Third Circuit· 3/17/2010
Holmes v. Kimco Realty Corp.
Citations
- 598 F.3d 115
- 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 5502
- 2010 WL 935779
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that \the great majority of other jurisdictions ... hold that a lessee in a multi-tenant shopping center does not have a duty to maintain common areas controlled by the landlord\
- stating that “the rule adopted by the great majority” of jurisdictions is that “a lessee in a multi-tenant shopping center does not have a duty to maintain common areas controlled by the landlord”
- observing that, although a shopping center tenant derives a benefit from the parking lot and a duty would incentivize the tenant to prevent dangerous condi tions, “countervailing policy considerations weigh more heavily against imposition of a duty”
- outlining the policy reasons against the imposition of a duty on tenants in a multi-tenant shopping center over common areas
- declining to impose a duty \on an individual tenant for snow removal from the common areas of a multi-tenant parking lot when the landlord has retained and exercised that responsibility\
- “In predicting how the highest state court would decide an issue .. . [wle may also look to ‘scholarly treatises, the Restatement of Law, and germane law review articles.’” (emphasis added
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Fisher, Hardiman, Van Antwerpen
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Mayer v. BelichickThird Circuit· 2010-05-19· cited 1,893×
- McDevitt v. Sportsman's Warehouse, Inc.Idaho Supreme Court· 2011-05-27· cited 34×
- Ephraim Dabush v. Seacret Direct LLCArizona Supreme Court· 2021-01-08· cited 27×
- Duncan-Bogley v. United StatesD. Maryland· 2018-12-06· cited 21×
- Papurello v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.W.D. Pennsylvania· 2015-11-16· cited 16×
- Lynn ex rel. Lynn v. Yamaha Golf-Car Co.W.D. Pennsylvania· 2012-08-16· cited 16×
- Nielsen v. Wal-Mart Store 2171New Jersey Superior Court App Division· 2013-01-11· cited 13×
- Perez v. Great Wolf Lodge of the Poconos LLCM.D. Pennsylvania· 2016-07-26· cited 9×
- Kandrac v. Marrazzo's MarketNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 2012-11-05· cited 8×
- Sansom v. Crown Equipment Corp.W.D. Pennsylvania· 2012-07-24· cited 8×
- Leonard v. Golden Touch Transportation of New York, Inc.D. New Jersey· 2015-11-18· cited 5×
- Doe 6 v. Pennsylvania State UniversityE.D. Pennsylvania· 2013-11-06· cited 4×
- Simkins v. Bank of Nova ScotiaSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2025-01-10· cited 1×
- Charles Kemp v. PJC of Rhode Island, Inc., d/b/a Rite Aid of Rhode Island, Inc.Supreme Court of Rhode Island· 2018-06-06
Cites
34 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Hopkins v. Fox & Lazo RealtorsSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1993-06-16· cited 484×
- Sondra L. McKenna and James R. McKenna v. Ortho Pharmaceutical CorporationThird Circuit· 1980-06-17· cited 390×
- Michael Kopec v. Tyrone Tate, Officer Township of WhitemarshThird Circuit· 2004-03-17· cited 386×
- Carvalho v. Toll Bros. and DevelopersSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1996-05-06· cited 187×
- Stewart v. 104 Wallace Street, Inc.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1981-07-22· cited 168×
- Hunt v. United States Tobacco Co.Third Circuit· 2008-08-05· cited 159×
- Mirza v. Filmore Corp.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1983-02-08· cited 95×
- Durm v. Heck's, Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court· 1991-02-13· cited 89×
- Monaco v. Hartz Mountain Corp.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 2004-02-09· cited 56×
- Wilson v. AlldayMississippi Supreme Court· 1986-04-16· cited 54×
- Warrington v. BirdNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1985-10-17· cited 42×
- Aetna Casualty & Surety Company v. Michael A. Farrell and Jane L. Farrell, Appeal of Jane L. FarrellThird Circuit· 1988-08-31· cited 37×
- Underhill v. ShactmanMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1958-06-24· cited 35×
- Leary v. Lawrence Sales Corp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1971-03-18· cited 32×
- Hopkins v. F. W. Woolworth Co.Massachusetts Appeals Court· 1981-04-17· cited 32×
- Levy v. Home Depot, Inc.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 1987-12-29· cited 29×
- Jackson v. K-Mart Corp.New Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1981-11-16· cited 28×
- Torres v. Piggly Wiggly Shop Rite Foods, Inc.New Mexico Court of Appeals· 1979-07-24· cited 26×
- Merkel v. Safeway Stores, Inc.New Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1962-12-20· cited 24×
- Johnson v. Tom Thumb Stores, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 5th Dist. (Dallas)· 1989-04-25· cited 23×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.