Opinions by Benjamin I. Salinger

Commonwealth v. Zachary Clough

Commonwealth v. Jose Rosado-Nazario

Harold Parsons, on Behalf of Himself and Others Similarly Situated v. the Commerce Insurance Company

Tommy Royal and Bernadette Costa, Individually and on Behalf of Similarly Situated Individuals v. Andrew Metcalf, Judgment Acquisitions Unlimited Inc., and Michael Zola

Massachusetts Premier Soccer LLC D/B/A Global Premier Soccer v. Burns & Levinson LLP and Perry A. Henderson, Jr.

Hector Maza, Monjid Hamdan, and Cortney Mittelsteadt v. Giner, Inc. and Andrew Belt

William I. Koch; Renegade Management, Inc.; And Nauticus Marina, Inc. v. Mark Curley and Bridge Street Marina, LLC

Old Ironsides Energy LLC v. Marsh & McLennan Agency LLC; Marsh LLC; Marsh USA Inc.; John Kurkulonis, Jr.; And Edward D. Fitzgerald

Cmfg Life Insurance Company; Cuna Brokerage Services, Inc.; And Cuna Mutual Insurance Agency, Inc. v. Earnest Consulting Group, LLC; Commonwealth Financial Corporation; Om Financial Group, LLC; Bruce Bauer; Brooks Berardi; Michael Bremer; John Ellis

Boston Seaport M1&2 Land, LLC v. Commissioner of Revenue

Moshe Yanai, Rachel Yanai, and Michal International Investment LLC v. Zack Keinan, Individually and as General Partner of Scintilla Holdings, Ltd.; Scintilla Holdings, Ltd., as General Partner of Scintilla Fund, L.P.; And Boaz Toshav

Hembio, Inc. F/K/A Hemera Biosciences, Inc. v. Paul Fireman, Adam Rogers, and Hemera Biosciences, LLC

Clear Blue Specialty Insurance Company v. R-Svp II, L.L.C.; Bp Sidecar Investment III, LLC; Bpi Credit 3, LLC; Bpi Credit 4, LLC; And Bpi Credit 5, LLC

Steven B. Deutsch and Joyce I. Greenberg v. Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange

In Re Revo Mg, LLC

Enfield Builders, Inc. v. the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Division of Capital Asset Management and Maintenance

Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Mv Realty Pbc, LLC; Mv of Massachusetts, LLC; Mv Brokerage of Massachusetts, LLC; Mv Realty Holdings, LLC; Mv Realty Receivables 1, LLC; Mv Receivables II, LLC; Mv Receivables III

Moshe Yanai, Rachel Yanai, and Michal International Investment LLC v. Zack Keinan, Individually and as General Partner of Scintilla Holdings, Ltd.; Scintilla Holdings, Ltd., as General Partner of Scintilla Fund, L.P.

Michael F. Holick, ph.D., M.D. v. Boston Medical Center and Evans Medical Foundation, Inc.

694 Worcester St LLC and Others v. Ccp Counter Manor 0507 LLC and Others

Moshe Yanai, Rachel Yanai, and Michal International Investment LLC v. Zack Keinan, Individually and as General Partner of Scintilla Holdings, Ltd.; Scintilla Holdings, Ltd., as General Partner of Scintilla Fund, L.P.; And Boaz Toshav

James Lyons v. Secretary of State William Galvin, Clerk of the House Timothy Carrol, Clerk of the Senate Michael Hurley, and Attorney General Andrea Campbell, in Their Official Capacities

Impact Technology Licensing , LLC, and Boston Technology Consultants Group, Inc. (d/B/A Impact Technology Development) v. Barry-Wehmiller Companies, Inc.; Carr Biosystems, LLC; Pneumatic Scale corp.(d/B/A \pneumatic Scale Angelus Corp.\); \\

Sheena Marandino and Others, on Behalf of Themselves and All Others Similarly Situated v. Peterson's Oil Services Inc. and Others

Michael Gerhardt and Lauren Seaverns v. Robert S. Burr; College Street Partners, LLC; 140 Commonwealth Avenue – Danvers, LLC; And Hawthorne Hill Development LLC

Massachusetts Gaming Commission v. Landmark American Insurance Company

John W. Baldwin, Jr., Robert N. Baldwin, James R. Baldwin, and John E. Baldwin v. Thomas P. Connor, Jr., Maria H. Connor, John J. Connor, II, Nicholas Kourtis, Polyvinyl Films, Inc., and Indusol, Inc.

Robert Sheinkopf (Individually), Sybil Sheinkopf (Individually), and Marilyn Sheinkopf Newman and Laure Sheinkopf as Trustees of the Robert Sheinkopf Family Irrevocable Trust v. Pacific Life Insurance Company

Joseph E. Szawlowski, as Trustee of the Stan and Mary Ellen Szawlowski Family Trust v. George W. Price and Others v. James F. Martin and Others

Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Mv Realty Pbc, LLC; Mv of Massachusetts, LLC; Mv Brokerage of Massachusetts, LLC; Mv Realty Holdings, LLC; Mv Realty Receivables 1, LLC; Mv Receivables II, LLC; Mv Receivables III, LLC

Arctaris Opportunity Zone Fund 2020, LLC v. Lc Baltimore 1b LLC, Lc Baltimore Development, LLC, and La Cité, LLC, Defendants; And Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., as Trustee

Greg Miller: Wellesley Asset Management, Inc.; And Michael Miller v. Darlene Murphy

Colin Booth v. Evan Smith, Katherine Faulkner, and Highland Park Technologies, Inc.

Waltham Centerpoint I Investment Group, LLC v. Generation Bio Co

Rff Family Partnership Lp and Saugus Developer LLC v. Shops at Saugus LLC and Town of Saugus

John W. Baldwin, Jr., Robert N. Baldwin, James R. Baldwin, and John E. Baldwin v. Thomas P. Connor, Jr., Maria H. Connor, John J. Connor, II, Nicholas Kourtis, Polyvinyl Films, Inc., and Indusol, Inc.

Fbt Everett Realty, LLC v. Massachusetts Gaming Commission v. Wynn Ma, LLC

Commonwealth v. Justice Gilkes

Giul, LLC v. Shenghuo Medical, LLC, D/B/A K2 Medical; Michael J. Antonoplos, Richard P. Blumberg, Mark L. Faupel, and Mark S. Pearlstein

eri/integral Holdings LLC v. Integral Fund I Investor, LLC; Iif1 Gp, LLC; Integral Development LLC; Eljp Real Estate, LLC; Egbert L.J. Perry; and Integral Investment Fund LLP

W. Hugo Van Vuuren v. Lowenstein Sandler LLP and Marie Defalco

Michael Gerhardt and Lauren Seaverns v. Robert S. Burr; College Street Partners, LLC; 140 Commonwealth Avenue – Danvers, LLC; And Hawthorne Hill Development LLC

Leo Bertolino, as Trustee for Leo P. Bertolino Trust, and Others v. Terence Fracassa and Frederick McDonald

Adrienne E. Cohen, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Bret A. Cohen v. Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough, LLP

Predictsoft, Inc. v. Boston Meridian, LLC; John Siracuse; John C. Raby; And Garrett Palm v. Predictsoft, Inc. and Saqib Syed

Kim Luz, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated v. Bayada Home Health Care, Inc.; David Baiada; And Mark Baiada

Jarret McGilloway and Linda Estrella, on Behalf of Themselves and All Others Similarly Situated v. Safety Insurance Company / Adam Ercolini, on Behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly Situated v. the Commerce Insurance Company

Tommy Royal and Bernadette Costa, Individually and on Behalf of Similarly Situated Individuals v. Judgment Acquisitions Unlimited Inc. (d/B/A Judgment Acquisitions Unlimited) and Michael Zola

Brammer Bio LLC v. Boston Properties Limited Partnership; 290 Binney LLC; The Trustees of Fourteen Cambridge Center Trust; And Turner Construction Company

Gem Plumbing and Heating Services, LLC v. Rusty's, Inc; Michael J. Roderick; Thomas R. Hansen; Air Pros Ma, LLC; Michael Hansen; And Paul Neary

Arco National Holdings, Inc. v. Laborers' International Union of North America; Massachusetts & Northern New England Laborers' District Council of the Laborers' International Union of North America; Laborers' International Union of North America Local 22

10 High Street Restaurant, LLC v. John F. Power and John Niles, Trustees of the Knh Realty Trust John F. Power and John Niles, Trustees of the Knh Realty Trust v. Seth Greenberg

Robert Sheinkopf (Individually), Sybil Sheinkopf (Individually), and Marilyn Sheinkopf Newman and Laure Sheinkopf as Trustees of the Robert Sheinkopf Family Irrevocable Trust v. Pacific Life Insurance Company, Sean M. Flynn

Leo Bertolino, as Trustee for Leo P. Bertolino Trust, and Others v. Terence Fracassa and Frederick McDonald

John W. Baldwin, Jr., Robert N. Baldwin, James R. Baldwin, and John E. Baldwin v. Thomas P. Connor, Jr., Maria H. Connor, John J. Connor, II, Nicholas Kourtis, Polyvinyl Films, Inc., and Indusol, Inc.

International Association of Fire Fighters v. National Fire

Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Inc. the Brigham and Women's Hospital, Inc. Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Inc. Joslin Diabetes Center, Inc. President and Fellows of Harvard College the Children's Hospital Corporation v. Matep LLC

Rff Family Partnership Lp and Saugus Developer LLC v. Shops at Saugus LLC and Town of Saugus

Nicole MacTaggart and Others / Glenn Wilder and Others / Irene Ray and Others / Anne Weiss and Others / Dianne L. Depalma and Others / Benjamin Brophy and Others / Robert Johnson and Others / Patricia Beckett and Others / Mary D. Lombardi

Commonwealth v. Ethan Isert

Commonwealth v. Makayla Lowe

Szawlowski Potato Farms, Inc., and Others v. Joseph E. Szawlowski, as the Special Personal Representative of the Estate of Stanley E. Szawlowski, and as Trustee of the Stan and Mary Ellen Szawlowski Family Trust

Susan Leavitt v. Welch & Forbes, LLC

Rebecca Wetteman v. Nucleus Research, Inc. and Ian Campbell, and Nucleus Holding LLC, Reach and Apply

Medmarc Casualty Insurance Company v. Harvard Bioscience, Inc. and Biostage, Inc.

Medmarc Casualty Insurance Company v. Harvard Bioscience, Inc. and Biostage, Inc.

Barry Graham Armstrong v. Office of the Secretary of the Commonwealth Securities Division

Commonwealth v. Kevin Santiago

Umnv 205–207 Newbury, LLC v. Caffé Nero Americas Inc.

Maura Healey, in Her Official Capacity as Attorney General for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Uber Technologies, Inc. and Lyft, Inc.

Commonwealth v. Credit Acceptance Corporation

Commonwealth v. Hipolito Masa, Jr.

Michael Baranofsky, Kimberly Gale, and Lawrence Essember, on Behalf of Themselves and All Others Similarly Situated v. Rousselot Peabody, Inc.

Craig Harrison and Barbara Ruchie, on Behalf of Themselves and All Others Similarly Situated v. Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority

Kyana Jinks, Antwione Taylor, Lee Tremblay, and Others, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated v. Credico (Usa) LLC, Dfw Consultants, Inc., and Jason Ward

Commcan, Inc., and Others v. Charlie Baker, in His Official Capacity as Governor of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Commerce Insurance Company v. First Help Financial, LLC and Marcio R. Rodrigues-Pessoa

Commonwealth v. David Fraize

Oxford Global Resources, LLC v. Jeremy Hernandez

Bassett v. Triton Technologies, Inc.

Meunier v. Market Strategies, Inc.

Netscout Systems, Inc. v. Hohenstein

Netscout Systems, Inc. v. Hohenstein

Mirra v. Mirra

Silva v. Todisco Services, Inc.

Whittier IPA, Inc. v. Steward Health Care Network, Inc.

Governo Law Firm, LLC v. CMBG3 Law, LLC

Commonwealth v. Robinson

Commonwealth v. Douglas

Murby v. Children's Hospital Corp.

Chen v. Wen Jing Huang

Murby v. Children's Hospital Corp.

Demoulas v. Demoulas Super Markets, Inc.

Sgarzi v. Sharkansky & Co. LLP

Cumberland Farms, Inc. v. Tenacity Construction, Inc.

Murby v. Children's Hospital Corp.

Gillette Co. v. Provost

Boston Globe Media Partners, LLC v. Retirement Board

Baker v. Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & Dorr, LLP

Kelleher v. Squires