McDuff v. State

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding that “the tragic fact that a fatality arises out of a motor vehicle accident is in no way, standing alone, an indicator that alcohol or drags were involved”
• statute providing that \[t]he operator of any motor vehicle involved in an accident that results in death shall be tested\ is unconstitutional because it \requires search and seizure absent probable cause\
• “[T]he tragic fact that a fatality arises out of a motor vehicle accident is in no way, standing alone, an indicator that alcohol or drugs were involved.”
• “Because the statute is designed to further this law enforcement purpose, we do not believe it falls within the special needs exception to the probable cause requirement.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

33 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Culp v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 2005-12-15· cited 59×
• Ginn v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 2003-10-09· cited 39×
• State v. Declerck
  Court of Appeals of Kansas· 2014-02-07· cited 38×
• State v. Aleman
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2005-04-04· cited 33×
• Comby v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2004-12-14· cited 16×
• Sanders v. Chamblee
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 2002-06-20· cited 16×
• State v. Cormier
  Supreme Judicial Court of Maine· 2007-08-14· cited 16×
• Havard v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2001-07-31· cited 15×
• Holloman v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2002-06-18· cited 15×
• STEWART v. STATE
  Court of Criminal Appeals of Oklahoma· 2019-05-16· cited 14×
• Ware v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2001-02-27· cited 12×
• Wash v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2001-02-20· cited 12×
• Irby v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 2010-12-09· cited 11×
• State v. Quinn
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2008-03-25· cited 11×
• State v. Meitler
  Court of Appeals of Kansas· 2015-03-27· cited 11×
• Brown v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2008-05-20· cited 10×
• Vaughn v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2008-01-08· cited 8×
• Jones v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2006-02-07· cited 8×
• Shaw v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2005-12-06· cited 6×
• Jones v. State
  Court of Appeals of Mississippi· 2003-05-06· cited 6×

Cites

24 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Schmerber v. California
  Supreme Court· 1966-06-20· cited 6,067×
• Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives' Assn.
  Supreme Court· 1989-03-21· cited 2,560×
• People v. LaFontaine
  New York Court of Appeals· 1998-12-03· cited 257×
• State v. Bickham
  Supreme Court of Louisiana· 1981-09-28· cited 155×
• Parker v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1992-08-31· cited 153×
• Commonwealth v. Kohl
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1992-09-16· cited 149×
• Commonwealth v. England
  Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1977-07-08· cited 119×
• Ashley v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1982-11-03· cited 87×
• Cotton v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1996-05-09· cited 74×
• State v. O'KELLY
  Supreme Court of Iowa· 1973-10-17· cited 62×
• King v. Ryan
  Illinois Supreme Court· 1992-12-04· cited 55×
• Perry v. State
  Supreme Court of Arkansas· 1990-07-16· cited 39×
• People v. Vigil
  Supreme Court of Colorado· 1986-12-08· cited 35×
• Ricks v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1992-12-31· cited 31×
• Nash v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1968-02-12· cited 27×
• McLean v. Mississippi Ex Rel. Roy
  Fifth Circuit· 1938-05-12· cited 24×
• State v. Roche
  Supreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1996-08-20· cited 21×
• Isaacks v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1977-09-14· cited 20×
• Cole v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1986-09-17· cited 18×
• Williams v. State
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 1983-07-20· cited 18×