Prall v. Prall
Citations
- 58 Fla. 496
Syllabus
<p>1. Where a final judgment or decree has been rendered by a court having jurisdiction of the subject matter and of the parties it is binding on the parties ahd their privies; and such final judgment or decree is a bar to another suit or action between the same parties for the same subject matter. This principle of law is enforced by the courts so that parties may not be vexed more than once for the same cause, and that there may be an end to litigation.</p> <p>2. Where a final judgment or decree is rendered for the defendant on demurrer, the plaintiff is estopped from maintaining a similar or concurrent action or suit for the same cause upon the same grounds that were disclosed in the first suit or action, for the reason that the judgment determines the merits of the cause as presented by the pleadings affected by the demurrer.</p> <p>3. Where a demurrer to a pleading is sustained because essential allegations of fact were omitted from the pleading; a final judgment on the demurrer concludes the parties and their privies only as to the sufficiency of the facts as alleged to state a cause of action.</p> <p>4. In general, a final judgment on demurrer is not a bar to a second suit or action for the same cause between the same parties as an estoppel by judgment because of the former adjudication, where the pleadings in the second suit or action supply the essential allegations .omitted from the first .suit or action, though the conduct of the parties in not presenting the case when an opportunity was afforded may under special circumstances operate as an estoppel in pais. Conclusions of law are not admitted by.demurrer.</p> <p>5. Where the second suit is upon the same cause of action and between the same parties as the first, the final judgment in the first suit upon the merits is conclusive in the second suit as to every question that was presented or might have been on the pleadings presented and determined in the first suit. ■</p> <p>6. When the second suit is upon
Judges: Hocker, Whitfield
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
56 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Gordon v. GordonSupreme Court of Florida· 1952-05-02· cited 200×
- Albrecht v. StateSupreme Court of Florida· 1984-01-12· cited 122×
- Theresa Graham v. R.J Reynolds Tobacco CompanyEleventh Circuit· 2017-05-18· cited 50×
- Caron v. Systematic Air ServicesDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1991-03-11· cited 26×
- Smith v. PattishallSupreme Court of Florida· 1937-03-16· cited 25×
- Martin v. MartinDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1958-05-14· cited 20×
- Young v. Miami Beach Improvement Co.Supreme Court of Florida· 1950-04-18· cited 18×
- Coulter v. DavinDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1979-07-27· cited 17×
- Windham v. WindhamSupreme Court of Florida· 1940-10-11· cited 17×
- Weeke v. ReeveSupreme Court of Florida· 1913-04-15· cited 17×
- Flynn-Harris-Bullard Co. v. HamptonSupreme Court of Florida· 1915-11-02· cited 17×
- Florida Real Estate Commission v. HarrisSupreme Court of Florida· 1961-10-25· cited 16×
- Verdier v. VerdierCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1962-05-21· cited 16×
- McKinnon v. JohnsonSupreme Court of Florida· 1910-01-15· cited 16×
- Kellogg v. KelloggSupreme Court of Florida· 1927-02-15· cited 16×
- Masilotti v. MasilottiSupreme Court of Florida· 1942-03-13· cited 14×
- Stone v. StoneDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1959-04-28· cited 13×
- Asphalt Paving, Inc. v. UleryDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1963-01-29· cited 13×
- Black v. BlackNevada Supreme Court· 1924-10-02· cited 11×
- Huddleston v. GrahamSupreme Court of Florida· 1917-02-12· cited 11×
Cites
23 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Gould v. Evansville & Crawfordsville R. Co.Supreme Court· 1876-02-21· cited 149×
- De Sollar v. HanscomeSupreme Court· 1895-05-20· cited 94×
- Draper v. MedlockSupreme Court of Georgia· 1905-03-04· cited 57×
- Horn v. StateAlabama Court of Appeals· 1916-09-07· cited 51×
- Rogers v. HigginsIllinois Supreme Court· 1870-09-15· cited 42×
- Fritz v. FritzIllinois Supreme Court· 1891-11-04· cited 41×
- Hancock v. HancockSupreme Court of Florida· 1908-01-15· cited 40×
- Beekman v. BeekmanSupreme Court of Florida· 1907-01-15· cited 38×
- Phelan v. PhelanSupreme Court of Florida· 1868-07-01· cited 37×
- Lake v. Hancock ex rel. PayneSupreme Court of Florida· 1896-06-15· cited 31×
- Lea v. LeaMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1868-09-15· cited 29×
- Southwick v. SouthwickMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1867-10-15· cited 26×
- Palmer v. PalmerSupreme Court of Florida· 1895-06-15· cited 20×
- Williams v. WilliamsSupreme Court of Florida· 1887-06-15· cited 17×
- Donnelly v. DonnellySupreme Court of Florida· 1897-01-15· cited 17×
- Crawford v. CrawfordSupreme Court of Florida· 1879-01-15· cited 16×
- Hickson v. HicksonSupreme Court of Florida· 1907-06-15· cited 14×
- Segelbaum v. SegelbaumSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1888-10-05· cited 14×
- Florida Packing & Ice Co. v. CarneySupreme Court of Florida· 1905-01-15· cited 11×
- Gredler v. GredlerSupreme Court of Florida· 1895-06-15· cited 8×
Other cases named Prall v. Prall
6 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Prall v. PrallSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1997-08-06· cited 9×
- Prall v. PrallSupreme Court of Florida· 1908-06-15· cited 5×
- Prall v. PrallSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1942-11-30· cited 4×
- Prall v. PrallAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 2017-12-22· cited 3×
- Prall v. PrallDistrict of Columbia· 1926-12-03· cited 3×
- Prall v. PrallD.C. Circuit· 1926-06-01· cited 2×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.