Pennsylvania R. v. Marchant
Citations
- 119 Pa. 541
- 13 A. 690
- 1888 Pa. LEXIS 577
Syllabus
<p>1. The mischief which the constitutional convention had before it in the adoption of § 8, article XVI., of the constitution of 1874, was the want of a remedy under previous constitutions to obtain compensation when property was injured or destroyed in the construction or enlargement of corporate works, though no portion of it was actually taken by the offending corporation; instances: O’Connor v. Pittsburgh, 18 Pa. 187; Monongahela Nav. Co. v. Coons, 6 W. & S. 101.</p> <p>2. The remedy provided by said constitutional provision, to secure just compensation by corporations for property “injured or destroyed,” has relation to injuries which, though popularly termed consequential, are yet to be understood as confined to such injuries to one’s property as are actual, positive and visible, the natural and necessary results of the original construction or enlargement of its works by a corporation, and of such certain character that compensation therefor may be ascertained at the time the works are being constructed or enlarged, and paid or secured, as provided in the constitution, in advance; instances: Reading v. Althouse, 93 Pa. 400; New Brighton v. U. P. Church, 96 Pa. 331; Phil. & R. R. Co. v. Patent, 17 W. N. 198; Penn. R. Co. v. Duncan, 111 Pa. 352; Chester Co. v. Brower, 117 Pa. 647.</p> <p>3. The necessities of a railroad company and the public character of its business compel it to seek the heart of a city; and, where, upon property it has itself acquired, it has constructed its roadway without taking any portion of the property of the plaintiff, it is not liable for indirect injuries to the plaintiff which are the result merely of the subsequent . operation of its railroad in a lawful manner, without negligence, unskilfulness or malice : Penn. R. Co. v. Lippincott, 116 Pa. 472, approved.</p> <p>4. The word “injury” (or injured), as used in § 8, article XVI., of the constitution, we understand to mean such a legal wrong as would be the subject of an action for
Judges: Clark, Gordon, Green, Paxson, Sterrett, Trdnkey, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Gardner v. Allegheny CountySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1955-05-23· cited 150×
- Delaware River Joint Toll Bridge Commission v. ColburnSupreme Court· 1940-05-27· cited 77×
- Strauss v. AllentownSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1906-05-07· cited 46×
- Smith v. St. Paul, Minneapolis & Manitoba Railway Co.Washington Supreme Court· 1905-07-27· cited 39×
- Truck Terminal Realty Co. v. CommonwealthSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1979-07-11· cited 35×
- In re HullSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1925-06-19· cited 26×
- Hartman v. Pittsburgh Incline Plane Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1894-01-15· cited 18×
- M'Clenachan v. CurwinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1802-03-15· cited 18×
- Taylor v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.Washington Supreme Court· 1915-05-27· cited 16×
- Dussell v. Kaufman Construction Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1960-01-18· cited 12×
- Holmes v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1922-07-13· cited 12×
- City of Amarillo v. GrayCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1957-06-17· cited 11×
- Johnson v. City of St. LouisEighth Circuit· 1909-07-06· cited 10×
- Shinzel v. Bell Telephone Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1906-06-30· cited 8×
- Pittsburg v. Pittsburg, Carnegie & Western RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1903-01-05· cited 7×
- Rogers v. Philadelphia Traction Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-10-11· cited 6×
- Ganster v. Metropolitan Electric Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1906-04-09· cited 5×
- Karcher v. Wheeling Electrical Co.West Virginia Supreme Court· 1923-06-12· cited 5×
- Ryan v. Pennsylvania. R.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1890-02-17· cited 2×
- McGrane v. Philadelphia & Reading Railway Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-04-21· cited 2×
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Higgins v. McCreaSupreme Court· 1886-03-01· cited 71×
- Monongahela Navigation Co. v. CoonsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1843-09-15· cited 71×
- County of Chester v. BrowerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1888-01-09· cited 50×
- Pennsylvania R. v. LippincottSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1887-05-31· cited 43×
- O'Connor v. PittsburghSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1851-11-24· cited 34×
- Pennsylvania Railroad v. DuncanSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1886-02-15· cited 24×
- M'Clenachan v. CurwinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1802-03-15· cited 18×
- Borough of New Brighton v. United Presbyterian ChurchSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1880-11-26· cited 14×
- Pusey v. City of AlleghenySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1881-11-07· cited 13×
- Setzler v. Pennsylvania Schuylkill Valley RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1884-02-23· cited 12×
- Pittsburgh & Lake Erie Railroad v. JonesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1886-01-04· cited 7×
- Buckwalter v. Black Rock Bridge CompanySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1861-02-28· cited 5×
- Lycoming Gas & Water Co. v. MoyerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1882-03-13· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.