Eighth Circuit· 9/17/2002
Treats v. Morgan
Citations
- 308 F.3d 868
- 2002 U.S. App. LEXIS 19103
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that “the evidence does not show an objective need for the force which was used because Treats had not jeopardized any person’s safety or threatened prison security.”
- explaining that officers may use force reasonably in good-faith effort to maintain or restore discipline, but not maliciously and sadistically to cause harm, and discussing relevant factors
- acknowledging the need for discipline and obedience in prison context but rejecting arbitrary force and the “punitive use of force on difficult inmates not posing a real threat to other persons or raising security concerns”
- “Not every instance of inmate resistance justifies the use of force, and use of pepper spray will not be justified every time an inmate questions orders or seeks redress for an officer's actions.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
12 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Roy Burns v. Edward EatonEighth Circuit· 2014-05-23· cited 203×
- Angelo Clark v. Robert CoupeThird Circuit· 2022-11-28· cited 194×
- Leonard Young, Jr. v. Deputy Superintendent Greene SThird Circuit· 2015-09-08· cited 149×
- Kevin Ward v. Bradley SmithEighth Circuit· 2016-12-21· cited 65×
- Curtis Stewart v. Anne PrecytheEighth Circuit· 2024-01-30· cited 12×
- Moore v. SchuetzleD. North Dakota· 2007-05-18· cited 9×
- Anderson v. CornejoN.D. Illinois· 2003-09-04· cited 9×
- Corey Fisherman v. David LaundervilleEighth Circuit· 2024-05-06· cited 5×
- Frank Staples v. NH State Prison, Warden, et al.D. New Hampshire· 2017-03-17· cited 3×
- Kevin McCourt v. Miguel Angel DelgadoWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2019-03-25
- Madera Gonzalez, Heriberto v. Mercado Borrero, FerdinandTribunal De Apelaciones De Puerto Rico/Court of Appeals of Puerto Rico· 2024-02-26
- Bradley Bolin v. Landon WilkinsEighth Circuit· 2026-05-07
Cites
14 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Harlow v. FitzgeraldSupreme Court· 1982-06-24· cited 22,846×
- Hudson v. McMillianSupreme Court· 1992-02-25· cited 8,199×
- Whitley v. AlbersSupreme Court· 1986-03-04· cited 6,155×
- Hope v. PelzerSupreme Court· 2002-06-27· cited 4,957×
- Johnson v. JonesSupreme Court· 1995-06-12· cited 2,857×
- Williams v. BenjaminFourth Circuit· 1996-03-06· cited 677×
- Robert Foulk v. Ronald Charrier, Lieutenant Charrier Individually and in His Official Capacity, United States of America, Intervenor Below-AppellantEighth Circuit· 2001-08-17· cited 221×
- Hickey v. ReederEighth Circuit· 1993-12-20· cited 152×
- Greiner v. City of ChamplinEighth Circuit· 1994-07-05· cited 142×
- Essalene Lambert v. City of DumasEighth Circuit· 1999-08-09· cited 131×
- R.D. Jones v. Thuworn ShieldsEighth Circuit· 2000-03-23· cited 102×
- Larry E. Yowell v. Jerry P. Combs Andy Dalton Jay Henges John Powell Jerry J. Presley David HurlbutEighth Circuit· 1996-08-14· cited 61×
- James D. Stenzel v. Jim Ellis, Jailer, Pat Adams and Lynn F. Jacobs, All Sued in Their Official and Individual CapacitiesEighth Circuit· 1990-10-08· cited 42×
- Byron Treats v. James MorganEighth Circuit· 2002-09-17· cited 1×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.