Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 8/22/2011
Commonwealth v. Hutchinson
Citations
- 25 A.3d 277
- 611 Pa. 280
- 2011 Pa. LEXIS 1993
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the authority to concede liability for murder rests solely with the defendant, and counsel has no authority to present a diminished capacity defense absent the defendant’s concession of liability
- holding that the defendant was not sufficiently provoked into heat of passion by argument with victim occurring shortly before murder or by other serious issues in relationship
- holding that where trial counsel prepared and presented the defense that the petitioner sought based on his claim of non-involvement in the murder, the petitioner failed to establish that trial counsel was ineffective for failing to investigate a diminished capacity defense
- noting that diminished capacity “is an extremely limited defense” that requires either a “mental defect” or intoxication
- stating that “[t]he PCRA court’s credibility determinations are binding on [an appellate c]ourt when they are supported by the record.”
- explaining that “cumulative prejudice from individual claims may be properly assessed in the aggregate” only when “the individual claims have failed due to lack of prejudice[.]”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: McCaffery, Castille, Eakin, Baer, Melvin, Todd, Saylor
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
64 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Commonwealth v. SpotzSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-01-17· cited 986×
- Commonwealth v. Mason, L., ApltSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-12-29· cited 619×
- Commonwealth v. RoneySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-10-30· cited 496×
- Commonwealth v. SneedSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-06-04· cited 398×
- Commonwealth v. BlakeneySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-12-29· cited 395×
- Commonwealth v. BusanetSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-10-19· cited 369×
- Commonwealth v. BrownSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2018-10-17· cited 303×
- Commonwealth v. SepulvedaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-11-28· cited 299×
- Commonwealth v. SanchezSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-12-17· cited 272×
- Commonwealth v. KingSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-11-26· cited 238×
- Commonwealth v. FreelandSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-12-11· cited 212×
- Commonwealth v. JohnsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-04-26· cited 203×
- Commonwealth v. Cousar, B., Aplt.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-02-22· cited 187×
- Commonwealth v. BaumhammersSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-05-27· cited 187×
- Commonwealth v. TharpSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-09-24· cited 187×
- Commonwealth v. SpotzSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-06-26· cited 186×
- Commonwealth v. WeissSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-10-31· cited 185×
- Commonwealth v. Eichinger, J., ApltSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-12-31· cited 169×
- Commonwealth v. WilliamsSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-12-08· cited 169×
- Commonwealth v. BryantSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-05-28· cited 152×
Cites
94 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Strickland v. WashingtonSupreme Court· 1984-06-25· cited 123,578×
- Brady v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1963-05-13· cited 33,902×
- Batson v. KentuckySupreme Court· 1986-04-30· cited 16,401×
- United States v. BagleySupreme Court· 1985-07-02· cited 8,539×
- Kyles v. WhitleySupreme Court· 1995-04-19· cited 6,003×
- Cullen v. PinholsterSupreme Court· 2011-04-04· cited 5,931×
- Commonwealth v. PierceSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1987-06-09· cited 2,071×
- Commonwealth v. GrantSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2002-12-31· cited 1,205×
- Commonwealth v. JohnsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-03-18· cited 958×
- Commonwealth v. HubbardSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1977-01-28· cited 854×
- Commonwealth v. AliSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-12-29· cited 675×
- Commonwealth v. AlbrechtSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1998-11-23· cited 654×
- Commonwealth v. WashingtonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2007-07-18· cited 593×
- Commonwealth v. MarshallSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-05-20· cited 562×
- Commonwealth v. LarkSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2000-02-23· cited 546×
- Commonwealth v. WilliamsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1999-06-04· cited 461×
- Commonwealth v. McGillSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-09-29· cited 412×
- Commonwealth v. Abu-JamalSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1998-10-29· cited 410×
- Commonwealth v. BasemoreSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2000-01-20· cited 404×
- Commonwealth v. SpotzSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-05-02· cited 402×
Other cases named Commonwealth v. Hutchinson
21 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-04-25· cited 129×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2002-10-24· cited 87×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1989-03-15· cited 71×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1981-08-28· cited 52×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1985-08-05· cited 23×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-07-05· cited 17×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1813-09-15· cited 13×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1849-07-05· cited 4×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1993-03-09· cited 3×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1979-08-17· cited 2×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1804-09-15· cited 2×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1863-10-15· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-06-17
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-06-17
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1977-05-04
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1981-12-18
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1982-06-04
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonBerks County Court of Common Pleas· 1996-06-07
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1804-09-15
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonMassachusetts Appeals Court· 2018-07-16
- Commonwealth v. HutchinsonRecorder of Philadelphia· 1846-07-01
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.