Federal Circuit· 11/13/2018
Siler v. Envtl. Prot. Agency
Citations
- 908 F.3d 1291
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that in the absence of relevant comparator evidence, the third Carr factor cannot favor the agency
- holding that Carr factor 3 cannot favor the Government when the Board finds an absence of relevant comparator evidence
- holding that in the absence of relevant comparator evidence, the third Carr factor cannot favor the agency
- holding that in the absence of relevant comparator evidence, the third Carr factor cannot favor the agency
- holding that in the absence of relevant comparator evidence, Carr factor 3 cannot favor the Government
- finding that the Board erred in considering the treatment of similarly situated whistleblowers under the third Carr factor
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: O'Malley, Clevenger, Stoll
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
10 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Javier Soto v. Department of Veterans AffairsMerit Systems Protection Board· 2022-04-20· cited 85×
- Arnold Wilson v. Department of Veterans AffairsMerit Systems Protection Board· 2022-04-26· cited 71×
- Smith v. Gen. Servs. Admin.Federal Circuit· 2019-07-19· cited 64×
- Garilynn Smith v. Department of the ArmyMerit Systems Protection Board· 2022-04-13· cited 63×
- Mikhail Semenov v. Department of Veterans AffairsMerit Systems Protection Board· 2023-04-25· cited 58×
- Rickel v. NavyFederal Circuit· 2022-04-18· cited 39×
- Cathy Covington v. Department of the InteriorMerit Systems Protection Board· 2023-01-13· cited 37×
- Mary Reese v. Department of the NavyMerit Systems Protection Board· 2025-01-31· cited 1×
- Biswas v. DVAFederal Circuit· 2025-01-17
- Oliva v. DVAFederal Circuit· 2026-05-07
Cites
14 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Coastal States Gas Corporation v. Department of EnergyD.C. Circuit· 1980-02-15· cited 1,241×
- United States v. United Shoe MacHinery CorporationD. Massachusetts· 1950-03-10· cited 503×
- Rokki Knee Carr v. Social Security AdministrationFederal Circuit· 1999-07-30· cited 497×
- Whitmore v. Department of LaborFederal Circuit· 2012-05-30· cited 347×
- William F. Curtin v. Office of Personnel ManagementFederal Circuit· 1988-05-18· cited 183×
- In Re Spalding Sports Worldwide, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2000-02-15· cited 150×
- Miller v. Department of JusticeFederal Circuit· 2016-12-02· cited 103×
- Carol Briley v. National Archives & Records Administration,respondentFederal Circuit· 2001-01-22· cited 83×
- Zenith Radio Corporation v. The United StatesFederal Circuit· 1985-06-19· cited 61×
- Harold J. Sullivan v. Department of the NavyFederal Circuit· 1983-11-08· cited 58×
- In Re: Queen's University at KingstonFederal Circuit· 2016-03-07· cited 34×
- Cobert v. MillerFederal Circuit· 2015-09-02· cited 26×
- Fellhoelter v. Department of AgricultureFederal Circuit· 2009-06-15· cited 19×
- Becker v. Office of Personnel ManagementFederal Circuit· 2017-04-07· cited 7×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.