Peake v. New Orleans
Citations
- 139 U.S. 342
- 11 S. Ct. 541
- 35 L. Ed. 131
- 1891 U.S. LEXIS 2388
Syllabus
<p>The judgment at law on which the bill in this case is based, absolved the defendant from any primary obligation of debtor to creditor, and left it chargeable only as trustee of a fund out of which plaintiff’s claim was to be paid; and it was unquestionably correct.</p> <p>To the extent that the city of New Orleans may be considered as such a trustee, it is a compulsory trustee by force of the legislation of 1871, and not a voluntary and contractual trustee, and its responsibility should be restricted to the narrowest limits.</p> <p>In failing to collect the uncollected assessments, the city was guilty of no dereliction of duty as trustee.</p> <p>The various assessment proceedings, tafeen in connection with the decision of the Supreme Court approving the homologation of the tableaux, may-have operated, if not to cast a specific lien upon the streets and other ■public grounds, at least to charge upon the city an obligation to the drainage fund for a proportionate share of the total cost of the drainage; but the city has, by its issues of city bonds in exchange for warrants,, paid an amount on account of drainage far in excess of all the assessments charged against it, and nothing is due from it as trustee on this, account.</p> <p>By the purchase of the property of the canal company under the act of February 4,1876, the city did not assume the duty of completing the contemplated work, and did not incur any responsibility for injuries resulting from its non-completion.</p> <p>A municipality which abandons a contemplated work of • public improvement, assumes thereby no obligation to parties who have invested on the faith and expectation of benefit from the completion of the work.</p> <p>When a contract for local improvements in a municipality is entered into, the contractor must look to the special assessments, and to them alone, for his compensation, and if they fail, without dereliction or wrong upon the part of the corporation, neither justice nor equity will toler
Judges: Brewer, Harlan, Brown
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
19 cases in this archive cite this case.
- New Orleans v. WarnerSupreme Court· 1899-11-13· cited 82×
- German-American Savings Bank v. City of SpokaneWashington Supreme Court· 1897-07-09· cited 47×
- Moore v. City of NampaSupreme Court· 1928-04-09· cited 25×
- Barber Asphalt Paving Co. v. City of HarrisburgThird Circuit· 1894-11-13· cited 23×
- Warner v. New OrleansSupreme Court· 1897-05-24· cited 19×
- Gray v. City of Santa FeTenth Circuit· 1937-03-31· cited 17×
- Broad v. City of MoscowIdaho Supreme Court· 1908-12-21· cited 16×
- Powell v. City of Ada, Okl.Tenth Circuit· 1932-09-26· cited 14×
- Kirby v. Omaha Bridge CommissionNebraska Supreme Court· 1934-06-13· cited 13×
- Brown-Crummer Inv. Co. v. City of MiamiN.D. Oklahoma· 1930-05-02· cited 5×
- City of El Paso v. WestFifth Circuit· 1939-04-06· cited 4×
- City of Winner v. KelleyEighth Circuit· 1933-06-29· cited 3×
- Purcell v. City of CarlsbadTenth Circuit· 1942-03-14· cited 3×
- City of Newberg v. Warren Construction Co.Oregon Supreme Court· 1929-03-27· cited 2×
- Wilder v. City of New OrleansU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Louisiana· 1895-02-06· cited 2×
- Town of Cicero v. PeopleAppellate Court of Illinois· 1903-01-16
- Casady v. First State BankW.D. Oklahoma· 1938-09-29
- Eddy v. City & County of San FranciscoD. California· 1906-08-24
- Eddy v. City & County of San FranciscoNinth Circuit· 1908-06-08
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Wood v. Guarantee Trust and Safe Deposit Co.Supreme Court· 1888-11-26· cited 101×
- Ketchum v. DuncanSupreme Court· 1878-05-13· cited 93×
- New Orleans Draining Co.Supreme Court of Louisiana· 1856-04-15· cited 11×
- Carter v. BurrSupreme Court· 1885-03-16· cited 9×
- Citizens' Bank v. BounySupreme Court of Louisiana· 1880-02-15· cited 9×
- Marquez v. City of New OrleansSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1858-05-15· cited 8×
- Correjolles v. Succession of FoucherSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1874-04-15· cited 6×
Other cases named Peake v. New Orleans
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.