Lutfy v. Lockhart

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• reversingjury verdict on plaintiffs negligent entrustment claim and stating trial court should have granted directed verdict on it because “no evidence” established that vehicle’s owner had known of driver’s alleged incompetence
• “An automobile is a machine that is capable of doing great damage if not carefully handled, and for this reason the owner must use care in allowing others to assume control over it.” (citation omitted)
• giving automobile to incompetent driver

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

38 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Mundy v. Pirie-Slaughter Motor Co.
  Texas Supreme Court· 1948-01-07· cited 135×
• Morris v. Cartwright
  New Mexico Supreme Court· 1953-04-29· cited 60×
• Siebrand v. Gossnell
  Ninth Circuit· 1956-05-23· cited 49×
• Alabam Freight Lines v. Phoenix Bakery, Inc.
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1946-02-25· cited 45×
• Silva v. Traver
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1945-10-15· cited 43×
• Strandt v. Cannon
  California Court of Appeal· 1938-11-30· cited 42×
• Lindsey v. Barton
  Supreme Court of Alabama· 1954-01-14· cited 39×
• Casey v. Marshall
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1946-04-22· cited 38×
• Tellez v. Saban
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1996-09-24· cited 35×
• Hardwick v. Bublitz
  Supreme Court of Iowa· 1961-10-17· cited 33×
• Anderson Aviation Sales Company, Inc. v. Perez
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1973-03-22· cited 32×
• Powell v. Langford
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1941-12-01· cited 32×
• Trauscht v. Lamb
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1954-05-26· cited 24×
• State Farm Automobile Insurance v. Dressler
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1987-02-17· cited 21×
• Christy v. Baker
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1968-04-08· cited 17×
• Verduzco v. American Valet
  Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2016-06-21· cited 17×
• Braughton v. United Air Lines, Inc.
  W.D. Missouri· 1960-06-01· cited 15×
• Collins v. Riverside Amusement Park Co.
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1944-02-07· cited 13×
• McGrew v. Stone
  Kentucky Supreme Court· 1999-08-26· cited 12×
• Duty v. East Coast Tender Service, Inc.
  Fourth Circuit· 1981-01-23· cited 12×

Cites

7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Crowell v. Duncan
  Supreme Court of Virginia· 1926-09-23· cited 92×
• Elliott v. Hardins
  Ohio Supreme Court· 1923-05-08· cited 57×
• Otero v. Soto Ex Rel. Gonzales
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1928-06-11· cited 40×
• Baker v. Maseeh
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1919-03-14· cited 36×
• McIver v. Allen
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1927-12-19· cited 19×
• Coppinger v. Broderick
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1931-01-26· cited 15×
• Southern Pacific Railroad v. Svendsen
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1910-04-02· cited 8×