Winton v. Amos
Citations
- 255 U.S. 373
- 41 S. Ct. 342
- 65 L. Ed. 684
- 1921 U.S. LEXIS 1770
Syllabus
<p>1. The acts authorizing these suits against Mississippi Choctaws (April 26, 1906, c. 1876, § 9, 34 Stat. 140; May 29, 1908, c. 216, § 27, 35 Stat. 457), contemplate not an action in personam to es-' tablish personal liability against individual Indians, or a group of them, but an equitable class suit against those who, by successfully asserting citizenship in the Choctaw Nation, acquired allotments out of the tribal land and participation in funds held in trust by the United States, to impose an equitable charge upon their lands and interests, so acquired, for a reasonable and proportionate contribution towards the value of the services rendered and expenses incurred by the claimants in securing such lands and interests for the class. Pp. 375, 391, 397.</p> <p>2. The acts, in treating the Indians affected as a class, and in providing for their representation by the Governor of the Choctaw Nation for the purpose of receiving notice of the suit and by the Attorney General of the United States for the purpose of appearing and defending it, and in omitting to make the United States a party, are within. the constitutional authority of .Congress over tribal Indians and their property, and do not deprive the Indians of thejr property, in violation of the Fifth Amendment, although they.are citizens. P. 392.</p> <p>3. For proper professional services rendered and expenses incurred - in successfully promoting legislation to rescue substantial property interests of a class of beneficiaries under a trust of a public.nature, it is equitable to impose a charge for reimbursement and compensation upon the interests so secured, the same as if a like result had been reached through litigation .in the courts.- P. 392.</p> <p>4. Where such services, enuring to the benefit of a class, are performed under express contracts with some of its members, the party performing them may exact compensation from such individuals directly, under the express contracts if they are valid or under im
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- allowing attorneys' fees in equity for legislative work substantially instrumental in creating a fund, citing Trustees v. Greenough, 105 U.S. 527, 26 L.Ed. 1157 (1881)
- “It is thoroughly established that Congress has plenary authority over the Indians . . . and full power to legislate concerning their tribal prop erty”
- “It is thoroughly established that Con- gress has plenary authority over the Indians and all their tribal relations”
- “It is thoroughly established that Congress has plenary authority over the Indians and all their tribal relations, and full power to legislate concerning their tribal property.”
- Congress’ “plenary authority” is based on Indians’ “condition of tutelage or dependency”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Pitney, Van Devanter McReynolds
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
79 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. WheelerSupreme Court· 1978-03-22· cited 1,076×
- Botany Worsted Mills v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1929-01-02· cited 788×
- Merrion v. Jicarilla Apache TribeSupreme Court· 1982-01-25· cited 568×
- United States v. Jicarilla Apache NationSupreme Court· 2011-06-13· cited 259×
- United States v. JohnSupreme Court· 1978-06-23· cited 202×
- George Groundhog v. W. W. KeelerTenth Circuit· 1971-05-05· cited 178×
- Haaland v. BrackeenSupreme Court· 2023-06-15· cited 138×
- Madeline Colliflower v. John Garland, Sheriff of County of BlaineNinth Circuit· 1965-02-04· cited 61×
- United States v. Esnault-PelterieSupreme Court· 1936-12-07· cited 57×
- Sekaquaptewa v. MacDonaldNinth Circuit· 1976-09-27· cited 55×
- United States v. HellardSupreme Court· 1944-05-22· cited 52×
- Hendrickson v. MeredithSupreme Court of Virginia· 1933-09-21· cited 52×
- United States v. BryantSupreme Court· 2016-06-13· cited 48×
- Ralph R. Tom v. William Sutton, Jailor, Whatcom CountyNinth Circuit· 1976-03-10· cited 42×
- United States of America v. State Tax Commission of the State of MississippiFifth Circuit· 1974-12-13· cited 41×
- People v. CarmenCalifornia Supreme Court· 1954-08-17· cited 41×
- Hawes v. Colorado Division of InsuranceSupreme Court of Colorado· 2003-03-03· cited 37×
- Porter v. HallArizona Supreme Court· 1928-11-02· cited 37×
- El Pueblo de Puerto Rico v. Sánchez ValleSupreme Court of Puerto Rico· 2015-03-20· cited 32×
- Big Cola Corporation v. World Bottling Co.Sixth Circuit· 1943-04-08· cited 30×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Winton v. Amos
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.