Bartley v. Phillips
Citations
- 179 Pa. 175
- 36 A. 217
- 1897 Pa. LEXIS 619
Syllabus
<p>Lease — Oil and gas lease — Clause of forfeiture.</p> <p>The clause of forfeiture or termination of the estate usually incorporated in oil and gas leases in this state is for the benefit of the lessor, and as against him no act of the lessee can work a forfeiture without his concurrence.</p> <p>Parties who lease or buy oil or gas lands, with a term apparently outstanding, without inquiry of the lessee, and without the exercise of the lessor’s power to forfeit, take the risk of the fact of abandonment of the first lease as the facts may be found by the jury.</p> <p>Defendant leased oil and gas lands from the owner. He had notice of the fact that there was an outstanding lease of ten years to plaintiffs, only three years of which had expired. The grantor of the lessor of defendant refused in his deed to assert a forfeiture of the first lease. Defendant made no inquiry of the plaintiffs as to whether their lease had been terminated. Held, (1) that the defendant had sufficient notice to put upon him the duty of inquiry; (2) that it was a question for the jury to determine whether there had been an abandonment of the first lease.</p> <p>Evidence — Testimony as to parly's intention.</p> <p>While in the case of a contract one party may not testify to an intent not disclosed at the time, in other cases, as where the character of the transaction depends on the intent of the party, it is competent for him to testify what his intention was.</p> <p>In an action of ejectment to recover oil and gas lands where the plaintiffs claim under a lease from the owner, and the defendant claims under a later lease from a grantee of the same owner, it is competent for the plaintiffs to testify that in removing certain materials from the land, they had no intention to abandon the lease.</p>
Judges: Dean, Fell, Green, McCollum, Mitchell, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
6 cases in this archive cite this case.
- English v. YatesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1903-02-09· cited 10×
- Wheeling v. PhillipsSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1899-07-28· cited 7×
- Harrop v. LutzSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1913-02-27· cited 7×
- Steele v. MaherSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-02-26· cited 6×
- Good Roads Machinery Co. v. Union TownshipSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1907-10-07· cited 3×
- Hall v. HainesSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1910-07-20
Cites
5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Wills v. Manufacturers N. Gas Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1889-11-12· cited 63×
- Venture Oil Co. v. FrettsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1893-01-16· cited 62×
- Juniata Building & Loan Ass'n v. HetzelSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1883-10-01· cited 24×
- Commonwealth v. JuliusSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-01-27· cited 13×
- Weaver v. ConeSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-03-02· cited 6×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.