Fleming's Estate
Citations
- 265 Pa. 399
- 109 A. 265
- 1919 Pa. LEXIS 569
Syllabus
<p>Wills — Probate—Forgery—Issue devisavit vel non — Refusal of issue — Constitutional law — Trial by jury — Act of March 15, 1882, p. L. ue.</p> <p>1. A dispute as to the facts such as to require the granting of an issue, under the Act of March 15, 1832, P. L. 146, must he a substantial dispute and the evidence, considered as a whole, must be such as would sustain a verdict in favor of the party praying for the issue. Suehtparty is usually the contestant but the rule is the same as to the other side, and, where the trial judge after a careful review of all the testimony would feel constrained to set aside a verdict, if in favor of one side, as contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence, the issue should be refused.</p> <p>2. In a will contest the judge sits as a chancellor, and must consider all the evidence; and the question is not whether a part of the evidence, standing alone, would support a certain verdict, but whether it would be considered as a whole.</p> <p>3. The right to an issue under the statute depends upon whether there is a substantial dispute upon a material matter of fact, and unless there is, the proponent is no more entitled to an issue on a question of forgery than is the contestant on a question of testamentary capacity. The statute does not confine the dispute to any particular question.</p> <p>4. The orphans’ court within its jurisdiction is a court of equity, although not technically so called, and proceedings therein on will contests are, as a rule, equitable in form and substance. The usual grounds upon which such contests are ba.sed, to wit, “lack of testamentary capacity,” “undue influence,” “fraud” and “forgery” are of equitable cognizance; and for either, when satisfactorily proven, chancery may decree the cancellation of a written instrument. Fraud, of which forgery is a glaring example, is one of the principal grounds of equity jurisdiction, and, as a general rule, equity may decree the cancellation of a written instrument found
Judges: Brown, Frazer, Kephart, Moschzisker, Simpson, Walling
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Robert Golden, Attorney-In-Fact for Leah Golden Donald Earwood, of the Estate of Helen Earwood v. David S. Golden Darlene KoposkoThird Circuit· 2004-09-03· cited 70×
- Tetlow's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1921-02-28· cited 60×
- Berkowitz v. Mayflower Securities, Inc.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1974-03-25· cited 47×
- Cross's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-06-23· cited 37×
- Henry's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-02-26· cited 19×
- Setlock v. SutilaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1971-10-12· cited 19×
- Leisey's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-05-27· cited 12×
- Molden WillSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1957-01-17· cited 12×
- May v. Fidelity Trust Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1953-10-15· cited 11×
- Buechley's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-06-23· cited 10×
- Tonkin v. TonkinSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1953-01-20· cited 8×
- Manzer v. WycoffSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1922-04-17· cited 7×
- Fleming's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-04-14· cited 5×
- Duross WillSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-04-20· cited 4×
- Golden v. GoldenThird Circuit· 2004-09-03
- Bellows's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-01-07
- Cranmer's EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1923-07-10
- Byer's EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1928-06-29
- Freihofer's EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1936-03-20
- Spungin's AppealDauphin County Court of Common Pleas· 1938-02-28
Cites
48 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Phillips' EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1914-02-09· cited 96×
- Cutler's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-06-22· cited 92×
- Byers & Davis v. CommonwealthSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1862-07-01· cited 66×
- Schmidt v. SchmidtSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1891-12-07· cited 45×
- Haines v. LevinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1866-01-23· cited 41×
- Wilson v. MitchellSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1882-12-30· cited 39×
- Caughey v. BridenbaughSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-03-14· cited 32×
- Pennsylvania Co. for Insurance on Lives & Granting Annuities v. Franklin Fire InsuranceSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-04-19· cited 30×
- Mactavish v. Kent Circuit JudgeMichigan Supreme Court· 1899-12-12· cited 27×
- Church v. RulandSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1870-03-24· cited 26×
- Smith v. BonsallSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1835-02-02· cited 24×
- Morgan v. ReelSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1905-10-30· cited 23×
- North Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. SnowdenSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1862-05-10· cited 22×
- Rhines v. ClarkSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1866-01-08· cited 21×
- Vernon v. KirkSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1858-07-01· cited 17×
- Estate of SharplessSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1890-04-21· cited 17×
- Keller v. LawsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-06-03· cited 17×
- Johnson's AppealSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1886-10-04· cited 16×
- Whipple v. EddyIllinois Supreme Court· 1896-03-28· cited 15×
- Wright v. FultzIndiana Supreme Court· 1894-09-26· cited 15×
Other cases named Fleming's Estate
6 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Fleming's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1907-04-22· cited 18×
- Fleming's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-04-14· cited 5×
- Fleming's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1908-01-06· cited 1×
- Fleming's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1907-07-01
- Fleming's EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1933-06-30
- Fleming's EstateElk County Orphans' Court· 1938-04-28
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.