Sixth Circuit· 5/30/2023
John Does 1-5 v. Gretchen Whitmer
Citations
- 69 F.4th 300
Oral argument
- ListenArgued46 min recording
Source: CourtListener oral-argument corpus (CC0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that the Sixth Circuit “treat[s] sovereign immunity as a ‘jurisdictional bar’ that, ‘once raised as a jurisdictional defect, must be decided before the merits’”
- noting that the court was “free to address the merits before sovereign immunity” because the defendants raised the issue in a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, rather than a Rule 12(b)(1) motion
- finding that plaintiff’s allegations supervisors knew that their subordinates were violating the plaintiffs’ constitutional rights, but failed to intervene, and that this failure encouraged and implicitly authorized the alleged constitutional violations, insufficient for supervisory liability
- “To survive a motion to dismiss, a plaintiff must plausibly allege ‘active unconstitutional behavior,’ which goes beyond ‘a mere failure to act.’” (citations omitted)
- court must “look to whether the sovereign is the real party in interest,” by determining “in the first instance whether the remedy sought is truly against the sovereign.”
- “Sovereign immunity bars official-capacity suits for damages, but not individual-capacity suits for damages.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
4 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Iesha Mitchell v. City of Benton Harbor, Mich.Sixth Circuit· 2025-05-06· cited 14×
- Geomatrix, LLC v. NSF Int'lSixth Circuit· 2023-09-12· cited 6×
- Qualitee Moshi v. Kia Motors Am., Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2025-09-16
- White's Landing Fisheries, Inc. v. Ohio Dep't of Nat. Res. Div. of WildlifeSixth Circuit· 2026-04-22
Cites
18 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Ashcroft v. IqbalSupreme Court· 2009-05-18· cited 149,772×
- Kentucky v. GrahamSupreme Court· 1985-06-28· cited 11,385×
- Hafer v. MeloSupreme Court· 1991-11-05· cited 4,063×
- Scott Peatross v. City of MemphisSixth Circuit· 2016-03-29· cited 710×
- Lewis v. ClarkeSupreme Court· 2017-04-25· cited 292×
- Julie Helphenstine v. Lewis CountySixth Circuit· 2023-02-09· cited 256×
- Dawn Crawford v. John TilleySixth Circuit· 2021-10-08· cited 242×
- John Russell v. Allison Lundergan-GrimesSixth Circuit· 2015-04-28· cited 224×
- John Does v. Richard SnyderSixth Circuit· 2016-09-15· cited 182×
- Jennifer Garza v. Lansing Sch. DistrictSixth Circuit· 2020-08-28· cited 128×
- D. Sreedharan Nair v. Oakland County Community Mental Health Authority and William J. AllenSixth Circuit· 2006-04-04· cited 92×
- Native American Distributing v. Seneca-Cayuga Tobacco Co.Tenth Circuit· 2008-11-17· cited 82×
- Starnes Canale Funeral Directors v. Regions Morgan Keegan SelectSixth Circuit· 2016-05-19· cited 61×
- Laura Martin v. Jack WoodFourth Circuit· 2014-11-18· cited 41×
- Craig Cunningham v. Deborah LesterFourth Circuit· 2021-03-04· cited 33×
- Doe v. City of RosevilleSixth Circuit· 2002-09-19· cited 22×
- John Does 1-4 v. SnyderE.D. Michigan· 2013-03-18· cited 13×
- BNA Assocs. LLC v. Goldman Sachs Specialty Lending Group, L.P.Sixth Circuit· 2023-03-29· cited 9×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.