Utah Supreme Court· 6/18/1991
State v. Gardiner
Citations
- 814 P.2d 568
- 163 Utah Adv. Rep. 16
- 1991 Utah LEXIS 56
- 1991 WL 110882
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the defense of habitation did not apply to the defendant’s use of force outside an airport building, which his father owned
- stating that right to resist unlawful police conduct rejected as defense to crime when common law defenses were supplanted by specifically codifying recognized defenses
- stating that right to resist unlawful police conduct rejected as defense to crime when common law defenses were supplanted by specifically codifying recognized defenses
- noting that “this court is not bound by earlier dicta”
- finding the legislature's decision against codifying the \common law right to resist an illegal search or arrest\ \impliedly preclude[d]\ the court from recognizing such a defense
- noting principle that warrantless searches are unreasonable “has as much, if not more, force under the Utah Constitution” as under Federal Constitution
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Zimmerman, Stewart, Hall, Durham, Howe, Bench
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
27 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Tillman v. StateSupreme Court of Florida· 2006-07-06· cited 91×
- State v. WiegmannCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1998-08-04· cited 73×
- Commonwealth v. HillSupreme Court of Virginia· 2002-11-01· cited 56×
- JH BY DH v. West Valley CityUtah Supreme Court· 1992-10-07· cited 36×
- State v. MillerUtah Supreme Court· 2008-08-29· cited 32×
- State v. TraneUtah Supreme Court· 2002-09-17· cited 30×
- Essential Botanical Farms, LC v. KayUtah Supreme Court· 2011-11-15· cited 19×
- State v. PhillipsNew Mexico Court of Appeals· 2008-12-29· cited 18×
- State v. GironCourt of Appeals of Utah· 1997-07-01· cited 18×
- In re K.A.S.Utah Supreme Court· 2016-12-06· cited 16×
- State v. HobbsCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2003-02-06· cited 15×
- State v. AlonzoCourt of Appeals of Utah· 1997-01-09· cited 14×
- American Fork City v. Pena-FloresUtah Supreme Court· 2002-12-27· cited 11×
- American Fork City v. Pena-FloresCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2000-11-16· cited 10×
- Salt Lake City v. ChristensenCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2007-07-27· cited 9×
- City of Champaign v. TorresAppellate Court of Illinois· 2004-01-21· cited 9×
- State v. RamirezCourt of Appeals of Utah· 1991-06-25· cited 8×
- Salt Lake City v. SmootCourt of Appeals of Utah· 1996-06-20· cited 7×
- Utah Department of Transportation v. FPA West Point, LLCUtah Supreme Court· 2012-11-20· cited 7×
- State v. GriegoCourt of Appeals of Utah· 1997-02-27· cited 6×
Cites
52 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Schneckloth v. BustamonteSupreme Court· 1973-05-29· cited 11,783×
- Camara v. Municipal Court of City and County of San FranciscoSupreme Court· 1967-06-05· cited 3,591×
- State v. WalkerUtah Supreme Court· 1987-08-25· cited 237×
- United States v. Saundra PrescottNinth Circuit· 1978-09-14· cited 214×
- Wright v. GeorgiaSupreme Court· 1963-11-07· cited 210×
- State v. VerdeUtah Supreme Court· 1989-02-03· cited 205×
- State v. RimmaschUtah Supreme Court· 1989-05-17· cited 202×
- Scharf v. BMG Corp.Utah Supreme Court· 1985-04-16· cited 195×
- Berube v. Fashion Centre, Ltd.Utah Supreme Court· 1989-03-20· cited 181×
- State v. LaroccoUtah Supreme Court· 1990-05-30· cited 135×
- Gray v. StateAlaska Supreme Court· 1970-01-16· cited 134×
- United States v. Piero Heliczer, Jack William Martin, Iii, and Jack v. SmithSecond Circuit· 1967-02-23· cited 130×
- City of Columbus v. FraleyOhio Supreme Court· 1975-03-12· cited 108×
- State v. DoeNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1978-09-06· cited 104×
- Miller v. StateAlaska Supreme Court· 1969-12-15· cited 95×
- Bonham v. MorganUtah Supreme Court· 1989-02-23· cited 87×
- State v. HattonArizona Supreme Court· 1977-07-06· cited 85×
- United States v. Augustine FerroneThird Circuit· 1971-02-17· cited 84×
- State v. KoonceNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1965-10-26· cited 77×
- Elson v. StateAlaska Supreme Court· 1983-02-18· cited 75×
Other cases named State v. Gardiner
11 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- State v. GardinerSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1994-01-31· cited 20×
- State v. GardinerIdaho Court of Appeals· 1995-06-09· cited 17×
- State v. GardinerSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-04-25· cited 9×
- State v. GardinerCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2023-11-29· cited 1×
- State v. GardinerMontana Supreme Court· 2008-01-08
- State v. GardinerCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2009-06-17
- State v. GardinerOhio Supreme Court· 1833-08-15
- State v. GardinerCourt of Appeals of Washington· 1996-12-19
- State v. GardinerSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1985-01-14
- State v. GardinerSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1974-05-17
- State v. GardinerMontana Supreme Court· 2003-09-08
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.