pointed out “a continuation of the gradual process of judicial erosion which in one-hundred-fifty years has slowly worn away a major portion of the essential guarantee of the Seventh Amendment,” Galloway v. United States, 319 U.S. 372, 397 (U.S. 1943).
Facts of the case
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Galloway_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Facts of the case")
The Petitioner, Galloway, claimed that his mental insanity was caused by this involvement in the military and sued the Government. The District Court granted the Government's motion for a directed verdict and held for the Government, citing Petitioner's lack of sufficient evidence to prove his claim. Petitioner appealed, stating that his Seventh Amendment rights of the United States Constitution right to a jury trial was denied because of the directed verdict.
Petitioner seeks benefits for total and permanent disability by reason of insanity he claims existed May 31, 1919. On that day his policy of yearly renewable term insurance lapsed for nonpayment of premium.
No contention that plaintiff 's behavior was erratic prior to arrival in France for World War I
Diagnosed with psychosis and other conditions in 1931 and 1934 at medical examinations
Wife is guardian of his person and estate
Admittedly, plaintiff is disabled by his insanity
Plaintiff argues that strain of active service led to his mental breakdown
Essential to this argument is view that it became total and permanent disability no later than May 31, 1919
Petitioner worked as a longshoreman in Philadelphia and elsewhere prior to enlistment in the Army November 1, 1917. He became a cook in a machine gun battalion. His unit arrived in France in April, 1918. He served actively until September 24. From then to the following January he was in a hospital with influenza. He then returned to active duty. He came back to the United States, and received honorable discharge April 29, 1919. He enlisted in the Navy January 15, 1920, and was discharged for bad conduct in July. The following December he again enlisted in the Army and served until May 1922, when he deserted. Thereafter he was carried on the Army records as a deserter.
In 1930 began a series of medical examinations by Veterans' Bureau physicians. On May 19 that year his condition was diagnosed as "Moron, low grade; observation, dementia praecox, simple type." In November, 1931, further examination gave the diagnosis, "Psychosis with other diseases or conditions (organic disease of the central nervous system — type undetermined)." In July, 1934, still another examination was made, with diagnosis: "Psychosis-manic and depressive insanity incompetent; hypertension, moderate; otitis media, chronic, left; varicose veins left, mild; abscessed teeth roots; myocarditis, mild."
Petitioner's wife, the nominal party in this suit, was appointed guardian of his person and estate in February, 1932. Claim for insurance benefits was made in June, 1934, and was finally denied by the Board of Veterans' Appeals in January, 1936. This suit followed two and a half years later.
Petitioner concededly is now totally and permanently disabled by reason of insanity and has been for some time prior to institution of this suit. It is conceded also that he was sound in mind and body until he arrived in France in April, 1918.
The theory of his case is that the strain of active service abroad brought on an immediate change, which was the beginning of a mental breakdown that has grown worse continuously through all the later years. Essential in this is the view it had become a total and permanent disability not later than May 31, 1919.
The evidence to support this theory falls naturally into three periods, namely, that prior to 1923; the interval from then to 1930; and that following 1930. It consists in proof of incidents occurring in France to show the beginnings of change; testimony of changed appearance and behavior in the years immediately following petitioner's return to the United States as compared with those prior to his departure; the medical evidence of insanity accumulated in the years following 1930; and finally the evidence of a physician, given largely as medical opinion, which seeks to tie all the other evidence together as foundation for the conclusion, expressed as of 1941, that petitioner's disability was total and permanent as of a time not later than May 1919.
Documentary exhibits included military, naval and Veterans' Bureau records. Testimony was given by deposition or at the trial chiefly by five witnesses. One, O'Neill, was a fellow worker and friend from boyhood; two, Wells and Tanikawa, served with petitioner overseas; Lt. Col. Albert K. Mathews, who was an Army chaplain, observed him or another person of the same name at an Army hospital in California during early 1920; and Dr. Wilder, a physician, examined him shortly before the trial and supplied the only expert testimony in his behalf. The petitioner also put into evidence the depositions of Commander Platt and Lt. Col. James E. Matthews, his superior officers in the Navy and the Army, respectively, during 1920-22.
What happened in France during 1918-19 is shown chiefly by Wells and Tanikawa. Wells testified to an incident at Aisonville, where the unit was billeted shortly after reaching France and before going into action. Late at night petitioner created a disturbance, "hollering, screeching, swearing. . . . The men poured out from the whole section." Wells did not see the incident, but heard petitioner swearing at his superior officers and saw "the result, a black eye for Lt. Warner." However, he did not see "who gave it to him."[4] Wells personally observed no infraction of discipline except this incident, and did not know what brought it on. Petitioner's physical appearance was good, he "carried on his duties as a cook all right," and the witness did not see him after June 1, except for about three days in July when he observed petitioner several times at work feeding stragglers.
Tanikawa, Hawaiian-born citizen, served with petitioner from the latter's enlistment until September, 1918, when Galloway was hospitalized, although the witness thought they had fought together and petitioner was "acting queer" at the Battle of the Argonne in October. At Camp Greene, North Carolina, petitioner was "just a regular soldier, very normal, . . . pretty neat." After reaching France "he was getting nervous . . ., kind of irritable, always picking a fight with other soldiers." This began at Aisonville. Tanikawa saw Galloway in jail, apparently before June. It is not clear whether these are references to the incident Wells described.
Tanikawa described another incident in June "when we were on the Marne," the Ger
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding the right to jury trial attaches only if an issue requiring resolution by a jury is presented
- explaining that a motion for directed verdict does not violate the right to trial by jury
- expressing concern regarding the “uncertainty and the variety of conclusions which follows from an effort at purely historical accuracy”
- [T]he jury [is] allowed to make reasonable inferences from facts proven in evidence having a reasonable tendency to sustain them.”
- “[T]he essential requirement is that mere speculation be not allowed to do duty for probative facts, after making due allowance for all reasonably possible inferences favoring the party whose case is attacked.”
- “[T]he essential requirement [for a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence] is that mere speculation be not allowed to do duty for probative facts, after making due allowance for all reasonably possible inferences favoring the party whose case is attacked.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Rutledge, Black, Douglas, Murphy
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
340 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Adickes v. S. H. Kress & Co.Supreme Court· 1970-06-01· cited 15,427×
- Whitley v. AlbersSupreme Court· 1986-03-04· cited 6,155×
- Parklane Hosiery Co. v. ShoreSupreme Court· 1979-01-09· cited 4,229×
- MARKMAN Et Al. v. WESTVIEW INSTRUMENTS, INC., Et Al.Supreme Court· 1996-04-29· cited 3,226×
- Brill v. Guardian Life Insurance Co. of AmericaSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1995-10-24· cited 3,095×
- Herbert Markman and Positek, Inc. v. Westview Instruments, Inc. And Althon Enterprises, Inc.Federal Circuit· 1995-04-05· cited 2,940×
- Patterson v. New YorkSupreme Court· 1977-06-17· cited 2,751×
- The Boeing Company v. Daniel C. ShipmanFifth Circuit· 1969-04-07· cited 2,445×
- EI Du Pont De Nemours & Co. v. RobinsonTexas Supreme Court· 1996-07-08· cited 1,699×
- Beacon Theatres, Inc. v. WestoverSupreme Court· 1959-05-25· cited 1,664×
- Republic Steel Corp. v. MaddoxSupreme Court· 1965-01-25· cited 1,309×
- Tull v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1987-04-28· cited 1,016×
- Lehman v. NakshianSupreme Court· 1981-06-26· cited 905×
- Tennant v. Peoria & Pekin Union Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1944-02-14· cited 904×
- Orme School v. ReevesArizona Supreme Court· 1990-12-06· cited 801×
- Draper v. WashingtonSupreme Court· 1963-03-18· cited 654×
- Brady v. Southern Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1944-02-14· cited 638×
- Unnamed caseThird Circuit· 1982-07-16· cited 539×
- Wilbur L. LOVELACE, Appellant, v. SHERWIN-WILLIAMS COMPANY, AppelleeFourth Circuit· 1982-06-15· cited 427×
- Edward J. Sweeney & Sons, Inc., and Mission Gas Oil Company, Inc. And Petroleum Products Co. v. Texaco, IncThird Circuit· 1980-11-03· cited 334×
Cites
53 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bridges v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1941-12-08· cited 874×
- Dimick v. SchiedtSupreme Court· 1935-01-07· cited 819×
- Improvement Company v. MunsonSupreme Court· 1872-04-22· cited 765×
- Sparf v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1895-01-21· cited 757×
- Montgomery Ward & Co. v. DuncanSupreme Court· 1940-12-09· cited 731×
- Gunning v. CooleySupreme Court· 1930-03-12· cited 665×
- Gasoline Products Co. v. Champlin Refining Co.Supreme Court· 1931-05-18· cited 659×
- Parsons v. Bedford, Breedlove, & RobesonSupreme Court· 1830-02-18· cited 609×
- Ex Parte PetersonSupreme Court· 1920-06-01· cited 576×
- Oscanyan v. Arms Co.Supreme Court· 1881-04-25· cited 566×
- Aetna Insurance v. Kennedy Ex Rel. BogashSupreme Court· 1937-05-17· cited 531×
- Pennsylvania Railroad v. ChamberlainSupreme Court· 1933-02-13· cited 425×
- Funk v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1933-12-11· cited 406×
- Slocum v. New York Life InsuranceSupreme Court· 1913-04-21· cited 368×
- Nye v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1941-04-14· cited 357×
- Lumbra v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1934-01-08· cited 272×
- Baltimore & Carolina Line, Inc. v. RedmanSupreme Court· 1935-06-03· cited 249×
- McElrath v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1880-12-13· cited 246×
- Ewing v. GoodeU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern Ohio· 1897-01-15· cited 233×
- Jacob v. New York CitySupreme Court· 1942-03-30· cited 213×
Other cases named Galloway v. United States
40 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Galloway v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1974-10-17· cited 38×
- Galloway v. United StatesNinth Circuit· 1942-09-01· cited 12×
- Galloway v. United StatesThird Circuit· 2007-06-21· cited 9×
- Galloway v. United StatesD.C. Circuit· 1960-05-26· cited 1×
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2014-10-06· cited 1×
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1956-10-08· cited 1×
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2019-10-07· cited 1×
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2003-12-08
- Galloway v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2010-10-25
- Galloway v. United StatesThird Circuit· 2007-06-21
- Galloway v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2020-01-15
- Galloway v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2019-06-05
- Galloway v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1956-01-05
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2010-10-12
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2011-03-21
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1943-01-04
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2016-03-21
- Galloway v. United StatesFourth Circuit· 2014-12-19
- Galloway v. United StatesW.D. Pennsylvania· 1975-04-14
- Galloway v. United StatesW.D. Pennsylvania· 1975-05-19
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1982-06-01
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2012-05-29
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1990-10-29
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1990-10-29
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1991-01-07
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1991-01-07
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1992-11-02
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1992-11-02
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1993-03-08
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1993-03-08
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1993-03-08
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1993-03-08
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2003-12-08
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2003-12-08
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2010-10-12
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2011-03-21
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1995-10-10
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1995-10-10
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2017-10-02
- Galloway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2013-05-13
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.