Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 12/27/2006
Commonwealth v. Meals
Citations
- 912 A.2d 213
- 590 Pa. 110
- 2006 Pa. LEXIS 2518
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that a sufficiency of the 5 evidence claim is a question of law
- holding that this Court erred in reweighing the SVP evidence presented to the trial court; “the Superior Court stepped beyond its authority when it reweighed the evidence, giving more weight to the ‘absent’ factors than those found and relied upon by the trial court”
- holding a reviewing court should not assign excessive importance to “absent” factors than those found and relied upon by the trial court
- holding that this Court erred in reweighing the SVP evidence presented to the trial court; “the Superior Court stepped beyond its authority when it reweighed the evidence, giving more weight to the ‘absent’ factors than those found and relied upon by the trial court”
- suggesting that offender may meet SVP criteria even if he does not necessarily meet all specific or technical criteria of the DSM–IV, the diagnostic manual that preceded the DSM-V
- noting that it is improper for this Court to reweigh the evidence and give “more weight to ‘absent’ factors than to those found and relied upon by the trial court[.]”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cappy, Castille, Newman, Saylor, Eakin, Baer, Former, Nigro
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
35 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Commonwealth v. SanchezSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-12-21· cited 300×
- Commonwealth v. RatsamySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2007-11-20· cited 275×
- Commonwealth v. BrooksSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-10-07· cited 203×
- Commonwealth v. BakerSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-06-27· cited 184×
- Commonwealth v. FeuchtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-08-04· cited 179×
- Commonwealth v. PrendesSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-07-22· cited 151×
- Commonwealth v. MartinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-09-24· cited 132×
- Commonwealth v. HollingsheadSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-02-19· cited 104×
- Morris v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 2011-12-07· cited 92×
- Commonwealth v. StephensSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-07-11· cited 85×
- In the Interest of S.T.S., Jr.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-08-15· cited 80×
- Commonwealth v. SimsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2007-04-18· cited 79×
- Commonwealth v. FuentesSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-03-17· cited 66×
- Commonwealth v. HansonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-12-27· cited 50×
- Commonwealth v. MorganSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-03-24· cited 39×
- In the Interest of D.S.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-02-21· cited 38×
- Commonwealth v. BishopSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2007-11-16· cited 36×
- In the Interest of D.Y.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-12-13· cited 32×
- Commonwealth v. GeiterSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2007-07-09· cited 31×
- In RE: S.M. Appeal Of: S.M.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-12-15· cited 28×
Cites
10 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Commonwealth v. MaldonadoSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-12-18· cited 205×
- Commonwealth v. DavidoSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-02-25· cited 114×
- Commonwealth v. SmithSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1989-12-22· cited 106×
- Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. DenglerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-12-30· cited 96×
- McMahon v. YoungSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1971-04-22· cited 86×
- Commonwealth v. WestonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2000-04-17· cited 74×
- Commonwealth v. SanfordSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2004-12-21· cited 55×
- Commonwealth v. KrouseSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2002-05-20· cited 49×
- Commonwealth v. FreySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-08-22· cited 28×
- Commonwealth v. MealsSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2004-01-26· cited 9×
Other cases named Commonwealth v. Meals
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.