Illinois Supreme Court· 6/19/1989
Pyne v. Witmer
Citations
- 543 N.E.2d 1304
- 129 Ill. 2d 351
- 135 Ill. Dec. 557
- 1989 Ill. LEXIS 92
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that “[s]ummary judgment is generally inappropriate when scope of employment is at issue.”
- explaining that “where the surrounding facts and circumstances leave room for legitimate inferences as to whether, despite the deviation, the employee was still engaged in the employer's business, the question is for the jury.”
- discussing the rules governing when an employee’s actions fall outside the scope of employment and stating that “when a deviation is exceedingly marked and unusual, as a matter of law the employee may be found to be outside the scope of employment” (citations omitted)
- “[T]he burden is on the plaintiff to show the contemporaneous relationship between tortious acts and scope of employment.”
- summary judgment is warranted when there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and the moving party’s right to judgment is clear and free from doubt
- “[W]hen a deviation is exceedingly marked and unusual, as a matter of law the employee may be found to be outside the scope of employment.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Stamos, Ryan, Miller
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
229 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Outboard Marine Corp. v. Liberty Mutual InsuranceIllinois Supreme Court· 1992-12-04· cited 1,920×
- Schur v. L.A. Weight Loss Centers, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2009-08-14· cited 581×
- Loyola Academy v. S & S Roof Maintenance, Inc.Illinois Supreme Court· 1992-01-23· cited 538×
- Espinoza v. Elgin, Joliet & Eastern Railway Co.Illinois Supreme Court· 1995-03-30· cited 413×
- Gilbert v. Sycamore Municipal HospitalIllinois Supreme Court· 1993-10-21· cited 404×
- In Re Estate of HooverIllinois Supreme Court· 1993-06-17· cited 349×
- Bagent v. Blessing Care Corp.Illinois Supreme Court· 2007-01-19· cited 215×
- Ziemba v. MierzwaIllinois Supreme Court· 1991-01-31· cited 208×
- Gill v. FosterIllinois Supreme Court· 1993-11-18· cited 204×
- Morris v. MargulisIllinois Supreme Court· 2001-07-19· cited 196×
- Luu v. KimAppellate Court of Illinois· 2001-06-19· cited 109×
- Knauerhaze v. NelsonAppellate Court of Illinois· 2005-09-19· cited 103×
- Wright v. City of DanvilleIllinois Supreme Court· 1996-12-19· cited 102×
- Fabiano v. City of Palos HillsAppellate Court of Illinois· 2002-11-25· cited 82×
- Joany Chou v. The University of Chicago and Arch Development Corporation, and Bernard Roizman, and Aviron CompanyFederal Circuit· 2001-07-03· cited 80×
- Blair v. Nevada Landing Partnership, RBG, LPAppellate Court of Illinois· 2006-12-08· cited 79×
- Betts v. Manville Personal Injury Settlement TrustAppellate Court of Illinois· 1992-04-08· cited 78×
- University of Illinois v. Continental Casualty Co.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1992-09-03· cited 73×
- O'BANNER v. McDonald's Corp.Illinois Supreme Court· 1996-05-31· cited 72×
- Governmental Interinsurance Exchange v. JudgeIllinois Supreme Court· 2006-05-18· cited 71×
Cites
59 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Purtill v. HessIllinois Supreme Court· 1986-02-06· cited 1,151×
- Fooden v. Board of GovernorsIllinois Supreme Court· 1971-03-31· cited 309×
- Murphy v. UrsoIllinois Supreme Court· 1981-12-18· cited 194×
- Kimbrough v. Jewel Companies, Inc.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1981-01-22· cited 138×
- Gundich v. Emerson-Comstock Co.Illinois Supreme Court· 1960-12-01· cited 85×
- Kobus v. Formfit Co.Illinois Supreme Court· 1966-09-23· cited 73×
- Gomien v. Wear-Ever Aluminum, Inc.Illinois Supreme Court· 1971-11-30· cited 67×
- Sunseri v. PucciaAppellate Court of Illinois· 1981-06-09· cited 67×
- Bates v. DoriaAppellate Court of Illinois· 1986-12-24· cited 59×
- RANDI F. v. High Ridge YMCAAppellate Court of Illinois· 1988-05-13· cited 56×
- LaMonte v. City of BellevilleAppellate Court of Illinois· 1976-08-27· cited 55×
- Ray v. City of ChicagoIllinois Supreme Court· 1960-05-20· cited 54×
- Easley v. Apollo Detective Agency, Inc.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1979-02-20· cited 53×
- Hoover v. University of Chicago HospitalsAppellate Court of Illinois· 1977-08-01· cited 50×
- Darner v. ColbyIllinois Supreme Court· 1941-02-14· cited 47×
- Taylor v. HockerAppellate Court of Illinois· 1981-11-09· cited 46×
- Richard v. Illinois Bell Telephone Co.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1978-11-03· cited 45×
- Seefeldt v. Millikin National Bank of DecaturAppellate Court of Illinois· 1987-04-13· cited 43×
- Webb v. Jewel Companies, Inc.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1985-10-25· cited 41×
- Urban v. Industrial CommissionIllinois Supreme Court· 1966-01-25· cited 40×
Other cases named Pyne v. Witmer
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.