Payton Castillo v. David Lloyd Rex, M.D.
Syllabus
In this appeal, we examine the privilege provided under Tennessee Code Annotated section 68-11-272, commonly referred to as the quality improvement committee or \QIC\ privilege, and its application. Plaintiff filed this healthcare liability action asserting that CHI Memorial Hospital and other entities and physicians were negligent in providing care for her husband, who passed away shortly after being discharged from the hospital's emergency room. Defendants sought a protective order based on the QIC privilege to prohibit inquiry into a meeting held by the hospital and the decedent's family. The trial court denied Defendants' motion. On interlocutory review, the Court of Appeals affirmed, finding that statements made in the meeting were not protected by the QIC privilege. Defendants appealed, arguing that the information sought related to QIC activities and therefore was privileged from direct or indirect discovery. We hold the QIC privilege applied to statements made during the meeting that were based on information obtained during the QIC process, but Memorial waived the privilege when hospital management voluntarily disclosed that privileged information.
Judges: Justice Dwight E. Tarwater
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCites
32 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. NixonSupreme Court· 1974-07-24· cited 4,095×
- Upjohn Co. v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1981-01-13· cited 3,227×
- Lee Medical, Inc. v. Paula BeecherTennessee Supreme Court· 2010-05-24· cited 990×
- Jaffee v. RedmondSupreme Court· 1996-06-13· cited 915×
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. WeintraubSupreme Court· 1985-04-29· cited 753×
- White v. Vanderbilt UniversityCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1999-12-30· cited 502×
- Konvalinka v. Chattanooga-Hamilton County Hospital AuthorityTennessee Supreme Court· 2008-02-13· cited 479×
- Calvin Gray Mills, Jr. v. Fulmarque, Inc.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2012-02-24· cited 248×
- Frontier Refining Inc. v. Gorman-Rupp Co.Tenth Circuit· 1998-02-13· cited 241×
- State v. ThompsonTennessee Supreme Court· 1989-02-27· cited 240×
- Flautt & Mann v. Council of City of MemphisCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2008-04-10· cited 186×
- Boyd v. Comdata Network, Inc.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 2002-04-30· cited 182×
- Doe Ex Rel. Doe v. Roman Catholic Diocese of NashvilleTennessee Supreme Court· 2005-01-18· cited 117×
- State v. OsteinTennessee Supreme Court· 2009-08-20· cited 111×
- Waldschmidt v. Reassure America Life Insurance Co.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2008-11-24· cited 99×
- Kimberly Powell v. Community Health Systems, Inc.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2010-05-24· cited 88×
- Smith County Education Ass'n v. AndersonTennessee Supreme Court· 1984-08-20· cited 81×
- Bailey v. Blount County Board of EducationTennessee Supreme Court· 2010-01-28· cited 67×
- Arnold v. City of ChattanoogaCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1999-11-22· cited 66×
- Bryan v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee· 1992-08-12· cited 55×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.