State v. John Rainey
Citations
- 175 A.3d 1169
Syllabus
The defendant, John Rainey, appeals his conviction of two counts of first-degree child molestation and one count of second-degree child molestation. The defendant primarily argued that the trial justice erred in allowing, under Rule 404(b) of the Rhode Island Rules of Evidence, testimony from the defendant's biological daughter as to an unconvicted assault he allegedly committed against her. Moreover, the defendant argued that, even if the evidence was admissible under Rule 404(b), it was inadmissible under Rule 403 of the Rhode Island Rules of Evidence. In addition, the defendant asserted that the state's late disclosure of the Rule 404(b) witness's testimony constituted a violation of Rule 16 of the Superior Court Rules of Criminal Procedure and that the trial justice's remedy of delaying the witness's testimony for three days so that defense counsel could prepare for it constituted an abuse of discretion. Lastly, the defendant alleged the trial justice erred in denying both his motion for new trial and motion for judgment of acquittal. The Court held that the trial justice did not abuse his discretion in allowing the Rule 404(b) testimony, nor did he do so in determining that the evidence was permissible under Rule 403. The Court similarly held that, while the state did violate Rule 16 in its late disclosure of the Rule 404(b) witness's testimony, the trial justice's remedy of requiring the state to wait three days before calling the witness was not an abuse of discretion. Finally, the Court upheld the trial justice's decision denying the defendant's motion for new trial and motion for judgment of acquittal. Accordingly, the Court affirmed the Superior Court's judgment.
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that based on the totality of circumstances sexual misconduct involving defendant’s daughter and the daughter of defendant’s girlfriend were sufficiently similar and nonremote
- affirming a trial justice's finding that a time span of eleven to fifteen years was nonremote
- “[T]he manner of abuse was similar with each victim in that both cases involved penetration, successful or otherwise.”
- “[T]estimony ‘was indicative of the defendant’s lecherous conduct toward girls over whom he exercised discipline, control, and supervision.’”
- “When the issue before us concerns a trial justice’s decision to either admit or exclude evidence, we examine that issue under an abuse-of-discretion standard.”
- “[Y]ou may consider the testimony only as it relates to defendant’s motive, his opportunity, his intent, preparation, [or] his plan * * *.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Suttell, Goldberg, Flaherty, Robinson, Indeglia
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
8 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Woodlin v. StateCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 2023-10-11· cited 14×
- State v. Jamal RogersSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2019-05-17· cited 2×
- State v. Joel NajeraSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2019-06-19· cited 1×
- State v. PerrySupreme Court of South Carolina· 2020-05-06
- State v. Eric MensahSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2020-05-14
- State v. Daniel E. Doyle, Jr.Supreme Court of Rhode Island· 2020-07-08
- Woodlin v. StateCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 2023-07-26
- State v. Milton AponteSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2024-07-12
Cites
77 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. Nicolas GomezSeventh Circuit· 2014-08-18· cited 185×
- United States v. Marvin Leo BeasleySeventh Circuit· 1987-01-09· cited 184×
- United States v. MillerSeventh Circuit· 2012-03-12· cited 124×
- State v. JaletteSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1978-01-18· cited 119×
- State v. CatsamSupreme Court of Vermont· 1987-08-14· cited 108×
- State v. GrayhurstSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2004-06-23· cited 83×
- State v. CoelhoSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1982-12-24· cited 82×
- State v. TooleSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1994-04-28· cited 77×
- State v. GomesSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1997-02-18· cited 70×
- State v. ConcannonSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1983-03-24· cited 65×
- Freeman v. StateAlaska Supreme Court· 1971-07-02· cited 64×
- State v. GarciaSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2000-01-26· cited 57×
- Commonwealth v. BradleySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1976-09-27· cited 52×
- State v. GasparSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2009-10-30· cited 50×
- State v. QuattrocchiSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1996-07-31· cited 50×
- State v. MohapatraSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2005-07-25· cited 49×
- State v. MeridaSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2008-11-25· cited 48×
- State v. DarcySupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1982-03-17· cited 48×
- State v. AakreMontana Supreme Court· 2002-05-10· cited 47×
- State v. PignoletSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1983-09-01· cited 46×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.