McGilvra v. Ross
Citations
- 215 U.S. 70
- 30 S. Ct. 27
- 54 L. Ed. 95
- 1909 U.S. LEXIS 1733
Syllabus
<p>While the construction of the act of Congress under which a patent issued and what rights passed under the patent present Federal questions which give the Circuit Court jurisdiction of the case as one arising under the laws of the United States, if prior decisions have so defined such rights that they are removed from controversy, jurisdiction does not exist in the absence of diverse citizenship.</p> <p>The decision in Shively v. Bowlby, 152 U. S. 1, which determined the relative rights of a patentee of the United States and one holding under a conveyance from the State of land below high watermark applies equally to lands bordering on navigable waters, whether tidal or inland, and the test of navigability is one of fact.</p> <p>Each State has full jurisdiction over the lands within its borders including the beds of streams and other waters, Kansas v. Colorado, 206 U. S. 46, 93, subject to the rights granted by the Constitution to the United States.</p> <p>Where the Circuit Court is without jurisdiction because the Federal questions presented by the bill are no longer open to discussion it should dismiss the bill and not decide it on the merits in order that the plaintiff’s rights, if any, may be litigated in the state, courts.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- definition of navigable waters as used in Shivley meant waters which were navigable in fact
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: McKenna, Holmes
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
94 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Hagans v. LavineSupreme Court· 1974-03-25· cited 2,844×
- Goosby v. OsserSupreme Court· 1973-01-17· cited 432×
- Levering & Garrigues Co. v. MorrinSupreme Court· 1933-04-10· cited 405×
- In Re Bendectin Litigation.Sixth Circuit· 1988-08-30· cited 252×
- Borax Consolidated, Ltd. v. Los AngelesSupreme Court· 1935-11-11· cited 194×
- Hannis Distilling Co. v. Mayor and City Council of BaltimoreSupreme Court· 1910-02-21· cited 183×
- Somali Development Bank v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1974-12-18· cited 139×
- Phillips Petroleum Co. v. MississippiSupreme Court· 1988-05-16· cited 117×
- Reliance Insurance Co. v. Barron'sS.D. New York· 1977-11-18· cited 77×
- Clifford Wiley v. National Collegiate Athletic AssociationTenth Circuit· 1979-12-17· cited 58×
- Ryals v. PigottMississippi Supreme Court· 1990-11-28· cited 46×
- Skokomish Indian Tribe v. E. L. France, TrusteeNinth Circuit· 1959-06-26· cited 45×
- Cinque Bambini Partnership v. StateMississippi Supreme Court· 1986-07-30· cited 40×
- Shawnee Sewerage & Drainage Co. v. StearnsSupreme Court· 1911-04-24· cited 38×
- Thomas W. Jones, Etc. v. Edgar M. BraniginSixth Circuit· 1970-10-21· cited 35×
- Keiser v. BellE.D. Pennsylvania· 1971-08-19· cited 35×
- Moreno v. University of MarylandD. Maryland· 1976-07-13· cited 30×
- Miller v. SmithE.D. Pennsylvania· 1965-08-25· cited 30×
- Walter S. Farley, Jr. v. Walter S. Farley, Jr.Third Circuit· 1973-06-25· cited 28×
- Cantor v. Supreme Court of PennsylvaniaE.D. Pennsylvania· 1973-01-31· cited 28×
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Shively v. BowlbySupreme Court· 1894-03-05· cited 734×
- United States v. WinansSupreme Court· 1905-05-15· cited 397×
- The Propeller Genesee Chief v. FitzhughSupreme Court· 1852-02-20· cited 380×
- Barney v. KeokukSupreme Court· 1877-04-23· cited 297×
- Scranton v. WheelerSupreme Court· 1900-12-03· cited 248×
- Joy v. City of St. LouisSupreme Court· 1906-04-02· cited 92×
- Prosser v. Northern Pacific RailroadSupreme Court· 1894-03-05· cited 15×
Other cases named McGilvra v. Ross
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.