Arizona Supreme Court· 3/13/2009
Seisinger v. Siebel
Citations
- 203 P.3d 483
- 220 Ariz. 85
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- observing that “the precise dividing line between substance and procedure ‘has proven elusive’” and that “[s]tatutes relating to evidence present particularly difficult problems, as such statutes, like rules of evidence, often have both substantive and procedural aspects”
- observing that “the precise dividing line between substance and procedure ‘has proven elusive’ ” and that “[statutes relating to evidence present particularly difficult problems, as such statutes, like rules of evidence, often have both substantive and procedural aspects”
- recognizing requirement that expert testimony in a medical malpractice action is a substantive component of the common law reflecting “a policy decision ... that the plaintiffs substantive burden of production could only be met by a particular kind of evidence”
- stating, in a separation of powers analysis, “we must ... determine whether the challenged statutory provision is substantive or procedural”
- requiring proof of standard of care, breach of that standard of care, causation, and injury, through use of expert witness testimony
- regarding substantive law, “[t]he legislature has plenary power to deal with any topic unless otherwise restrained by the Constitution”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Hurwitz, Berch, Ryan, Bales
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
68 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- People v. Watkins; People v. PullenMichigan Supreme Court· 2012-06-08· cited 466×
- State of Arizona v. Shawna FordeArizona Supreme Court· 2014-01-17· cited 103×
- Robert Baker v. University Physicians HealthcareArizona Supreme Court· 2013-03-12· cited 75×
- State of Arizona v. Ronald Bruce BiggerArizona Supreme Court· 2021-08-16· cited 63×
- Harvey v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 2012-07-13· cited 60×
- McMurtry v. Weatherford Hotel, Inc.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2013-01-10· cited 50×
- Brumett v. MGA Home Healthcare, LLCCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2016-07-28· cited 50×
- Gutierrez v. Hon. fox/kivlighnCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2017-04-13· cited 46×
- Ryan v. San Francisco Peaks Trucking Co.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2011-08-25· cited 38×
- State Ex Rel Brnovich v. City of tucson/dewitArizona Supreme Court· 2017-08-17· cited 28×
- Albano v. SHEA HOMES LTD. PARTNERSHIPArizona Supreme Court· 2011-06-30· cited 22×
- Planned Parenthood Arizona, Inc. v. American Ass'n of Pro-Life Obstetricians & GynecologistsCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2011-08-11· cited 22×
- State v. EddingtonCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2010-12-17· cited 21×
- Benkendorf v. Advanced Cardiac Specialists CharteredCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2012-01-24· cited 19×
- State of Arizona v. Richard Allen ReedArizona Supreme Court· 2020-01-24· cited 19×
- Cornerstone Hospital of Southeast Arizona v. Ernest H. BlackburnCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2012-12-07· cited 17×
- State v. RiosCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2010-08-12· cited 16×
- Rice v. Brakel, M.D., Center for NeurosciencesCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2013-09-12· cited 16×
- Lear v. FieldsCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2011-01-12· cited 15×
- Claudia Duff v. Hon. lee/tucson PoliceArizona Supreme Court· 2020-11-25· cited 13×
Cites
40 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Erie Railroad v. TompkinsSupreme Court· 1938-04-25· cited 18,491×
- Hanna v. PlumerSupreme Court· 1965-04-26· cited 2,853×
- Roderic R. McDowell v. Pernell BrownEleventh Circuit· 2004-12-08· cited 797×
- State v. RobinsonArizona Supreme Court· 1987-04-07· cited 253×
- McDougall v. SchanzMichigan Supreme Court· 1999-07-30· cited 249×
- Ewing v. GoodeU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern Ohio· 1897-01-15· cited 233×
- State v. DavoltArizona Supreme Court· 2004-02-17· cited 223×
- Daou v. HarrisArizona Supreme Court· 1984-02-14· cited 172×
- State v. HansenArizona Supreme Court· 2007-05-30· cited 146×
- Arizona Downs v. Arizona Horsemen's FoundationArizona Supreme Court· 1981-12-08· cited 133×
- State v. BirminghamArizona Supreme Court· 1964-06-04· cited 120×
- Adams v. BolinArizona Supreme Court· 1952-07-16· cited 97×
- Annabelle Legg v. Dr. Ash Chopra, University Urology, P.C.Sixth Circuit· 2002-04-03· cited 89×
- Cronin v. SheldonArizona Supreme Court· 1999-12-17· cited 83×
- Duncan v. Scottsdale Medical Imaging, Ltd.Arizona Supreme Court· 2003-06-16· cited 79×
- Readenour v. Marion Power ShovelArizona Supreme Court· 1986-05-12· cited 79×
- State Ex Rel. Collins v. SeidelArizona Supreme Court· 1984-11-21· cited 75×
- McGraw v. KerrColorado Court of Appeals· 1912-09-15· cited 64×
- Valerie M. v. Arizona Department of Economic SecurityArizona Supreme Court· 2009-01-12· cited 58×
- State v. FletcherArizona Supreme Court· 1986-03-28· cited 54×
Other cases named Seisinger v. Siebel
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.