Second Circuit· 5/24/2019
Charles v. Orange County
Citations
- 925 F.3d 73
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that \something more than mere negligence\ and \mere medical malpractice\ is necessary to establish deliberate indifference in the Fourteenth Amendment context
- observing that, after Darnell, “[a] plaintiff must show something more than mere negligence to establish deliberate indifference in the Fourteenth Amendment context” (citation and internal quotation marks omitted)
- explaining that conduct constituting deliberate indifference to medical needs in violation of the Eighth Amendment for convicted prisoners would also violate the Fourteenth Amendment rights of pretrial detainees
- noting that “[i]n most cases, the actual medical consequences that flow from the denial of care are highly relevant in determining whether the denial of treatment subjected the detainee to a significant risk of serious harm”
- applying same two-part objective/subjective standard to detainee’s claim for deliberate indifference to serious medical needs under the Fourteenth Amendment
- “A plaintiff must show something more than mere negligence to establish deliberate indifference in the Fourteenth Amendment context.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Lynch, Hall, Bolden
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
11 cases in this archive cite this case.
- E. D. v. Daniel SharkeyThird Circuit· 2019-07-01· cited 164×
- Velasco Lopez v. DeckerSecond Circuit· 2020-10-27· cited 161×
- Francis v. Kings Park Manor, Inc.Second Circuit· 2021-03-25· cited 160×
- Darby v. GreenmanSecond Circuit· 2021-09-16· cited 143×
- Sheri Trozzi v. Lake County, OhioSixth Circuit· 2022-03-29· cited 77×
- Wiggins v. GriffinSecond Circuit· 2023-11-20· cited 44×
- Lara-Grimaldi v. County of PutnamSecond Circuit· 2025-03-27· cited 14×
- Julie Helphenstine v. Lewis CountySixth Circuit· 2023-04-18· cited 6×
- Paykina ex rel. E.L. v. LewinN.D. New York· 2019-05-31· cited 3×
- Robson Xavier Gomes v. US Department of Homeland Security, Acting Secretary et al.D. New Hampshire· 2020-07-01· cited 1×
- J.M. v. SessionsSecond Circuit· 2025-12-23
Cites
22 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Ashcroft v. IqbalSupreme Court· 2009-05-18· cited 149,772×
- Farmer v. BrennanSupreme Court· 1994-06-06· cited 28,443×
- Estelle v. GambleSupreme Court· 1976-11-30· cited 28,035×
- County of Sacramento v. LewisSupreme Court· 1998-05-26· cited 6,212×
- DeShaney v. Winnebago County Department of Social ServicesSupreme Court· 1989-02-22· cited 4,564×
- Cuoco v. MoritsuguSecond Circuit· 2000-07-28· cited 2,979×
- Youngberg v. Romeo Ex Rel. RomeoSupreme Court· 1982-06-18· cited 2,433×
- City of Revere v. Massachusetts General HospitalSupreme Court· 1983-06-27· cited 1,572×
- Darnell v. City of New YorkSecond Circuit· 2017-02-21· cited 1,487×
- Weyant v. OkstSecond Circuit· 1996-12-03· cited 808×
- Chance v. ArmstrongSecond Circuit· 1998-05-07· cited 744×
- Willie Smith v. Nurse Carpenter, Superintendent Wilkinson, Superintendent at Pharsalia Corr. FacilitySecond Circuit· 2003-01-14· cited 644×
- Wakefield v. ThompsonNinth Circuit· 1999-05-27· cited 525×
- Harrison v. BarkleySecond Circuit· 2000-07-17· cited 513×
- Hathaway v. CoughlinSecond Circuit· 1996-11-08· cited 319×
- Matican v. City of New YorkSecond Circuit· 2008-04-23· cited 164×
- Brown Media Corporation v. K&L Gates, LLPSecond Circuit· 2017-04-14· cited 162×
- Edward Koehl v. Stephen Dalsheim, Superintendent Kenley Meritt, Corrections Officer Frank Averill, Corrections OfficerSecond Circuit· 1996-05-31· cited 111×
- Lombardi v. WhitmanSecond Circuit· 2007-04-19· cited 82×
- Kirkendall v. Halliburton, Inc.Second Circuit· 2013-01-29· cited 77×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.