Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 9/22/1980
Mattos v. Thompson
Citations
- 421 A.2d 190
- 491 Pa. 385
- 1980 Pa. LEXIS 775
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- recognizing that a restrictive statutory provision in the Health Care Services Malpractice Act imper-missibly infringes on the constitutional right to trial by jury
- striking as unconstitutional a statute giving arbitration panel original jurisdiction over medical malpractice claims where delays involved in statutory procedures oppressively burdened. the right to a jury trial so as to “make the right practically unavailable”
- striking as unconstitutional a statute giving arbitration panel original jurisdiction over medical malpractice claims where delays involved in statutory procedures oppressively burdened the right to a jury trial so as to \make the right practically unavailable\
- oppressive delays in mandatory arbitration under Pennsylvania’s Health Care Services Malpractice Act constitute an impermissible burden on the state constitutional right to jury trial
- statutory arbitration scheme first upheld in Parker later determined to cause lengthy delays which present onerous conditions and restrictions which impose oppressive burden on that right
- statutory arbitration scheme first upheld in Parker later determined to cause lengthy delays which present onerous conditions and restrictions which impose oppressive burden on that right
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Eagen, O'Brien, Roberts, Nix, Larsen, Flaherty, Kauffman
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
52 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Thompson v. Nason HospitalSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1991-05-20· cited 209×
- American Bank & Trust Co. v. Community HospitalCalifornia Supreme Court· 1984-07-09· cited 170×
- Zeier v. Zimmer, Inc.Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 2006-12-19· cited 104×
- Fletcher v. Pennsylvania Property & Casualty Insurance Guaranty Ass'nSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-12-15· cited 96×
- Beatty v. Akron City HospitalOhio Supreme Court· 1981-08-12· cited 78×
- Rosemarie T. Schwilm, Administratrix of the Estate of Carrol A. Schwilm, Deceased v. Thomas J. Holbrook, M.D. And Cabell Huntington HospitalThird Circuit· 1981-09-28· cited 74×
- Butler v. Flint Goodrich Hosp. of Dillard Univ.Supreme Court of Louisiana· 1992-11-10· cited 72×
- Hoem v. StateWyoming Supreme Court· 1988-06-14· cited 60×
- Firelock Inc. v. District Court in & for the 20th Judicial District of the State of ColoradoSupreme Court of Colorado· 1989-07-24· cited 59×
- Grant v. GAF Corp.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1992-04-30· cited 57×
- Morris v. MetriyakoolMichigan Court of Appeals· 1981-06-05· cited 54×
- Keyes v. Humana Hospital Alaska, Inc.Alaska Supreme Court· 1988-02-19· cited 51×
- Hoffman v. Memorial Osteopathic HospitalSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-05-10· cited 50×
- Zauflik, A., Aplt. v. Pennsbury School DistrictSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-11-19· cited 45×
- Simmons v. St. Clair Memorial HospitalSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-08-17· cited 43×
- Cha v. WarnickIndiana Supreme Court· 1985-04-03· cited 42×
- Heller v. FrankstonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-04-18· cited 39×
- Lacy v. GreenSuperior Court of Delaware· 1981-03-09· cited 32×
- Fastuca v. L.W. Molnar & AssociatesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-01-18· cited 30×
- Coburn by and Through Coburn v. AgustinD. Kansas· 1985-11-25· cited 26×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Smith v. AllwrightSupreme Court· 1944-06-12· cited 875×
- Johnson v. St. Vincent Hospital, Inc.Indiana Supreme Court· 1980-05-16· cited 365×
- In Re William L.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1978-01-31· cited 319×
- Everett v. GoldmanSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1978-05-22· cited 218×
- State Ex Rel. Strykowski v. WilkieWisconsin Supreme Court· 1978-01-03· cited 211×
- American Federation of Labor v. American Sash & Door Co.Supreme Court· 1949-01-03· cited 188×
- Eastin v. BroomfieldArizona Supreme Court· 1977-09-27· cited 186×
- Daly v. HemphillSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1963-06-04· cited 184×
- Nellie Woods, as Personal Representative of the Estate of John N. Woods v. Holy Cross HospitalFifth Circuit· 1979-03-26· cited 149×
- Tosto v. Pennsylvania Nursing Home Loan AgencySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1975-01-27· cited 139×
- Prendergast v. NelsonNebraska Supreme Court· 1977-07-20· cited 136×
- Parker v. Children's Hospital of Phila.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1978-11-01· cited 126×
- Flightways Corp. v. Keystone Helicopter Corp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1975-01-27· cited 125×
- Smith CaseSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1955-03-23· cited 119×
- Paro v. Longwood HospitalMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1977-11-16· cited 116×
- Marshall v. Daniel Construction Co.Supreme Court· 1978-10-02· cited 93×
- Comiskey v. ArlenAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1976-12-20· cited 74×
- Moore v. JamiesonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1973-03-19· cited 70×
- Capecci v. Joseph Capecci, Inc.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1958-03-17· cited 29×
- Children's Hospital v. American Arbitration Ass'nSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1974-12-11· cited 28×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.