York v. Washburn
Citations
- 129 F. 564
- 64 C.C.A. 132
- 1904 U.S. App. LEXIS 4071
Syllabus
<p>1. Federal Courts — Actions—Trial by Court — Findings—Effect.</p> <p>Where an action at law is tried to the court without a jury, the finding of the court, given under, the circumstances recited in this opinion, and whether regarded as general or special, has the same effect as the verdict of a jury, and prevents any inquiry on appeal as to whether it is sustained by the evidence.</p> <p>2. Opinion of Trial Judge — Not a Special Finding.</p> <p>An opinion of the trial judge, delivered in writing and setting forth the reasons for his decision, does not, by being copied into the judgment entry, become a special finding of the ultimate facts, in the nature of a special verdict.</p> <p>8. Statute op Kbauds — State Laws — State Decisions — Rules op Peopebty —Effect in Fedebal Couets.</p> <p>Whether an oral contract for a lease of real property for more than a year, not complying with the statute of frauds of the state where the property is situated, is a nullity or unenforceable only at the election of the parties, is not a question of general jurisprudence or of commercial or mercantile law, but a rule of property, which must be determined in the federal courts according to the decisions of the highest judicial tribunal of the state where such property is located.</p> <p>4. Same — Lease foe Mobe than a Yeae — Eaenest Money — Recoveey.</p> <p>An oral contract for the letting of real property located in Minnesota for more than a year, not complying with the statute of frauds of such state, though unenforceable, is not void, and hence the contemplated lessee cannot recover earnest money paid thereon; the lessor being ready, willing, and able to perform.</p> <p>11 3. State laws as rules of decision in federal courts, see notes to Griffin v. Wheel Co., 9 C. C. A. 548; Wilson v. Perrin, 11 C. C. A. 71; Hill v. Hite. 29 C. C. A. 553.</p>
Judges: Devanter
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Fleischmann Construction Co. v. United States Ex Rel. ForsbergSupreme Court· 1926-03-01· cited 226×
- United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. Board of Com'rs of Woodson CountyEighth Circuit· 1906-03-30· cited 86×
- Lahman v. Burnes Nat. BankEighth Circuit· 1927-07-20· cited 30×
- United States v. Sioux City Stock Yards Co.Eighth Circuit· 1909-02-12· cited 26×
- G. Amsinck & Co. v. Springfield Grocer Co.Eighth Circuit· 1925-08-04· cited 23×
- Keeley v. Ophir Hill Consol. Mining Co.Eighth Circuit· 1909-04-09· cited 15×
- Felker v. First Nat. Bank of CincinnatiEighth Circuit· 1912-03-29· cited 15×
- Merriam v. HuseltonEighth Circuit· 1930-12-06· cited 14×
- Bell v. Union Pac. R.Eighth Circuit· 1912-03-04· cited 12×
- Gibson v. LutherEighth Circuit· 1912-04-10· cited 12×
- Noble v. C. Crane & Co.Sixth Circuit· 1909-04-15· cited 11×
- Clayton v. TibbensEighth Circuit· 1924-04-03· cited 11×
- Odegard v. General Casualty & Surety Co.Eighth Circuit· 1930-09-08· cited 10×
- Northern Pac. Ry. Co. v. Van Dusen Harrington Co.D. Minnesota· 1929-10-05· cited 9×
- Holford v. CroweSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1917-02-02· cited 8×
- Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co. v. George A. Hormel & Co.Eighth Circuit· 1917-03-05· cited 8×
- Jackson v. Mutual Life Ins.Eighth Circuit· 1911-03-24· cited 7×
- Eastern Oil Co. v. HolcombEighth Circuit· 1914-02-23· cited 7×
- Northern Idaho & Montana Power Co. v. A. L. Jordan Lumber Co.Ninth Circuit· 1920-02-02· cited 7×
- Hayden v. Ogden Savings BankEighth Circuit· 1907-11-29· cited 5×
Cites
30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Burgess v. SeligmanSupreme Court· 1883-01-29· cited 389×
- Hartford Fire Insurance v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1899-11-06· cited 166×
- Williams v. EgglestonSupreme Court· 1898-05-02· cited 153×
- Bauserman v. BluntSupreme Court· 1893-03-06· cited 147×
- Lehnen v. DicksonSupreme Court· 1893-03-06· cited 140×
- Township of Pine Grove v. TalcottSupreme Court· 1874-05-18· cited 107×
- Martinton v. FairbanksSupreme Court· 1885-01-05· cited 91×
- Dooley v. PeaseSupreme Court· 1901-01-21· cited 89×
- Supervisors v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1873-11-24· cited 60×
- Wilson v. Merchants' Loan & Trust Co. of ChicagoSupreme Court· 1901-12-02· cited 59×
- Louisville & Nashville Railroad v. KentuckySupreme Court· 1902-01-06· cited 52×
- Robinson & Co. v. BeltSupreme Court· 1902-10-27· cited 51×
- Kentucky Life & Acc. Ins. v. HamiltonSixth Circuit· 1894-05-08· cited 44×
- First Nat. Bank v. GlassEighth Circuit· 1897-03-22· cited 40×
- Wilkes County v. ColerSupreme Court· 1901-03-25· cited 39×
- Mercantile Trust Co. v. WoodEighth Circuit· 1894-02-12· cited 38×
- Hughes County v. LivingstonEighth Circuit· 1900-10-09· cited 36×
- Dickinson v. The Planters' BankSupreme Court· 1873-01-20· cited 30×
- Barnard v. RandleEighth Circuit· 1901-09-23· cited 28×
- McKinney v. HarvieSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1887-12-19· cited 22×
Other cases named York v. Washburn
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.