State v. Doty
Citations
- 94 Ohio St. 258
- 113 N.E. 811
- 1916 Ohio LEXIS 147
Syllabus
<p>Criminal law — Aider and abettor — Indicted as principal for murder— Prosecution based on conspiracy — Knowledge of acts of principal immaterial, when — Charge to jury — Conspirators guilty with principal — Although latter's acts not contemplated —And conspirators absent and without knowledge — Evidence — Admissibility of confession detailing flight after crime — Confession to be sent to jury room, when — Evidence of threats and possession of weapons, inadmissible, when — Competency of evidence of payment of money by confederate.</p> <p>1. Where the state has indicted a defendant as a principal offender for murder in the first degree, but on the trial prosecutes him only as an aider and abettor and lodges its entire case upon proof of a conspiracy to commit an unlawful act by the use of deadly weapons or force and violence of such character as would reasonably be expected to cause the death of another, it is error to charge the jury that if it finds that the shot was fired by the principal offender without the knowledge, connivance or assent of the defendant the jury must acquit.</p> <p>2. Where only such unlawful act was contemplated in the original conspiracy, although not identical with or similar to the criminal act charged, if the conspired unlawful act and the manner of its performance would be reasonably likely to produce death, each conspirator is equally guilty with the principal offender, as an aider and abettor in the homicide, although such aider and abettor was neither present nor had knowledge of the physical killing or of the weapon used.</p> <p>3. Where a signed confession details the defendant’s connection with the crime charged and also contains an account of flight shortly following the crime and the actions of himself and one or more of his confederates, the entire confession is competent and relevant; but if improper or irrelevant statements are incorporated therein they may be excluded by the court.</p> <p>4. The parties in a criminal case h
Judges: Donahue, Johnson, Jones, Matthias, Newman, Nichols, Wanamaker
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
18 cases in this archive cite this case.
- State v. LozaOhio Supreme Court· 1994-11-30· cited 824×
- State v. RobbinsOhio Supreme Court· 1979-05-02· cited 484×
- State v. ClarkOhio Supreme Court· 1988-08-24· cited 292×
- State v. MelchiorOhio Supreme Court· 1978-10-04· cited 290×
- State v. JosephOhio Supreme Court· 1995-08-30· cited 255×
- State v. LockettOhio Supreme Court· 1976-12-30· cited 96×
- The People v. CaldwellIllinois Supreme Court· 1968-03-28· cited 84×
- State v. LozaOhio Supreme Court· 1994-11-29· cited 79×
- State v. LordNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1938-10-08· cited 71×
- McAtee v. CommonwealthKentucky Supreme Court· 2013-09-26· cited 32×
- State v. DietzWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1990-03-08· cited 21×
- John Palfy, Jr. v. Harold J. Cardwell, WardenSixth Circuit· 1971-09-22· cited 14×
- Dorger v. StateOhio Court of Appeals· 1931-07-06· cited 5×
- State v. ThomasOhio Court of Appeals· 2015-11-23· cited 3×
- State v. WilliamsOhio Court of Appeals· 2011-05-16· cited 1×
- Black v. StateOhio Supreme Court· 1921-11-15
- State v. GordonButler County Court of Common Pleas· 1948-09-27
- State v. MorlockOhio Court of Appeals· 2024-02-07
Cites
4 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named State v. Doty
25 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 1982-11-10· cited 20×
- State v. DotyMontana Supreme Court· 1977-07-29· cited 18×
- State v. DotyOregon Supreme Court· 1875-12-15· cited 9×
- State v. DotySupreme Court of New Jersey· 1868-02-15· cited 9×
- State v. DotyOhio Court of Appeals· 2019-03-18· cited 8×
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2013-07-30· cited 6×
- State v. DotyArizona Supreme Court· 1974-02-28· cited 5×
- State v. DotySupreme Court of Iowa· 1897-12-15· cited 4×
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2011-02-02· cited 2×
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 1994-03-23· cited 1×
- State v. DotySupreme Court of Iowa· 1899-10-21· cited 1×
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Wisconsin· 2005-03-22
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2004-08-11
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2009-02-18
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2011-02-02
- State v. DotyOregon Supreme Court· 2009-07-09
- State v. DotyOregon Supreme Court· 2010-12-09
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2010-08-18
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Washington· 2015-12-23
- State v. DotyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2002-02-20
- State v. DotyIndiana Supreme Court· 1859-01-10
- State v. DotyMississippi Supreme Court· 1826-06-15
- State v. DotySupreme Court of Louisiana· 1995-05-12
- State v. DotySupreme Court of Louisiana· 2006-08-16
- State v. DotyMississippi Supreme Court· 1872-07-01
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.