Alford v. Dennis
Citations
- 102 Kan. 403
- 170 P. 1005
- 1918 Kan. LEXIS 52
Syllabus
<p>SYLLABUS BY THE COURT.</p> <p>1. Oil and Gas Lease — Improvident Contract — Cancellation. Rule followed that equity will not cancel a contract which is merely a bad or improvident bargain.</p> <p>2. Same — Breach of. Implied Covenant — Forfeiture. Rule followed that equity will not arbitrarily declare a forfeiture for breach of an implied covenant.-</p> <p>3. Oil and Gas Lease — Failure to Develop — Remedy in Damages— Prompt Development or Cancellation. A lease of two tracts of land, 716 acres and 220 acres respectively, was made in 1902 to prospect for oil and gas, for a term-of ten years and as much longer as gas or oil might be found in paying quantities, the lessees agreeing to pay royalties on all paying wells and binding themselves to commence operations, within six months, and to' complete three wells before January 1, 1904, “no other or additional expense shall be incurred under this lease,” etc. The larger tract was developed and many wells were drilled thereon, but in nearly fourteen years nothing was done towards drilling or developing the smaller tract. Plaintiff succeeded to the ownership of the latter and brought suit to cancel the lease, alleging that there was an implied covenant to prospect and develop his tract as well as the other. No demand was made on the lessees to drill on the plaintiff’s tract prior to the commencement of this action. Held, that-the ordinary rule that equity will not relieve against an improvident bargain prevents an absolute forfeiture, that equity -will not forfeit a contract for the mere breach of one of its implied covenants; but held, also, that the petition stated a cause of of action for some redress, either in damages, if such be ascertainable, or in the alternative that the lessees be required to drill and develop plaintiff’s land within a reasonable, time pursuant to their irriplied covenant, under penalty of' forfeiture, following the doctrine announced in the fourth paragraph of the syllabus of Howerton v. Gas
Judges: Dawson
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
33 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Renner v. Monsanto Chemical Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1960-08-04· cited 32×
- Cowman v. Phillips Petroleum Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1935-12-07· cited 27×
- Kansas Baptist Convention v. Mesa Operating Ltd. PartnershipSupreme Court of Kansas· 1993-10-29· cited 26×
- Temple v. Continental Oil Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1958-01-25· cited 25×
- Severson v. BarstowMontana Supreme Court· 1936-12-23· cited 20×
- Reese Enterprises, Inc. v. LawsonSupreme Court of Kansas· 1976-07-23· cited 19×
- Greenwood v. Texas-Interstate Pipe Line Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1936-04-11· cited 19×
- Berry v. WondraSupreme Court of Kansas· 1952-07-03· cited 18×
- Christiansen v. Virginia Drilling Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1951-01-06· cited 17×
- Rook v. James E. Russell Petroleum, Inc.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1984-03-24· cited 17×
- Brown v. Union Oil Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1923-07-07· cited 17×
- Kahm v. Arkansas River Gas Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1927-02-12· cited 16×
- Webb v. CroftSupreme Court of Kansas· 1926-04-10· cited 15×
- Nigh v. HaasSupreme Court of Kansas· 1934-04-07· cited 15×
- Robbins v. Chevron U.S.A., Inc.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1990-01-19· cited 14×
- Cole v. ButlerSupreme Court of Kansas· 1918-07-06· cited 14×
- Baron v. LymanSupreme Court of Kansas· 1933-01-28· cited 14×
- Stamper v. Jones, Shelburne & Farmer, Inc.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1961-09-18· cited 13×
- Drummond v. AlphinSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1928-03-12· cited 13×
- Harris v. Morris Plan Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1936-11-07· cited 13×
Cites
5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Brewster v. Lanyon Zinc Co.Eighth Circuit· 1905-09-27· cited 220×
- Howerton v. Kansas Natural Gas Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1910-01-08· cited 54×
- Howerton v. Kansas Natural Gas Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1910-05-07· cited 39×
- Rose v. Lanyon Zinc Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1903-12-12· cited 27×
- Davis v. Chautauqua Oil & Gas Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1908-05-09· cited 9×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.