Tenth Circuit· 12/19/2006
Hatch v. Boulder Town Council
Citations
- 471 F.3d 1142
- 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 31276
- 2006 WL 3720142
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- recognizing that the complaint “frames the scope of litigation, estab- lishing a transactional nexus into which facts and claims are fitted or ex- cluded for purposes of claim preclusion”
- noting Macris’s statement about subjective awareness but holding only that “any causes of action based on facts that occurred after [the date of the filing of the initial action] need not have been included in the case for claim-preclusion purposes”
- “Under the transactional test, a new action will be permitted only where it raises new and independent claims, not part of the previous transaction, based on the new facts.”
- “‘New’ claims, arising after the complaint has been filed, but before judgment, may be . . . litigated in a subsequent action.”
- “[A] claim arising out of the same transaction, or series of connected transactions as a previous suit . . . will be precluded.”
- “Under the transactional test, a new action will be permitted only where it raises new and independent claims, not part of the previous transaction, based on the new facts.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Baldock, Porfilio, Tymkovich
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
21 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Pueblo of Jemez v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 2015-06-26· cited 207×
- Lenox MacLaren Surgical Corp. v. Medtronic, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2017-02-07· cited 135×
- Patricia Kennedy v. Floridian Hotel, Inc.Eleventh Circuit· 2021-05-27· cited 111×
- Karen Vanover v. NCO Financial Services, Inc.Eleventh Circuit· 2017-05-17· cited 102×
- Denver Homeless Out Loud v. Denver, ColoradoTenth Circuit· 2022-05-03· cited 59×
- Lenox MacLaren Surgical Corp. v. Medtronic, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2014-08-05· cited 39×
- Herington v. City of WichitaSupreme Court of Kansas· 2021-12-17· cited 24×
- Carstarphen v. MilsnerD. Nevada· 2009-01-23· cited 20×
- Chen v. Dillard Store Services, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2014-08-27· cited 12×
- Stewart v. Virgin Islands Board of Land Use AppealsSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2017-04-26· cited 8×
- Taylor v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co.M.D. North Carolina· 2015-02-06· cited 6×
- Boone River, LLC v. Miles -- supplemental opinionNebraska Supreme Court· 2023-11-03· cited 6×
- Watkins v. GeneshTenth Circuit· 2025-04-29· cited 6×
- Hernandez v. Asset Acceptance, LLCD. Colorado· 2013-09-10· cited 5×
- Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Capital One Financial Corp.D. Maryland· 2015-03-02· cited 4×
- Oregon Natural Desert Ass'n v. SaboD. Oregon· 2012-03-30· cited 4×
- Markley v. U.S. Bank National AssociationTenth Circuit· 2025-06-24· cited 4×
- Stewart v. Transport Workers Union of Greater New York, Local 100S.D. New York· 2008-06-17· cited 3×
- In re Sandia Resorts, Inc.D. New Mexico· 2016-09-01· cited 1×
- Pueblo of Jemez v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 2015-07-21
Cites
14 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Mitchell v. City of MooreTenth Circuit· 2000-07-11· cited 564×
- Yapp v. Excel CorporationTenth Circuit· 1999-08-03· cited 292×
- Rivera v. City & County of DenverTenth Circuit· 2004-04-27· cited 243×
- Melissa Rawe Thomas J. Rawe Kimberly Rawe v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company Cynthia HoltcampSixth Circuit· 2006-09-01· cited 230×
- LAWRENCE STOREY, — v. CELLO HOLDINGS, L.L.C., CELLO MUSIC AND FILM SYSTEMS, INC., — HERRICK, FEINSTEIN LLP AND ODIN, FELDMAN & PITTLEMAN, P.C.Second Circuit· 2003-10-09· cited 208×
- Computer Associates International, Inc. v. Altai, Inc.Second Circuit· 1997-09-25· cited 138×
- Wilkes v. Wyoming Department of Employment Division of Labor StandardsTenth Circuit· 2002-12-23· cited 107×
- MacRis & Associates, Inc. v. Neways, Inc.Utah Supreme Court· 2000-12-05· cited 102×
- Stone v. Department of AviationTenth Circuit· 2006-07-06· cited 79×
- Patterson v. American Fork CityUtah Supreme Court· 2003-03-21· cited 67×
- Fox v. Security NationalTenth Circuit· 1997-04-28· cited 50×
- Snyder v. Murray City Corp.Utah Supreme Court· 2003-04-11· cited 43×
- Anderson v. Provo City Corp.Utah Supreme Court· 2005-01-21· cited 16×
- Hatch v. Boulder Town CouncilCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2001-02-23· cited 5×
Other cases named Hatch v. Boulder Town Council
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.