United States v. Daniel Mathis

Oral argument

• Argued

  44 min recording
  Listen

Source: CourtListener oral-argument corpus (CC0).

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• recognizing that “not all inconsistences between the written judgment and what was orally pronounced are reversible errors under Rogers and Singletary”
• confirming that Rogers and Singletary provide a “clear rule” that Rogers-Singletary errors require vacatur of entire sentence and a remand for full resentencing
• confirming that Rogers and Singletary provide a “clear rule” that vacatur and remand for a full resentencing is the only remedy available for Rogers errors (internal quotation marks omitted)
• noting that “under our Rogers-Singletary jurisprudence, one rotten apple spoils the whole barrel”
• confirming that “[o]ur precedent leaves no choice” but to “vacate the entire sentence and remand for the district court to resentence the defendant” when the district court commits a Rogers error (internal quotation marks omitted)
• “[U]nder our Rogers-Singletary jurisprudence, one rotten 5 USCA4 Appeal: 23-4062 Doc: 31 Filed: 08/20/2024 Pg: 6 of 7 apple spoils the whole barrel.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

10 cases in this archive cite this case.

• United States v. Aghee Smith, II
  Fourth Circuit· 2024-09-17· cited 22×
• United States v. David Alcorn
  Fourth Circuit· 2024-09-17
• United States v. Robert Turner
  Fourth Circuit· 2024-12-04
• United States v. Young Yoo
  Fourth Circuit· 2025-11-18
• United States v. Tony Le
  Fourth Circuit· 2025-11-18
• United States v. Peter Le
  Fourth Circuit· 2025-11-18
• United States v. Joseph Lamborn
  Fourth Circuit· 2025-11-18
• United States v. Oluwatoyin Aborisade
  Fourth Circuit· 2026-01-08
• United States v. John McLaurin
  Fourth Circuit· 2026-03-06
• United States v. Amanda Tostado
  Fourth Circuit· 2026-03-31

Cites

10 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Anders v. California
  Supreme Court· 1967-05-08· cited 87,848×
• United States v. Daniel Mathis
  Fourth Circuit· 2019-07-31· cited 334×
• Carrie A. McMellon Lori Dawn White Kathy D. Templeton Cheri Call v. United States of America United States Army Corps of Engineers
  Fourth Circuit· 2004-10-14· cited 313×
• United States v. Cortez Rogers
  Fourth Circuit· 2020-06-02· cited 264×
• United States v. Christopher Singletary
  Fourth Circuit· 2021-01-12· cited 187×
• United States v. Betty Anne Osborne
  Fourth Circuit· 2003-10-09· cited 91×
• United States v. Robert Cisson
  Fourth Circuit· 2022-05-05· cited 73×
• United States v. Daniel Kemp, Sr.
  Fourth Circuit· 2023-12-13· cited 67×
• United States v. Malek Lassiter
  Fourth Circuit· 2024-03-15· cited 40×
• United States v. Christopher Singletary
  Fourth Circuit· 2023-08-01· cited 13×