Oregon Supreme Court· 5/1/2008
Lowe v. Philip Morris USA, Inc.
Citations
- 183 P.3d 181
- 344 Or. 403
- 2008 Ore. LEXIS 273
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that the court’s statement in Joshi regarding deprivation of a 30 percent chance of survival “goes to the causal connection necessary to prove negligence, not the type of injury necessary to state a negligence claim”
- “Following our precedents, we hold that 19 negligent conduct that results only in a significantly increased risk of future injury that requires medical monitoring does not give rise to a claim for negligence.”
- “Oregon law has long recognized that the fact that a defendant’s negligence poses a threat of future physical harm is not sufficient, standing alone, to constitute an actionable injury”
- a plaintiff must allege and prove an actual loss or harm to make out a claim for negligence
- “the present economic harm that defendants’ actions allegedly have caused -- the cost of medical monitoring -- is not sufficient to give rise to a negligence claim”
- “Oregon law has long recognized that the fact that a defendant’s negligence poses a threat of future physical harm is not sufficient, standing alone, to constitute an actionable injury.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: De Muniz, Gillette, Durham, Balmer, Kistler, Walters
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
21 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Caronia v. Philip Morris USA, Inc.Second Circuit· 2013-05-01· cited 190×
- Johnson v. Wells Fargo Home Mortgage, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2011-02-15· cited 81×
- Caronia v. Philip Morris USA, Inc.New York Court of Appeals· 2013-12-17· cited 37×
- Paul v. Providence Health System-OregonOregon Supreme Court· 2012-02-24· cited 24×
- Klutschkowski v. PeaceHealthOregon Supreme Court· 2013-09-26· cited 17×
- In re Gen. Motors LLCS.D. Illinois· 2018-09-12· cited 16×
- Tomlinson v. Metropolitan Pediatrics, LLCCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2015-12-30· cited 14×
- Paul v. Providence Health System-OregonCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2010-10-06· cited 12×
- Smith v. Providence Health & Services - OregonOregon Supreme Court· 2017-05-11· cited 10×
- Classen v. Arete NW, LLCCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2012-12-19· cited 9×
- Bell v. 3M Co.D. Colorado· 2018-09-25· cited 7×
- Dougan v. Sikorsky Aircraft Corp.Supreme Court of Connecticut· 2020-09-14· cited 6×
- Alexander Manufacturing, Inc. v. Illinois Union InsuranceD. Oregon· 2009-10-15· cited 5×
- Berry v. City of ChicagoAppellate Court of Illinois· 2019-10-07· cited 2×
- Smith v. Providence Health & Services - OregonCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 2015-04-08· cited 2×
- Lunsford v. NCH Corp.Court of Appeals of Oregon· 2015-06-03· cited 1×
- Inc.Colorado Court of Appeals· 2025-10-30· cited 1×
- Sadler v. PacifiCare of Nev.Nevada Supreme Court· 2014-12-31
- Bohr v. Tillamook County Creamery Assn.Oregon Supreme Court· 2025-04-03
- Kevin Brown et al v Saint-Gobain Performance PlasticsD. New Hampshire· 2017-12-06
Cites
27 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Potter v. Firestone Tire & Rubber Co.California Supreme Court· 1993-12-27· cited 493×
- William Barnes v. The American Tobacco CompanyThird Circuit· 1998-11-12· cited 337×
- Ayers v. Township of JacksonSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1987-05-07· cited 310×
- Metro-North Commuter Railroad v. BuckleySupreme Court· 1997-06-23· cited 198×
- Henry v. Dow Chemical CompanyMichigan Supreme Court· 2005-07-13· cited 193×
- Norwest v. Presbyterian Intercommunity HospitalOregon Supreme Court· 1982-10-05· cited 170×
- Onita Pacific Corp. v. Trustees of BronsonOregon Supreme Court· 1992-12-31· cited 144×
- Oregon Steel Mills, Inc. v. Coopers & Lybrand, LLPOregon Supreme Court· 2004-01-23· cited 117×
- Hansen v. Mountain Fuel Supply Co.Utah Supreme Court· 1993-08-04· cited 112×
- Hale v. GroceOregon Supreme Court· 1987-11-03· cited 111×
- William Hagerty v. L & L Marine Services, Inc., and Union Carbide Corp.Fifth Circuit· 1986-04-30· cited 105×
- Mauro v. Raymark Industries, Inc.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1989-08-01· cited 84×
- Solberg v. JohnsonOregon Supreme Court· 1988-08-30· cited 80×
- Hammond v. Central Lane Communications CenterOregon Supreme Court· 1991-08-22· cited 75×
- G. L. v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals, Inc.Oregon Supreme Court· 1988-06-07· cited 67×
- Joshi v. Providence Health System of Oregon Corp.Oregon Supreme Court· 2006-12-21· cited 65×
- Herber v. Johns-Manville Corp.Third Circuit· 1986-03-05· cited 57×
- Zehr v. HaugenOregon Supreme Court· 1994-04-21· cited 55×
- Wood v. Wyeth-Ayerst Laboratories, Division of American Home ProductsKentucky Supreme Court· 2002-08-22· cited 52×
- William Hagerty v. L & L Marine Services, Inc., and Union Carbide Corp.Fifth Circuit· 1986-08-20· cited 49×
Other cases named Lowe v. Philip Morris USA, Inc.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.