L.J. v. Carricato
Citations
- 2018 COA 3
- 413 P.3d 1280
Syllabus
D.J.M., age 2, died after suffering a beating by his mother's boyfriend. D.J.M.'s father brought an action against the City of Colorado Springs (City) and Officer Carricato, individually and in his capacity as an officer with the City of Colorado Springs Police Department, for failing to report child abuse that father complained about to them multiple times. The complaint alleged violation of the Child Protection Act of 1987 (CPA) negligence (wrongful death) by the City and Officer Carricato negligence per se by the City and Officer Carricato violation of 42 USC § 1983 by the City and Officer Carricato vicarious liability against the City and an entitlement to exemplary damages under CRS § 24-10-118(1)(c) against Officer Carricato. The district court determined that while the negligence claims for wrongful death and negligence per se were barred by the Colorado Governmental Immunity Act (CGIA), the claim for violation of the CPA was not barred because it was not a claim based in tort. The district court allowed the claim for vicarious liability to stand insofar as it related to the violation of the CPA and found, without conducting a hearing under Trinity Broadcasting of Denver, Inc. v. City of Westminster, that the complaint alleged a sufficient factual basis to support a claim of willful and wanton behavior. On appeal, the City and Officer Carricato argued that the district court erred because the CGIA bars the claim for violation of the CPA and father's complaint does not allege specific facts sufficient to support a finding that Officer Carricato's conduct was willful and wanton. The City is undisputedly a \public entity.\ The exceptions to sovereign immunity are not applicable here because (1) the enumerated statutory exceptions are not at issue (2) the CPA does not fit within any of the statutory exceptions and (3) father is not requesting equitable, remedial, or non-compensatory remedies. Here, the essence of father's claim is that the City breached a duty of
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- “The district court must determine whether the conduct was in fact willful and wanton.”
- \[I]t is not enough for the district court to merely determine that the complaint adequately alleged that the conduct was willful and wanton. The district court must determine whether the conduct was in fact willful and wanton.\
- “[I]t is not enough for the district court to merely determine that the complaint adequately alleged that the conduct was willful and wanton. The district court must determine whether the 9 conduct was in fact willful and wanton.” (citing Martinez, 379 P.3d at 317–18, 322)
- “The plaintiff bears the burden of proving jurisdiction.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
3 cases in this archive cite this case.
Cites
26 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Robinson v. Shell Oil Co.Supreme Court· 1997-02-18· cited 2,720×
- Valentine v. Mountain States Mutual Casualty Co.Colorado Court of Appeals· 2011-01-06· cited 1,127×
- Trinity Broadcasting of Denver, Inc. v. City of WestminsterSupreme Court of Colorado· 1993-04-12· cited 263×
- Robinson v. Colorado State Lottery DivisionSupreme Court of Colorado· 2008-03-24· cited 236×
- Springer v. City & County of DenverSupreme Court of Colorado· 2000-11-14· cited 135×
- Medina v. StateSupreme Court of Colorado· 2001-11-27· cited 106×
- State v. MoldovanSupreme Court of Colorado· 1992-12-14· cited 73×
- City of Colorado Springs v. ConnersSupreme Court of Colorado· 2000-02-07· cited 58×
- Moody v. UngererSupreme Court of Colorado· 1994-06-13· cited 55×
- City of Florence v. PepperSupreme Court of Colorado· 2006-10-02· cited 42×
- Jenkins v. Panama Canal Railway Co.Supreme Court of Colorado· 2009-05-18· cited 39×
- Martinez v. Estate of Bleck Ex Rel. ChurchillSupreme Court of Colorado· 2016-09-12· cited 34×
- Pizza Hut of America, Inc. v. KeefeSupreme Court of Colorado· 1995-06-30· cited 32×
- Colorado Department of Transportation v. Brown Group Retail, Inc.Supreme Court of Colorado· 2008-04-14· cited 31×
- Property Tax Administrator v. Production Geophysical Services, Inc.Supreme Court of Colorado· 1993-09-27· cited 29×
- Walcott v. Total Petroleum, Inc.Colorado Court of Appeals· 1998-08-20· cited 28×
- Bryant v. Community Choice Credit UnionColorado Court of Appeals· 2007-01-25· cited 24×
- Burnett v. Colorado Dep't of Natural Resources, Div. of Parks and Outdoor RecreationSupreme Court of Colorado· 2015-03-23· cited 21×
- Gray v. University of Colorado Hospital AuthorityColorado Court of Appeals· 2012-07-05· cited 19×
- Town of Minturn v. TuckerSupreme Court of Colorado· 2013-01-22· cited 9×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.