MALDONADO-CRUZ
Citations
- 19 I. & N. Dec. 509
Syllabus
MALDONADO-CRUZ, 19 I&N Dec. 509 (BIA 1988) ID 3041 (PDF) (1) A threat to harm or kill a deserter from a guerrilla organization operating in a country does not constitute persecution under the Refugee Act of 1980, Pub. L. No. 96-212, 94 Stat. 102.(2) In analyzing a claim of persecution made in the context of a civil war, it is necessary to examine the motivation of the group threatening harm. (3) The threat to harm a deserter from the guerrilla organization is part of a military policy of that group, inherent in the nature of the organization, and a tool of discipline thus, the threat is neitheran act of persecution nor evidence of persecution by the guerrilla organization on account of political opinion, or any other ground set forth in the Refugee Act of 1980. (4) The holding of Bolanos-Hernandez v. INS, 767 F.2d 1277 (9th Cir. 1984), is not applied outside of the Ninth Circuit. (5) It is not persecution for the government of a country to investigate and detain individuals suspected of aiding or being a member of a guerrilla organization.
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- finding that punishment or threat of punishment for desertion is disciplinary tool; thus, such threat is neither act of persecution, nor evidence of persecution on account of political opinion or any other ground set forth in Act
- finding that punishment or threat of punishment for desertion is disciplinary tool; thus, such threat is neither act of persecution, nor evidence of perse- cution on account of political opinion or any other ground set forth ABDEL-RAHMAN v. GONZALES 13 in Act
- “We know of no Fifth Circuit case which agrees with the rationale of Bolanos-Hernandez.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
11 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Vaso and Djela Perkovic v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSixth Circuit· 1994-08-29· cited 311×
- HBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1996-07-01· cited 116×
- CHANGBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1989-07-01· cited 74×
- Said Husni Al-Fara Bahya Safi v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United StatesThird Circuit· 2005-04-14· cited 67×
- Abdel-Rahman v. GonzalesFourth Circuit· 2007-07-12· cited 39×
- T-M-BBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1997-07-01· cited 38×
- Civil v. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceFirst Circuit· 1998-05-18· cited 23×
- VIGILBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1987-07-01· cited 14×
- Civil v. INSFirst Circuit· 1998-05-18
- Al-Fara v. Atty Gen USAThird Circuit· 2005-04-14
- Al-Fara v. GonzalesThird Circuit· 2005-02-14
Cites
28 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Cardoza-FonsecaSupreme Court· 1987-03-09· cited 4,149×
- Woodby v. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceSupreme Court· 1966-12-12· cited 1,005×
- MOGARRABIBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1987-07-01· cited 442×
- Luis Alonzo Sanchez-Trujillo, and Luis Armando Escobar-Nieto v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1986-10-15· cited 268×
- William Joseph Quinn v. Glen Robinson, United States Marshal for the Northern District of CaliforniaNinth Circuit· 1986-02-18· cited 262×
- Espectacion Bolanos-Hernandez v. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1985-06-14· cited 257×
- Djordje Kovac v. Immigration and Naturalization Service, John P. Boyd, District Director, Seattle, WashingtonNinth Circuit· 1969-01-29· cited 203×
- Reginaldo Diaz-Escobar v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1986-02-14· cited 180×
- Adela Hernandez-Ortiz v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1985-12-02· cited 167×
- Rene Carvajal-Munoz v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1984-09-12· cited 129×
- Ziyad Abu Eain v. Peter Wilkes, United States Marshal for the Northern District of IllinoisSeventh Circuit· 1981-02-20· cited 126×
- Gaspar Eugenio Jimenez Escobedo v. United States of America, Gustavo Castillo v. Donald D. Forsht, U. S. MarshalFifth Circuit· 1980-08-14· cited 115×
- Jose Enrique Lopez v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1985-10-31· cited 100×
- Bhima Nathubhai Patel v. United States Immigration and Naturalization ServiceFifth Circuit· 1986-05-28· cited 78×
- Sofia Campos-Guardado v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceFifth Circuit· 1987-03-09· cited 69×
- Rosa Candida Martinez-Romero v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1982-11-10· cited 65×
- Peter Gabriel John McMullen v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1986-04-25· cited 51×
- SANTOSBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1984-07-01· cited 37×
- Ghazwan and Nashwan Dally, Tarik Jerjis Khamou and Sabiha Hermiz, Asam J. Satto and Lamia K. Satto v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSixth Circuit· 1984-09-20· cited 31×
- In re EzetaN.D. California· 1894-09-22· cited 31×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.