Hall v. Haines
Citations
- 43 Pa. Super. 213
- 1910 Pa. Super. LEXIS 33
Syllabus
<p>Lease — Mines and mining — Lease of slate land — Royalty—Covenant running with land — Assignment of lease — Fraud—Legal fraud. ■</p> <p>Where a lessee of slate land assigns all his right, title and interest in the lease to another, and the assignee agrees to pay in addition to the royalty due the lessor under the lease, two per cent, on the product to the lessee, his heirs or sublessees, “so long as the said indenture of lease shall remain in force and effect,” and the assignee subsequently notifies the lessor that he has lost money and cannot continue operations, and the lessor executes a new lease directly to the assignee at a reduced royalty, the original lessee after the abrogation of the first lease is no longer entitled to two per cent of the product.. In such a case the covenant to pay the two per cent is a personal one, and even if it ran with the land it ran no longer than the continuance of'the first lease. The action of the assignee in securing a new lease was not, under the circumstances, a legal fraud upon the original lessee.</p>
Judges: Beaver, Head, Henderson, Morrison, Orlady, Porter, Rice
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Young v. Forest Oil Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1899-12-30· cited 36×
- Bradford Oil Co. v. BlairSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1886-05-31· cited 22×
- Fennell v. GuffeySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1891-01-05· cited 21×
- Pocono Spring Water Ice Co. v. American Ice Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1906-04-09· cited 20×
- Bartley v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-01-04· cited 15×
- Stone v. Marshall Oil Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1898-11-14· cited 13×
- English v. YatesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1903-02-09· cited 10×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.