Sixth Circuit· 2/6/2004
William H. Smith v. Betty Mitchell, Warden
Citations
- 348 F.3d 177
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that counsel was not deficient and that petitioner was not prejudiced because “virtually all of the mitigating elements that [petitioner] complains of” were presented
- holding that comparative proportionality review is not constitutionally required
- noting that, on habeas review, the issue is “the right to a fair trial, not to perfect representation”
- finding no prejudice where mitigation expert relied on earlier reports addressing competency and considered the same types of sources Dr. Fridman considered here
- finding no prejudice where, other than inconclusive evidence of a brain disorder, defendant “failed to point to any mitigating evidence that was not actually presented”
- finding no prejudice where “virtually all of the mitigating elements that [the petitioner] complain[ed] of were presented via [the mitigation expert’s] testimony and her mitigation report”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Suhrheinrich, Batchelder, Cole
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
74 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Willie Williams, Jr. v. Margaret Bagley, WardenSixth Circuit· 2004-08-13· cited 361×
- Jeffrey Wogenstahl v. Betty MitchellSixth Circuit· 2012-02-02· cited 317×
- Lee Moore v. Betty MitchellSixth Circuit· 2013-02-26· cited 308×
- Henry Hodges v. Stanton Heidle, WardenSixth Circuit· 2013-08-14· cited 213×
- Jeffrey D. Hill v. Betty Mitchell, WardenSixth Circuit· 2005-03-08· cited 212×
- Hartman v. BagleySixth Circuit· 2007-07-10· cited 204×
- Darryl M. Durr v. Betty Mitchell, WardenSixth Circuit· 2007-05-18· cited 202×
- Slagle v. BagleySixth Circuit· 2006-08-08· cited 182×
- Commonwealth v. BlakeneySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-05-01· cited 176×
- Romell Broom v. Betty MitchellSixth Circuit· 2006-03-17· cited 173×
- Derry Lovins v. Tony ParkerSixth Circuit· 2013-03-28· cited 150×
- Haliym v. MitchellSixth Circuit· 2007-07-13· cited 125×
- Joseph Lewis Clark v. Betty MitchellSixth Circuit· 2005-10-04· cited 123×
- Richard Nields v. Margaret Bradshaw, WardenSixth Circuit· 2007-04-06· cited 119×
- Samuel Moreland v. Margaret BradshawSixth Circuit· 2012-11-15· cited 102×
- Beuke v. HoukSixth Circuit· 2008-08-13· cited 99×
- Rhoades v. HenryNinth Circuit· 2011-02-08· cited 93×
- Hunt v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Alabama· 2005-11-23· cited 89×
- Bedford v. CollinsSixth Circuit· 2009-06-04· cited 79×
- McWilliams v. DunnSupreme Court· 2017-06-19· cited 71×
Cites
55 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Strickland v. WashingtonSupreme Court· 1984-06-25· cited 123,578×
- Brady v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1963-05-13· cited 33,902×
- Williams v. TaylorSupreme Court· 2000-04-18· cited 15,929×
- Gregg v. GeorgiaSupreme Court· 1976-07-22· cited 7,936×
- North Carolina v. PearceSupreme Court· 1969-06-23· cited 7,763×
- Brecht v. AbrahamsonSupreme Court· 1993-06-07· cited 7,022×
- Wiggins v. Smith, WardenSupreme Court· 2003-06-26· cited 5,961×
- McMann v. RichardsonSupreme Court· 1970-05-04· cited 5,113×
- Darden v. WainwrightSupreme Court· 1986-09-03· cited 4,161×
- Ake v. OklahomaSupreme Court· 1985-02-26· cited 3,332×
- Zant v. StephensSupreme Court· 1983-06-22· cited 2,410×
- Adams v. United States Ex Rel. McCannSupreme Court· 1943-01-04· cited 2,192×
- Pulley v. HarrisSupreme Court· 1984-01-23· cited 2,080×
- McCleskey v. KempSupreme Court· 1987-06-08· cited 2,038×
- Boyde v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1990-04-23· cited 1,983×
- O'NEAL v. McAninchSupreme Court· 1995-02-21· cited 1,687×
- Lowenfield v. PhelpsSupreme Court· 1988-03-07· cited 1,385×
- Barclay v. FloridaSupreme Court· 1983-07-06· cited 820×
- Robert Glen Coe, Petitioner-Appellee/cross-Appellant v. Ricky Bell, Warden, Respondent-Appellant/cross-AppelleeSixth Circuit· 1999-02-23· cited 698×
- John W. Byrd, Jr. v. Terry L. Collins, WardenSixth Circuit· 2000-04-06· cited 569×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.